A Phthalocyanine Optical Probe Responding to Cationic Surfactants Containing Long Carbon Chains with High Selectivity in Total Water Phase and Its Applications

Yan Zhang, Tao Zhou, Yabin Deng, Xiao Zheng, Jiaqi Guo, Ping Huang, Donghui LiMolecules 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel optical probe based on nickel phthalocyanine (NiS₄Pc) for the selective and sensitive detection of long-chain cationic surfactants in aqueous solutions. The probe leverages the unique spectral changes of NiS₄Pc when interacting with these surfactants, offering a fast, environmentally friendly, and accurate method for their quantification.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Cationic surfactants are widely used in various industries, from medicine to water treatment, due to their beneficial properties like antimicrobial activity. However, their potential environmental impact necessitates accurate and reliable methods for their quantitative analysis. Existing analytical techniques often suffer from limitations such as complexity, the need for organic solvents, or the inability to determine total surfactant concentrations. This paper addresses the need for a simple, selective, and environmentally friendly method for the direct quantitative analysis of long-chain cationic surfactants in aqueous environments.

Methods

The core of this research lies in the development of a phthalocyanine-based optical probe. The authors investigated four types of water-soluble tetra-sulfonated metal phthalocyanines (Fe, Co, Ni, and Zn) for their response to cationic surfactants. They found that tetra-sulfonated nickel phthalocyanine (NiS₄Pc) exhibited a particularly strong and selective spectral response. The mechanism behind this response was attributed to the influence of long-chain cationic surfactants on the self-association equilibrium of NiS₄Pc in aqueous solutions. Specifically, surfactants with carbon chains of twelve or more carbons induced distinct spectral changes, shifting the equilibrium from dimer to monomer forms.

The researchers then optimized experimental conditions, including pH, ion strength, wavelength pair selection, reaction time, temperature, and NiS₄Pc concentration, to establish a robust analytical method. They constructed calibration curves for various cationic surfactants and averaged them to create a mean calibration curve, enabling the determination of both individual and total cationic surfactants.

Datasets

The study did not utilize pre-existing datasets for training or evaluation. Instead, the researchers generated their own experimental data by conducting spectroscopic measurements of NiS₄Pc in the presence of various cationic surfactants under different conditions. They also tested the interference of several common inorganic salts and organic substances.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Structure-Activity Relationship: The study highlights a clear structure-activity relationship, where the length of the carbon chain in cationic surfactants (specifically, 12 or more carbons) is crucial for eliciting a significant spectral response from NiS₄Pc. Shorter chains do not produce the same effect.
  • Self-Association Equilibrium as a Sensing Mechanism: The core sensing mechanism is the disruption of NiS₄Pc's self-association equilibrium by structure-matched cationic surfactants. This interaction shifts the balance from dimer to monomer forms, leading to observable spectral changes.
  • NiS₄Pc as a Selective Probe: NiS₄Pc emerges as a highly selective probe, responding strongly to long-chain cationic surfactants while showing minimal response to others. This selectivity is key to its utility.
  • Simultaneous Determination of Single and Total Surfactants: The remarkable similarity in the spectral responses of different long-chain cationic surfactants allows the method to quantify either a specific surfactant or the total concentration of such surfactants.
  • Aqueous-Phase Analysis: The development of a water-soluble probe that functions effectively in a complete aqueous phase is a significant advantage, eliminating the need for organic solvents and making the method more environmentally friendly and operationally simpler.

Key Results

  • NiS₄Pc was identified as the most responsive and selective metal phthalocyanine among the tested compounds.
  • Cationic surfactants with carbon chains of 12 or more carbons induced significant spectral changes in NiS₄Pc.
  • The optimized method achieved a linear calibration curve with the equation y = 1.67 - 0.017x and a correlation coefficient (r) of 0.9987.
  • The limit of detection (LOD) for this method was determined to be 3 × 10⁻⁶ mol L⁻¹.
  • The method was successfully applied to the analysis of real samples (cetylpyridinium chloride mouthwash), yielding satisfactory results with low relative errors (within ±1%).
  • Most tested foreign substances showed acceptable interference levels (±10%), with dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide being a notable exception.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Specificity to Long Chains: While selective for long-chain cationic surfactants, the method does not differentiate between different types of long-chain cationic surfactants. The paper notes that the response is similar across various long-chain surfactants, enabling total surfactant determination. Future work could explore strategies for differentiating between specific long-chain surfactants.
  • Interference: Although most common substances showed acceptable interference, dodecyltrimethylammonium bromide exhibited a significant negative deviation. Further investigation into mitigating or accounting for such specific interferences might be beneficial.
  • Broader Application: The authors propose this study as a new strategy for developing phthalocyanine-based optical probes. Future work could extend this approach to other types of analytes by designing phthalocyanine derivatives with tailored interactions. The study also suggests exploring the application of these probes in other analytical fields.

Summary updated

Abstract

The analysis of cationic surfactants with high selectivity is a source of great research interest. In this study, the absorption spectra of tetra-sulphonated metal phthalocyanine (coordinated by iron, zinc, cobalt, and nickel) in the presence of cationic surfactants in complete aqueous solutions were investigated. Interestingly, the absorption spectra of tetra-sulphonated nickel phthalocyanine (NiS<sub>4</sub>Pc) exhibits a remarkable response to the cationic surfactants compared with other water-soluble metal phthalocyanines. Further investigation has yielded important findings that cationic surfactants with carbon chains containing twelve or more carbons cause distinct spectral responses, and the response behaviors are highly similar, showing a typical structure-activity relationship. Studies on the mechanism of response indicate that the spectral behavior could be attributed to the dramatic binding effects of structure-matched cationic surfactants on the self-association equilibrium of nickel phthalocyanine. Based on the above findings, we applied NiS<sub>4</sub>Pc as a directly responsive optical probe for the quantitative analysis of long carbon chain cationic surfactants. Due to the high degree of similarity in optical responding, this method can be used to determine the single cationic surfactant and the total cationic surfactants. It is worth mentioning that NiS<sub>4</sub>Pc is a water-soluble optical probe that can be used in a complete aqueous phase. Therefore, this method is not only selective but also easy and fast to operate, without the need for organic solvents. Under optimized conditions, the average calibration curve equation of the method is y = 1.66 - 0.0173 x, r = 0.9987, with a limit of detection of 3 × 10<sup>-6</sup> mol L<sup>-1</sup>. This method has been applied to the determination of real samples, for which we obtained satisfactory results. We not only describe the establishment of a new method for the direct quantitative analysis of cationic surfactants but also propose a new strategy for obtaining phthalocyanine-based optical probes in this study, which explored the novel application of phthalocyanine compounds in analytical sciences.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025phthalocyanine,
  author = {Yan Zhang and Tao Zhou and Yabin Deng and Xiao Zheng and Jiaqi Guo and Ping Huang and Donghui Li},
  title = {{A Phthalocyanine Optical Probe Responding to Cationic Surfactants Containing Long Carbon Chains with High Selectivity in Total Water Phase and Its Applications}},
  booktitle = {Molecules},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3390/molecules30214184},
}
Figure