A Novel Steganography-Based Pattern for Print Matter Anti-Counterfeiting by Smartphone Cameras

Hong Zheng, Chengzhuo Zhou, Xi Li, Zhongyuan Guo, Tianyu WangSensors 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel steganography-based pattern for anti-counterfeiting print materials, designed to be verifiable using standard smartphone cameras. The method embeds authentication information within a pattern that is robust to legitimate capture but fragile to illicit copying, effectively distinguishing original prints from fakes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The proliferation of counterfeit goods is a significant global economic issue, with fake products impacting various sectors. While anti-counterfeiting technologies exist, many suffer from high costs, poor user experience, or insufficient security, failing to prevent counterfeiting before a product reaches the consumer. Traditional printed identifiers like QR codes, while useful for traceability, are easily replicated due to their open nature and high-resolution digital reproduction capabilities. This makes it difficult to distinguish an original printed QR code from a copy. The paper aims to address this by developing a print-based anti-counterfeiting solution that is both secure and accessible via common devices like smartphones.

Methods

The proposed method employs a multi-stage process combining steganography, encryption, and scrambling techniques:

  1. First-Level Block Expansion: Each pixel of an original binary message image (e.g., a QR code) is replaced by a block of pixels of the same binary gray value (0 or 255). This expands the image size.
  2. Image Encryption and Scrambling: The expanded image is then encrypted using a logistic chaotic sequence, with the sequence parameters acting as secret keys. Following encryption, the image is scrambled using Arnold's cat transform for a specified number of rounds.
  3. Second-Level Block Expansion: The scrambled image undergoes a second block expansion. Here, each pixel is replaced by a square block whose size and gray value can be adjusted. Crucially, the gray value of these blocks can differ from the original binary pixel's value, allowing for control over the pattern's semi-fragile nature. This means the pattern is designed to degrade in a specific way when subjected to illegal copying processes, making the embedded information unrecoverable or corrupted.

The authentication process involves reversing these steps. If the extracted message (e.g., a QR code) is complete and decodable after the inverse operations, the pattern is deemed original. Otherwise, it's flagged as a copy.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on generating and testing synthetic patterns based on standard QR codes.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Smartphone Accessibility is Key: The core innovation is designing an anti-counterfeiting pattern that works with ubiquitous smartphone cameras, bypassing the need for specialized scanners.
  • Semi-Fragility as a Security Feature: The pattern's design intentionally makes it robust to legitimate capture (e.g., a clear photo of the original print) but fragile to illegitimate copying processes (e.g., scanning and reprinting). This differential behavior is the foundation of its anti-counterfeiting capability.
  • Hierarchical Block Expansion: Using two levels of block expansion allows for fine-tuning the trade-off between robustness to legitimate capture and fragility to copying. The second level, in particular, offers control over the semi-fragile property.
  • Chaotic Encryption for Confidentiality: The use of logistic chaotic maps provides a strong layer of encryption, ensuring that the embedded information is not easily deciphered without the correct keys, even if the pattern itself is captured.
  • Arnold Transform for Spatial Scattering: Arnold's cat transform helps to distribute the impact of local attacks across the entire image, enhancing robustness.

Key Results

  • Effective Discrimination: The proposed pattern successfully distinguished between original prints and copied versions in experimental tests.
  • Robustness to Legitimate Capture: The method demonstrated good recognition rates for patterns captured under normal conditions (e.g., smartphone photography), with optimal combinations achieving near 100% recognition.
  • Fragility to Forgery: For direct copy and HD photographing/printing forgeries, recognition rates dropped significantly, often to 0%, especially for less optimal parameter settings. Combinations with large block sizes and distinct gray values (0 and 255) showed slightly better (though still low) recognition for forged patterns.
  • Resilience to Defacing and Blurring: The pattern showed reasonable resilience to defacing (up to 50% of the region) and some degree of blurring, though performance degraded with increased blur.
  • Compact Physical Size: The optimal combination resulted in a printed pattern size of approximately 0.66 cm x 0.66 cm at 600 dpi, which is smaller than comparable methods like two-level QR codes or LCAC 2D barcodes, leading to lower printing costs and better aesthetic integration.
  • Runtime: The decryption process was found to be primarily dominated by Arnold unscrambling and logistic decryption, with average runtimes for different pattern sizes ranging from approximately 12 ms to 32 ms.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Robustness to Blur: The paper acknowledges that the pattern's robustness to motion blur and defocus blur, common in smartphone photography, is limited. Correct decoding requires a clear captured image.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest future research should focus on developing methods to find and utilize anti-blur features within the image to enable correct evaluation of blurred patterns and improve recognition rates. They also note that while the proposed pattern is fragile to secondary printing, it can be obtained via smartphone camera for anti-counterfeiting discrimination.

Summary updated

Abstract

Print matter authentication based on anti-counterfeiting techniques has received continuously increasing concern from academia and industry. However, the existing printing anti-counterfeiting solutions often have the defects of poor identification experience, high cost, or weak anti-counterfeiting ability, and cannot achieve pre-sale anti-counterfeiting. Therefore, a novel steganography-based pattern for print matter anti-counterfeiting by smartphone cameras is proposed in this study. Firstly, every pixel in the original binary message image (such as QR code) is replaced by a square pixel block with the same binary gray value of 0 or 255 (the first-level expansion). Secondly, the obtained image is encrypted based on the logistic chaotic sequence, and then scrambled by Arnold transform. Lastly, once again every pixel in the generated image is replaced with a square pixel block (the second-level expansion), the size and gray value of which can be set to control the semi-fragile ability to distinguish an originally printed pattern from its illegitimate copy. If the message extracted from the printed pattern through the inverse procedure is complete enough to decode and read, the pattern is assumed to be an original print. Experimental results verify the advancement and effectiveness of the proposed scheme in distinguishing the copied pattern.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zheng2022novel,
  author = {Hong Zheng and Chengzhuo Zhou and Xi Li and Zhongyuan Guo and Tianyu Wang},
  title = {{A Novel Steganography-Based Pattern for Print Matter Anti-Counterfeiting by Smartphone Cameras}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3390/s22093394},
}
Figure