A Novel Strategy for Improving the Aeromagnetic Compensation Performance of Helicopters

Luzhao Chen, Peilin Wu, Wanhua Zhu, Yongqiang Feng, Guangyou FangSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel strategy using two optically pumped magnetometers (OPMs) on a helicopter to improve aeromagnetic compensation. By employing a reference magnetometer and a coherent noise suppression (CNS) method, they significantly reduce residual magnetic interference, enhancing the accuracy of geophysical surveys.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Aeromagnetic surveys are crucial for geophysical prospecting, but the magnetic field measurements made by aircraft-mounted magnetometers are heavily influenced by the aircraft's own magnetic fields. Traditional compensation methods address permanent, induced, and eddy current magnetic fields. However, they often overlook interference from avionics systems and the relative motion between the aircraft and the sensors. This residual interference degrades the accuracy of the measurements, making it difficult to detect subtle magnetic signals. The paper aims to tackle this by proposing a method to suppress these additional interference sources.

Methods

The core of the proposed strategy involves using two OPMs: one as a sensing magnetometer (OPM-I) and another as a reference magnetometer (OPM-II). OPM-I is placed further from the helicopter's main body, while OPM-II is closer, acting as a reference to capture more of the platform's interference.

  1. Traditional Compensation: The paper starts by outlining the classical Tolles-Lawson model, which accounts for permanent, induced, and eddy current magnetic fields. This involves using attitude data (direction cosines) to model and remove these interference components. They also discuss the use of ridge regression (RR) analysis to handle multi-collinearity in the model.
  2. Coherent Noise Suppression (CNS): After traditional compensation, residual interference remains. The novel part of this paper is the application of a CNS method. This method leverages the high spatial coherence of the interference field between the two OPMs.
  3. The signals from both OPMs are processed (band-pass filtered, FFT).
  4. The mutual power spectrum and auto-spectra are calculated in the frequency domain.
  5. A transfer function, $H(\omega)$, is derived to represent the relationship between the interference fields captured by the two magnetometers.
  6. This transfer function is then used to suppress the residual interference in the sensing magnetometer's signal by applying an inverse Fourier transform.

Datasets

The study uses data collected from a helicopter equipped with two OPMs and a fluxgate magnetometer for attitude measurement. The data was collected during:

  • Calibration Flights: These flights involved maneuvering the helicopter in specific patterns (e.g., a "calibration box") to capture the aircraft's magnetic interference characteristics.
  • Test Flights: These flights were conducted to evaluate the performance of the compensation and CNS methods.
  • Magnetic Anomaly Detection Experiment: A controlled experiment was set up with a square closed coil generating a known magnetic anomaly signal. This allowed for testing the method's ability to detect and preserve a target signal while suppressing interference.

The paper does not introduce new benchmark datasets but utilizes real-world flight data for validation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Dual OPMs for Interference Capture: Using two OPMs, one closer and one further from the aircraft, is a clever way to differentially capture the platform's magnetic signature. The closer sensor acts as a proxy for the stronger interference.
  • Coherence is Key: The CNS method relies on the assumption that the interference fields measured by the two OPMs are highly correlated (coherent). This coherence allows for the estimation of a transfer function that can be used to "subtract" the interference.
  • Frequency Domain Analysis: Transforming the data into the frequency domain (using FFT) is crucial for calculating power spectra and the transfer function, enabling effective noise cancellation.
  • Beyond Traditional Models: The paper highlights that even after accounting for permanent, induced, and eddy currents, significant residual interference remains, necessitating more advanced techniques like CNS.
  • Improved Signal-to-Noise Ratio: The ultimate goal is to improve the signal-to-noise ratio, allowing for the detection of weaker magnetic anomalies that would otherwise be masked by aircraft noise.

Key Results

  • Standard Deviation Reduction: The novel strategy, combining traditional compensation with CNS, reduced the standard deviation of the residual interference field from approximately 0.065 nT to 0.045 nT.
  • Improvement Ratio (IR): The CNS method improved the compensation performance by about 30% compared to the traditional method alone.
  • Magnetic Anomaly Detection: In a controlled experiment, the CNS method successfully suppressed interference while preserving the magnetic anomaly signal, making it smoother and more discernible. The standard deviation for the interference field was reduced from 0.0555 nT to 0.0390 nT, and the peak-to-peak value was reduced from 0.297 nT to 0.184 nT for the test line-1.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Uncorrelated Interference: The CNS method is most effective for highly correlated interference. The paper acknowledges that some residual interference remains, likely due to poorly correlated components or uncorrelated interference between the two OPMs.
  • System Optimization: The authors suggest future work to optimize the system by:
  • Increasing the number of reference magnetometers.
  • Optimizing the placement of reference sensors to further increase the correlation of interference fields.
  • Broader Applicability: The authors believe the method could be applied to other frequency bands, such as extremely low frequency (ELF) signals, for performance improvement.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{chen2018novel,
  author = {Luzhao Chen and Peilin Wu and Wanhua Zhu and Yongqiang Feng and Guangyou Fang},
  title = {{A Novel Strategy for Improving the Aeromagnetic Compensation Performance of Helicopters}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18061846},
}
Figure