A Numerical Investigation on the Flooding Process of Multiple Compartments Based on the Volume of Fluid Method

XinLong Zhang, Zhuang Lin, Simone Mancini, Ping Li, Ze Li, Fei LiuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper uses advanced CFD simulations to model the complex process of water flooding into damaged ship compartments. By accurately capturing air-water interfaces and the effects of air compression, the study provides crucial insights into ship survivability and informs better rescue and evacuation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Ship accidents, unfortunately, remain a reality. When a ship is damaged, water ingress into its compartments is a critical factor determining its survivability. This flooding process is highly dynamic and complex, involving distinct stages: transient, progressive, and steady. Understanding these dynamics is paramount for developing effective life-saving measures and evacuation procedures. While experimental methods can provide valuable data, they are often costly and limited in their ability to explore numerous damage scenarios. Numerical simulations offer a more flexible and economical alternative, but accurately modeling the intricate fluid behavior, especially the interaction of water and trapped air, remains a significant challenge. This paper aims to address this by providing a detailed numerical investigation of multi-compartment flooding, focusing on the impact of air compression and its implications for ship safety.

Methods

The researchers employed the commercial Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) software STAR-CCM+ to simulate the flooding process. The core of their simulation approach relies on the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) solver for fluid dynamics. To accurately capture the interface between water and air, they utilized the Volume of Fluid (VOF) method. A key innovation presented in this paper is the development of a user-defined field function (UDFF). This function is crucial for precisely defining the initial distribution of the free surface within the damaged compartments, particularly when dealing with complex geometries or specific initial conditions where simply setting a water level isn't sufficient. They also implemented the Realizable k-ε turbulence model to account for the turbulent nature of the fluid flow. For the numerical setup, they used a second-order temporal discretization scheme and a second-order upwind scheme for the convection term, aiming for a balance between accuracy and computational cost. The damaged ship was modeled as stationary in a 6-DOF solver to simplify the analysis of flooding dynamics.

Datasets

The study utilizes the DTMB Model 5415, a well-known benchmark US Navy Destroyer hull, scaled down by a factor of 1/25. The internal compartment arrangement of this model is based on a previously described layout. The paper does not introduce new datasets but rather uses this established model for its simulations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Air Compression is a Major Factor: The simulations clearly demonstrate that trapped air within damaged compartments significantly impedes the flooding process. Restricted ventilation leads to air compression, which in turn reduces the amount of water entering the compartment and slows down the overall flooding rate. This is a critical finding for understanding ship stability and survivability.
  • Transient Stage is Violent and Complex: The initial flooding phase (transient stage) is characterized by rapid water ingress, significant jetting, splashing, and complex fluid-structure interactions. These phenomena, though short-lived, can have a substantial impact on ship stability.
  • Flooding Sequence and Time are Crucial for Safety: The paper highlights that the timing and sequence of flooding across multiple compartments are vital for effective rescue management and evacuation planning. Knowing when specific compartments will flood allows for proactive measures like blocking internal openings or establishing safe evacuation routes.
  • Damage Location Matters: Different damage locations (amidship, bow, stern) result in distinct flooding patterns and dynamics, influenced by hydrostatic pressure, gravity, and the geometry of the compartments and openings.
  • CFD as a Powerful Tool: The study validates the utility of advanced CFD techniques, particularly the VOF method with UDFF, for simulating complex flooding scenarios that are difficult and expensive to replicate experimentally.

Key Results

The simulations successfully captured various hydrodynamic phenomena during flooding, including:

  • Transient Stage: Jetting, splashing, liquid tumbling, and bubble formation due to gas-liquid interaction.
  • Air Cushioning: In scenarios with restricted ventilation, an "air cushion" was observed, significantly limiting the water level rise in damaged compartments. For example, in the amidship damage case, the final water height was lower than the external sea level due to this effect.
  • Flooding Times: The study provided specific flooding times for different damage scenarios. For instance, in the bow damage case, the second and third compartments began flooding at 2.9 s and 7 s, respectively, with a total flooding time of 34.7 s. For the stern damage, the total flooding time was approximately 30 s (on the scale model). These times are crucial for decision-making in emergency situations.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Experimental Validation Needed: The current study relies solely on numerical results. Future work should involve model tests to validate the simulation results and enhance confidence in the predictions.
  • Simplified Model: The simulations assumed empty compartments and did not account for the presence of cargo, equipment, or other internal structures that could affect compartment permeability and flooding dynamics.
  • Stationary Ship Assumption: The damaged ship was modeled as stationary. Future research should investigate the effect of coupled ship motion (heave, roll, pitch, etc.) on the flooding process.
  • Environmental Conditions: The simulations were performed in calm water. Incorporating external factors like waves and ship forward speed would provide a more realistic representation of real-world scenarios.
  • Computational Cost: The authors note the significant time consumption of CFD simulations for flooding. Future work should focus on developing methods to balance solution accuracy with computational efficiency, potentially through advanced meshing strategies or faster solvers.
  • Real-time Prediction and Data Fusion: Developing systems for fast prediction of flooding results and integrating this data with onboard decision support systems for real-time rescue and evacuation guidance is identified as a future challenge.

Summary updated

Abstract

A detailed description of the flooding process is crucial to analyze the complex hydrodynamic behaviors and enhance the survivability of the damaged ship. In this paper, through establishing three typical damage scenarios with various locations, the commercial software CD Adapco STAR-CCM+ based on the Reynolds-Averaged Navier-Stokes (RANS) solver is applied to simulate the flooding process involving multiple compartments. The basic computational fluid dynamics (CFD) models and specific simulation settings are elaborated. The volume of fluid (VOF) method combined with the user defined field function is developed to distribute the initial free surface. The captured flooding process indicates that the air compression due to the restricted ventilation decreases the flooding amount. The obtained flooding time can provide necessary data to support for appropriate rescue management and evacuation options.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2019numerical,
  author = {XinLong Zhang and Zhuang Lin and Simone Mancini and Ping Li and Ze Li and Fei Liu},
  title = {{A Numerical Investigation on the Flooding Process of Multiple Compartments Based on the Volume of Fluid Method}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse7070211},
}
Figure