A numerical scheme for moving bottlenecks in traffic flow

Maria Laura Delle Monache, Paola GoatinBulletin 2016 · DOI

Introduction

In macroscopic traffic modeling, traffic is typically treated as a fluid governed by conservation laws, such as the Lighthill-Whitham-Richards (LWR) model. However, the introduction of large, slow-moving vehicles like buses creates "moving bottlenecks" that significantly complicate the mathematical landscape. These vehicles locally reduce road capacity and move at speeds influenced by the surrounding traffic density. This paper introduces a novel numerical framework designed to capture the complex, "non-classical" shock waves created by these interactions.

The PDE-ODE Coupling Framework

The authors employ a strongly coupled PDE-ODE system to model this behavior. A scalar conservation law describes the evolution of car density ($\rho$), while a series of ordinary differential equations track the trajectories ($y_i$) of $N$ buses. The coupling is bidirectional: the bus speed depends on the local traffic density, and the traffic flux is subject to an inequality constraint at the bus's location, representing the reduced road capacity.

Flux constraints in fixed and moving reference frames.

As illustrated in the figure above, the flux $f(\rho)$ is constrained by the presence of the bus. In the fixed reference frame (a), the constraint limits the maximum allowable flux at the bus position. In the bus's reference frame (b), the relative flux $f(\rho) - V_b\rho$ is bounded by a value $F_\alpha$, representing the reduced capacity of the road segment occupied by the bus.

Numerical Innovation: In-Cell Reconstruction

Standard numerical solvers often smear discontinuities (shocks) over several grid cells. To maintain sharp profiles for the non-classical shocks produced by moving bottlenecks, the authors implement a conservative finite volume scheme with in-cell reconstruction. Instead of averaging values across a grid cell, the algorithm "reconstructs" the exact position of the shock within the cell. This involves precise shock tracking of the bus trajectory and splitting affected cells into two states based on the flux constraint. This approach allows the model to capture interactions on a fixed mesh with minimal numerical diffusion.

Key Insights: Density-Dependent Dynamics

A critical feature of the model is the realistic treatment of bus speed. Buses do not move at a constant velocity; they adapt to the surrounding traffic conditions.

Bus speed vs. traffic density.

The figure above demonstrates that a bus maintains its maximum speed $V_b$ in free-flow traffic (where density $\rho < \rho^*$). However, as traffic becomes more congested and density increases beyond $\rho^*$, the bus slows down to match the speed of the surrounding cars $v(\rho)$. This transition is essential for modeling how buses create queues and trigger "stop-and-go" waves.

Results and Future Work

The proposed scheme was validated through numerical tests, including scenarios where multiple buses transition a system from free-flow to congested regimes and cases where two buses merge to act as a single larger bottleneck. While the current model assumes uniform maximal bus speeds and no overtaking, it provides a robust foundation for future extensions. Incorporating heterogeneous vehicle speeds and overtaking maneuvers remains a key direction for making the model applicable to more diverse urban transit scenarios.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{monache2016numerical,
  author = {Maria Laura Delle Monache and Paola Goatin},
  title = {{A numerical scheme for moving bottlenecks in traffic flow}},
  journal = {Bulletin},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.1007/s00574-016-0172-8},
}
Figure