A Novel Strength Model for Cement Marine Clay Based on the Mechanical-Chemical Coupling Behavior

Liyang Xu, Zihai Yan, Jiajia Yan, Qiliang Xu, Jiancai Zhu, Riqing XuJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel strength model for cement-stabilized marine clay that explicitly accounts for the complex mechanical-chemical (MC) interactions during cement hydration. By focusing on porosity as a key indicator of these interactions, the model offers a more accurate prediction of unconfined compressive strength (UCS) compared to existing methods, paving the way for better engineering designs in coastal and offshore environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Marine clays, common in coastal and offshore areas, are notoriously weak, highly compressible, and prone to excessive settlement, making them unsuitable for many engineering applications. Cement stabilization is a widely adopted solution, but the underlying mechanisms that govern the strength development in these materials are complex. Specifically, the interplay between the physical (mechanical) and chemical processes during cement hydration, known as mechanical-chemical (MC) coupling, significantly influences the clay's strength. However, existing strength models often overlook or inadequately represent these crucial MC interactions, leading to less accurate predictions. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a theoretical model that directly incorporates the MC coupling behavior, using porosity as a central parameter to capture its influence.

Methods

The researchers developed a novel strength model, termed the "MC model," which is built upon the principles of mechanical-chemical coupling. The core idea is that the cement hydration process alters the clay's microstructure, which can be effectively characterized by changes in porosity.

  1. Mechanism Analysis: The study began by analyzing the cement hydration process and its impact on the microstructure of cement marine clay, using Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) images. This analysis highlighted how the formation of hydration products like CSH (Calcium Silicate Hydrate) and CH (Calcium Hydroxide) alters particle arrangements and pore spaces.
  2. Porosity as a Key Parameter: Porosity was identified as the primary factor to quantify the influence of MC interactions on the overall strength. The model posits that changes in porosity, driven by hydration products, water consumption, and inter-particle forces, directly affect the clay's mechanical properties.
  3. MC Model Formulation:
    • Elastic Behavior: Hooke's Law is used, with the Young's modulus ($E$) expressed as an exponential function of porosity ($n$).
  4. Yield Function: The Drucker-Prager yield function is employed, assuming elastoplastic behavior. The cohesion force ($c$) and friction angle ($\phi$) are modeled as evolving functions of porosity.
  5. Experimental Validation:
    • UCS Tests: Unconfined Compressive Strength (UCS) tests were conducted on cement marine clay samples with varying cement contents and curing times.
  6. COMSOL Simulation: A numerical model of the UCS test was built using COMSOL Multiphysics® to simulate the behavior of the cement marine clay based on the proposed MC model.
  7. Comparison and Sensitivity Analysis: The MC model's predictions were compared against experimental data and results from three existing strength models. A sensitivity analysis was performed to understand the influence of the model's parameters ($E$, $c$, and $\phi$) on the stress-strain behavior.

Datasets

The study utilized a specific type of marine clay sourced from the Taizhou coastal industrial zone in China. This clay was mixed with Ordinary Portland Cement (OPC) to create cemented marine clay samples. The physical properties of the original Taizhou clay, including water content, unit weight, specific gravity, porosity, liquid limit, and plastic limit, are provided in Table 1. The experimental data for UCS tests, with varying cement slurry content, water-cement ratio, and curing ages, form the basis for validation. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing experimental data were used to validate the proposed model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Porosity as a Unified Indicator: The paper successfully demonstrates that porosity can serve as a single, unifying parameter to capture the complex mechanical-chemical interactions during cement hydration in marine clay. This simplifies the modeling process significantly.
  • MC Coupling is Crucial: The study strongly emphasizes that neglecting the mechanical-chemical coupling during cement hydration leads to inaccurate strength predictions for stabilized marine clays.
  • Evolving Mechanical Properties: The model effectively captures how the elastic modulus, cohesion, and friction angle of the cement marine clay evolve with changes in porosity, reflecting the ongoing hydration and microstructural development.
  • Simplicity and Efficacy: The proposed MC model is relatively simple, relying on porosity as its primary input, yet it shows high efficacy in predicting UCS strength.

Key Results

  • The UCS strength of the cemented Taizhou clay ranged from 10.21 kPa to 354.2 kPa as cement content increased from 10% to 20% and curing time varied from 3 to 28 days.
  • The proposed MC model showed a reasonably good agreement between simulated and experimentally observed UCS strength data.
  • When compared to three existing strength models, the MC model demonstrated the best correspondence with measured UCS values, with average normalized discrepancies of 3% for the MC model, compared to 79% and 8% for the other models.
  • The sensitivity analysis revealed that the elastic stage of the stress-strain curve is primarily controlled by the elastic modulus ($E$), while the plastic stage is governed by cohesion ($c$) and friction angle ($\phi$).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Softening Behavior: The authors acknowledge that the proposed MC model is a perfect elastic-plastic model and cannot capture the strain-softening behavior observed in some of the experimental results, particularly at longer curing times.
  • Parameter Identification: While the model is simple, obtaining the fitting curve parameters ($a_E, b_E, a_c, b_c, a_\phi, b_\phi$) for the relationships between mechanical properties and porosity requires experimental data and curve fitting. The R² values for these fits, while good (0.9151 for $E$, 0.9064 for $c$, and 0.8688 for $\phi$), indicate some variability, especially for the friction angle.
  • Future Work: The paper suggests that future research could focus on extending the model to incorporate the strain-softening behavior and exploring the influence of other factors like temperature and chemical environments on the MC coupling. Further validation with a wider range of marine clay types and experimental conditions would also be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Crucial mechanical-chemical (MC) interactions occur during the cement hydration process in cement marine clay; however, the role of such an important element of the resulting strength has been subject to less investigation, particularly from the theoretical perspective. To overcome this scientific gap, an efficient strength-based model accounting for the coupled MC processes is proposed here. Based on the analysis of the cement hydration mechanism, the porosity was chosen as the main factor to characterize the influence of the MC interactions on the overall response. To verify the accuracy of the MC model, the unconfined compressive strength (UCS) experiment was conducted for the cement marine clay samples, and the corresponding simulation model was constructed using COMSOL multiphysics®. In addition, a comparison between the predicted results by the existing three strength models and the proposed MC model was performed. Subsequently, the sensitivity analysis and identification of mechanical parameters were carefully carried out. The obtained results show that the UCS strength for Taizhou clay ranges from 10.21 kPa to 354.2 kPa as the cement content increases from 10% to 20%, and the curing time varies from 3 days to 28 days. The mechanical parameters in the MC model can be obtained according to the porosity level. A reasonably good agreement between the UCS strength results of simulations and the experimentally observed data is reported. Additionally, the predicted UCS strength results by the MC model demonstrate the best correspondence with the measured values, indicating the high efficacy of the established model.
BibTeX
@article{xu2021novel,
  author = {Liyang Xu and Zihai Yan and Jiajia Yan and Qiliang Xu and Jiancai Zhu and Riqing Xu},
  title = {{A Novel Strength Model for Cement Marine Clay Based on the Mechanical-Chemical Coupling Behavior}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse9121454},
}
Figure