A Novel Single-Axis MEMS Tilt Sensor with a High Sensitivity in the Measurement Range from 0∘ to 360∘

Shudong Wang, Xueyong Wei, Yinsheng Weng, Yulong Zhao, Zhuangde JiangSensors 2018 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel single-axis MEMS tilt sensor that achieves high sensitivity across a full 0° to 360° measurement range. This is accomplished using a unique design featuring a hexagonal proof mass, micro-lever force amplifiers, and three double-ended-tuning fork (DETF) resonators, overcoming limitations of previous designs that offered high sensitivity only over smaller angular ranges.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Accurate tilt measurement is crucial for a wide array of applications, from structural health monitoring and inertial navigation to industrial automation. While MEMS (Micro-Electro-Mechanical Systems) technology has enabled smaller, more affordable sensors, achieving high sensitivity across a broad measurement range has remained a significant challenge. Traditional MEMS tilt sensors often rely on the principle that gravity's acceleration component changes with tilt angle, leading to a physical response (like capacitance or frequency shift). However, this response is typically sinusoidal, meaning sensitivity varies with angle, and high sensitivity is usually confined to a limited range (e.g., ±30°). Extending this high-sensitivity range to a full 360° without compromising performance is a key problem this paper tackles.

Methods

The core innovation lies in the sensor's design and sensing principle. The sensor utilizes a hexagonal proof mass at its center, surrounded by six micro-lever force amplifiers and three Double-Ended-Tuning Fork (DETF) resonant strain gauges arranged radially at 120° intervals. When the sensor tilts, the gravity acting on the proof mass is amplified by the micro-levers and applied as axial force to the DETFs. This force tunes the resonant frequency of the DETFs. By analyzing the frequency shifts of these DETFs, the tilt angle can be determined.

The paper details the use of finite element analysis (FEA) to optimize the sensor's structure and dimensions. For characterization, both open-loop and closed-loop tests were performed. In the open-loop test, the frequency response of the DETFs was directly measured as the sensor was tilted. The closed-loop test involved building a self-oscillation circuit for the DETF resonators, allowing for real-time frequency measurement and feedback control. To handle noise and improve stability, a Kalman Filter (KF) was employed, and Allan deviation analysis was used to assess frequency stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design, fabrication, and experimental characterization of a single sensor prototype.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging the Range-Sensitivity Gap: The primary insight is the successful integration of a broad 360° measurement range with high sensitivity. This is achieved by strategically arranging multiple sensing elements (DETFs) and using force amplification mechanisms.
  • DETF Resonance Tuning for Tilt: The paper demonstrates the effectiveness of using the frequency shift of DETF resonators as a robust and sensitive indicator of gravitational acceleration components, which directly correlate to tilt angle.
  • Micro-Lever Amplification: The inclusion of micro-lever force amplifiers is critical for magnifying the small inertial forces from gravity, thereby increasing the sensitivity of the DETF resonators.
  • Kalman Filtering for Stability: The application of a Kalman Filter is shown to be effective in significantly reducing noise in the raw frequency data, leading to improved sensor resolution and stability.
  • Allan Deviation for Performance Metrics: Using Allan deviation analysis provides a standardized method to quantify the frequency stability of the resonant oscillators, which is crucial for determining the ultimate resolution of the tilt sensor.

Key Results

  • Scale Factor: The sensor achieves a scale factor of at least 11.53 Hz/degree in the sensitive region.
  • Resolution: The tilt sensor demonstrates a resolution of 0.002° across the entire 0° to 360° measurement range.
  • Minimum Allan Deviation: The minimum Allan deviation of the DETF oscillator is 220 ppb (parts per billion) for a 5-second integration time.
  • Nonlinearity: The nonlinearity of the tilt sensor is 0.61% FS (Full Scale).
  • Hysteresis: The hysteresis is measured at 0.22% FS.
  • Repeatability: The repeatability is 0.46% FS.
  • Accuracy: The overall accuracy of the tilt sensor is 0.79% FS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Drift: The paper acknowledges that single-crystal silicon is anisotropic and its elastic properties change with temperature. While FEA was used to simulate this effect, temperature drift can reduce the stability of frequency data and affect angle calculations. The authors state that in practical use, compensation for external temperature is necessary.
  • Angular Misalignment: Manufacturing process errors can lead to slight deviations in the 120° spacing between DETFs. These misalignments were quantified and noted as factors to be considered in future analysis.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to focus on further increasing the scale factor and resolution of the tilt sensor. Integrated packaging of the entire system is also a key area for future research. Additionally, they aim to develop methods for compensating temperature drift and other environmental factors.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{wang2018novel,
  author = {Shudong Wang and Xueyong Wei and Yinsheng Weng and Yulong Zhao and Zhuangde Jiang},
  title = {{A Novel Single-Axis MEMS Tilt Sensor with a High Sensitivity in the Measurement Range from 0∘ to 360∘}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2018},
  doi = {10.3390/s18020346},
}
Figure