A pantropical assessment of deforestation caused by industrial mining

Stefan Giljum, Victor Maus, Nikolas Kuschnig, Sebastian Luckeneder, Michael Tost, Laura J. Sonter, Anthony J. BebbingtonProceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

Industrial mining is a significant driver of tropical deforestation, with direct forest loss concentrated in a few countries but indirect impacts felt across two-thirds of tropical nations. This study provides a comprehensive pantropical assessment, highlighting the urgent need to consider both direct and indirect deforestation impacts in mining assessments and mitigation strategies to protect these vital ecosystems.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The ever-increasing global demand for minerals, fueled by rising affluence and the transition to green technologies, has led to a dramatic expansion of mining activities worldwide. Tropical forests, with their rich biodiversity and critical role in climate regulation, are particularly vulnerable to these impacts. While numerous local studies have documented the extensive and long-lasting deforestation caused by mining, a comprehensive, biome-wide understanding of this phenomenon across the tropics has been lacking. This knowledge gap hinders effective conservation efforts and the development of robust mitigation plans, as it's unclear where and how industrial mining is most significantly impacting these crucial forest ecosystems. This paper aims to fill this gap by quantifying both the direct and indirect deforestation caused by industrial mining across 26 tropical countries.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive approach to assess both direct and indirect deforestation.

  • Direct Deforestation: They quantified forest loss occurring directly within mining areas. This involved identifying and delineating mining sites and then analyzing satellite imagery to measure the extent of forest cover lost within these areas between 2000 and 2019.
  • Indirect Deforestation: To capture deforestation occurring outside of the immediate mining footprint, they developed a statistical model. This model assessed whether mining activities induced deforestation in surrounding areas by analyzing the relationship between the distance to the nearest mine and deforestation rates. Crucially, this analysis controlled for other known drivers of deforestation, such as proximity to agriculture, protected areas, and population density, to isolate the specific impact of mining.

Datasets

  • Mining Areas: Data on industrial mining extents (polygons) were derived from a previously published dataset (Maus et al., 2020), which identified 3,446 industrial mining sites based on visual interpretation of satellite imagery and data from the Standard and Poor's Metals and Mining database. These datasets covered the period from 2000 to 2019.
  • Forest Cover Change: High-resolution global maps of forest cover change from 2000 to 2019 were utilized, specifically the 1-arcsec resolution Global Forest Change dataset (Hansen et al., 2013). This dataset allowed for the measurement of forest loss within tropical biomes.
  • Control Variables: Datasets for elevation, slope, soil type, population density, proximity to protected areas, proximity to agriculture, and proximity to roads and waterways were incorporated as control variables in the statistical model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Concentrated Direct Impact, Widespread Indirect Impact: The most striking finding is the dichotomy between direct and indirect deforestation. While direct forest loss is heavily concentrated in just a few countries, the indirect effects of mining ripple much further, impacting a majority of tropical nations. This suggests that focusing solely on the immediate mine site misses a significant portion of mining's environmental footprint.
  • The "Invisible" Footprint: The indirect deforestation pathways are often less visible and harder to quantify, yet they can be substantial. This includes deforestation driven by the infrastructure required for mining (energy, transport, processing) and the subsequent population growth and land-use changes that often follow mining development.
  • Commodity-Specific Impacts Matter: The paper hints that different commodities might have varying deforestation impacts, a crucial point for future policy development. For instance, the infrastructure needs and land-use patterns associated with coal mining might differ significantly from those of bauxite or gold extraction.
  • Governance and Policy Gaps: The study implicitly points to significant governance and policy challenges, particularly in countries like Indonesia and Brazil, where institutional factors have influenced the pace of deforestation. The "often unmanaged impacts" mentioned in the abstract underscore the need for stronger regulatory frameworks.

Key Results

  • Direct Deforestation: Between 2000 and 2019, industrial mining directly caused the loss of 3,264 km² of tropical forest.
  • Top Countries for Direct Loss: * Indonesia: 1,901 km² (58.2% of total direct loss) * Brazil: 327 km² (10%) * Ghana: 213 km² (6.5%) * Suriname: 203 km² (6.2%)
    • These four countries accounted for 80% of all direct tropical forest loss due to industrial mining.
  • Indirect Deforestation: Industrial mining was found to drive indirect deforestation in 18 out of the 26 investigated countries (two-thirds of the total).
  • In Brazil, a 10% increase in proximity to a mine was associated with a 3% average increase in deforestation.
  • In Indonesia, the same 10% increase in proximity to a mine was linked to a 2.3% average increase in deforestation.
  • Countries like Suriname and Guyana showed a high share of their total deforestation attributed to mining, even if the absolute area was smaller.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Focus on Industrial Mining: The study primarily focused on industrial mining and only conceptually included artisanal and small-scale mining (ASM) as a potential indirect effect. Comprehensive quantification of ASM's direct impact remains a challenge due to data limitations.
  • Exclusion of Key Countries: Important tropical mining countries like Peru and Bolivia were excluded due to a lack of industrial mines within tropical forests and insufficient ASM data.
  • Commodity Specificity: The study did not differentiate deforestation impacts based on the type of commodity extracted. Future work should explore how different mining types (e.g., open-pit vs. underground) and commodities influence deforestation patterns.
  • Temporal Dynamics of Indirect Effects: While the study identified the presence of indirect deforestation, further research is needed to quantify the actual areas deforested indirectly and to disentangle the specific causal pathways and their magnitudes.
  • Mine Rehabilitation: The role of mine rehabilitation and reforestation efforts in mitigating impacts was not assessed and should be considered in future geospatial assessments.
  • Data Granularity: More detailed data that allows for time-tagging of key variables (e.g., mine start dates, infrastructure project timelines) is needed for deeper insights into country-specific variations.
  • Cross-Country Drivers: The current country-by-country analysis might miss important cross-border deforestation drivers.

Future work should also focus on developing better monitoring systems for both industrial mining and ASM, potentially leveraging satellite data and platforms like Delve, to improve transparency and accountability along global supply chains.

Summary updated

Abstract

Growing demand for minerals continues to drive deforestation worldwide. Tropical forests are particularly vulnerable to the environmental impacts of mining and mineral processing. Many local- to regional-scale studies document extensive, long-lasting impacts of mining on biodiversity and ecosystem services. However, the full scope of deforestation induced by industrial mining across the tropics is yet unknown. Here, we present a biome-wide assessment to show where industrial mine expansion has caused the most deforestation from 2000 to 2019. We find that 3,264 km2 of forest was directly lost due to industrial mining, with 80% occurring in only four countries: Indonesia, Brazil, Ghana, and Suriname. Additionally, controlling for other nonmining determinants of deforestation, we find that mining caused indirect forest loss in two-thirds of the investigated countries. Our results illustrate significant yet unevenly distributed and often unmanaged impacts on these biodiverse ecosystems. Impact assessments and mitigation plans of industrial mining activities must address direct and indirect impacts to support conservation of the world’s tropical forests.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{giljum2022pantropical,
  author = {Stefan Giljum and Victor Maus and Nikolas Kuschnig and Sebastian Luckeneder and Michael Tost and Laura J. Sonter and Anthony J. Bebbington},
  title = {{A pantropical assessment of deforestation caused by industrial mining}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=Etl39knEl0},
}
Figure