A Novel Ultrasonic Method for Liquid Level Measurement Based on the Balance of Echo Energy

Bin Zhang, Yue-Juan Wei, Wen-Yi Liu, Yan-Jun Zhang, Zong Yao, Liang Zhang, Jijun Xiong2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, non-contact ultrasonic method for measuring liquid levels in sealed containers by analyzing the balance of echo energy received by two sensors. This approach offers improved accuracy and reliability, particularly in challenging coupling conditions, by focusing on the ratio of echo energies rather than their absolute values.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate and reliable liquid level monitoring is crucial in many industrial sectors, including petroleum, chemical, and aerospace. Traditional methods often require direct contact with the liquid or invasive installation within the container, posing significant risks in environments with high temperatures, pressures, flammability, corrosiveness, or volatility. These conditions can lead to leaks, making maintenance difficult and costly. While non-contact methods like ultrasound have emerged, they often face challenges with sensor-to-container wall coupling, which can significantly impact measurement accuracy and stability. This paper aims to address these coupling issues by proposing a method that is less sensitive to variations in coupling quality.

Methods

The core of this novel method lies in using a single ultrasonic transmitter (S₀) and two receiving sensors (S₁ and S₂) arranged symmetrically on the container's outer wall. The key innovation is the principle of "balance of echo energy." When the ultrasonic beam is transmitted, it reflects off the inner surface of the container. The difference in ultrasonic impedance between the gas and liquid media causes different reflection and transmission characteristics. As the transmitter moves along the container wall, the balance of echo energy received by S₁ and S₂ is disrupted when the beam approaches the liquid level. By analyzing the ratio of the echo energies received by S₁ and S₂, the liquid level can be determined.

The method involves:

  • Sensor Arrangement: Three round plate ultrasonic sensors are encapsulated in a coupling plane and arranged according to specific rules (d₁ = 0 or d₁ = r₁ + r₂, and 2r₂ ≤ d₂ ≤ (4r₁ + 2r₂)).
  • Acoustic Modeling: An acoustic model is established to calculate echo energy, considering the propagation and attenuation of ultrasonic waves in the container wall. This model utilizes the Kirchhoff integral theorem and a Multi-Gaussian Beam Model to simulate the sound field.
  • Echo Energy Calculation: The echo energy received by each sensor is calculated by integrating the sound pressure over the projected energy circle on the inner surface of the container. The difference and ratio of these energies are then analyzed.
  • Experimental Validation: The method is tested under various coupling conditions (good and bad) and sensor arrangements to evaluate its accuracy, reliability, and stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The experiments were conducted using an aluminum container with water as the liquid medium and air as the gaseous medium.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Focus on Ratio, Not Magnitude: The method's strength lies in analyzing the ratio of echo energies received by the two sensors, rather than their absolute magnitudes. This makes it inherently more robust to variations in coupling quality.
  • Symmetry is Key: The symmetrical arrangement of the receiving sensors around the transmitter is crucial for establishing a baseline "balance" of echo energy when away from the liquid level.
  • Liquid Level as a Disruption: The liquid level acts as a distinct acoustic boundary that disrupts this energy balance, providing the signal for detection.
  • Reduced Coupling Sensitivity: The experimental results demonstrate that the ratio of echo energies remains relatively stable even under poor coupling conditions, a significant advantage over traditional methods.

Key Results

  • The proposed method demonstrated good accuracy, with measurement errors around 1 mm in optimal configurations, outperforming some existing literature methods.
  • Under good coupling conditions, both sensors' received echo energy increased with the change in liquid level (Ad). However, the ratio of the echo energies remained relatively stable, even under bad coupling conditions, highlighting the method's robustness.
  • The sensor arrangement significantly impacts accuracy. For the d₁ = 0 arrangement, accuracy was optimal when the distance d₂ between sensors was minimized (4r). For the d₁ = 2r arrangement, optimal accuracy was achieved at d₂ = 3r.
  • The method is effective and non-destructive, offering higher detection accuracy, reliability, and stability compared to previously developed methods.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Impedance Difference: The method relies on a sufficient difference in ultrasonic impedance between the gas and liquid media. If this difference is too small, the echo energies might be too similar, making measurement impossible.
  • Container Wall Thickness: The thickness of the container wall affects the echo energy received, potentially reducing measurement resolution. The authors suggest that increasing the incident frequency or the size of the transmitting sensor could improve accuracy in cases of thicker walls.
  • Optimal Sensor Combination: The paper suggests that in actual detection scenarios, the optimal sensor arrangement can be combined based on the specific detection environment and initial conditions. Further research could explore a wider range of sensor arrangements and materials.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{zhang2017novel,
  author = {Bin Zhang and Yue-Juan Wei and Wen-Yi Liu and Yan-Jun Zhang and Zong Yao and Liang Zhang and Jijun Xiong},
  title = {{A Novel Ultrasonic Method for Liquid Level Measurement Based on the Balance of Echo Energy}},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.3390/s17040706},
}

Loading related content...

Figure