A Novel Sediment Pressure Sampling Device Carried by a Hadal-Rated Lander

Jiawang Chen, Yue Huang, Yuan Lin, Peng Zhou, Yuping Fang, Xiaoling Le, Yuhong WangJournal of Marine Science and Engineering 2020 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a novel, compact pressure sampling device for hadal sediments, designed to be deployed from a lander. This device addresses the challenge of obtaining pristine deep-sea sediment samples by employing a unique sealing mechanism and has demonstrated its feasibility through simulations and preliminary experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Exploring the hadal zone (depths > 6000 m) is crucial for understanding Earth's geological history, marine ecosystems, and biogeochemical cycles. However, obtaining undisturbed sediment samples from these extreme depths is technically challenging. Traditional methods often struggle to maintain the in-situ pressure of the sediment during recovery, leading to sample degradation and loss of valuable scientific information. Existing pressure samplers can be bulky, require external power, or are not easily integrated with autonomous landers. This paper tackles the need for a more convenient, economical, and lander-compatible pressure sampling device specifically for hadal sediments.

Methods

The core of this research is the design and simulation of a novel sediment pressure sampling device. Key methodological aspects include:

  • Device Design: The device features an oil-filled servo motor for operation in high-pressure environments, a reduction drive, and a screw drive mechanism to control the sampling cylinder's movement. A unique sealing structure is implemented using core keepers and a sampling cone, which avoids traditional valves and significantly reduces the device's size and weight. The device is designed to be self-powered with its own battery and control cabin, making it independent of ship-based ROVs or cables.
  • Simulation: The sampling process was analyzed using ABAQUS software. Due to the large deformation of sediment during sampling, a Coupled Eulerian-Lagrangian (CEL) method was employed. This approach treats the sampling cylinder as Lagrangian (tracking its movement) and the sediment as Eulerian (allowing for large deformations and material flow).
  • Parameter Optimization: Simulations were conducted to investigate the influence of key design parameters on sampling length, specifically:
  • Mesh Density: A mesh sensitivity study was performed to determine an adequate mesh resolution for accurate simulation results.
  • Installation Position of Core Keepers (L1): The distance between the bottom of the core keepers and the top of the sampling cone was varied to find an optimal position for maximizing sampling length.
  • Open Diameter of Core Keepers (D1): The diameter of the core keepers was adjusted to determine its impact on sediment intake and overall sampling length.
  • Experimental Verification: A simplified experiment was conducted using the sampling structure (without the driving mechanism) to manually push the sampling cylinder into sediment and assess the feasibility of the sampling process and sealing.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The study relies on simulated sediment behavior and experimental validation with actual sediment samples.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Novel Sealing Mechanism: The device's innovative sealing approach, utilizing core keepers and a sampling cone rather than traditional valves, is a significant advancement. This design drastically reduces the sampler's size and weight, making it ideal for lander deployment.
  • Lander Integration: The development of a self-contained, battery-powered unit that doesn't require external cable or ROV support is a crucial step towards autonomous hadal exploration.
  • Simulation-Driven Optimization: The use of ABAQUS with a CEL method allowed for detailed analysis of complex sediment deformation, providing critical insights into how design parameters like core keeper position and diameter affect sampling performance.
  • Trade-offs in Design: The simulations revealed that there are optimal ranges for both the installation position (L1) and open diameter (D1) of the core keepers. Too small or too large values for these parameters can lead to reduced sampling length or potential issues during recovery.

Key Results

  • Optimized Design Parameters: Simulations identified an optimal installation position for the core keepers at 12 mm, yielding a maximum sampling length of 148.3 mm. Similarly, an optimal open diameter for the core keepers was found to be 86 mm, also resulting in a maximum sampling length of 148.3 mm.
  • Feasibility Demonstrated: The device's overall structure and sealing mechanism were verified through simulations and preliminary experiments, indicating that the sampling process can be realized effectively.
  • Sampling Length: The simulations showed that sampling length increases with increasing time, with a relatively constant sampling rate observed after approximately 0.6 seconds.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations:
    • The current device is primarily designed for sampling soft sediments. Its performance with harder sediments or those containing gas hydrates is not discussed.
  • The experimental verification in this paper focused on the sampling structure itself, without the full driving mechanism. Field tests with the complete, operational device are still pending.
  • The paper mentions a potential for pressure loss during recovery due to leakage, which the accumulator aims to compensate for. The effectiveness of this compensation under actual hadal conditions requires further validation.
  • Future Work:
    • The authors plan to conduct sea trials of the device on a lander in the Mariana Trench.
  • Further optimization of the structure is suggested to improve the sampling length.
  • Testing the device's performance with a wider range of sediment types, including harder sediments and those with gas hydrates, would be valuable.
  • Detailed analysis of the pressure loss compensation mechanism and its effectiveness in real-world scenarios is needed.

Summary updated

Abstract

Reliable sampling technology for deep-sea sediments is a prerequisite for studying the sedimentary environment in the geological history, the mechanical characteristics of sediments and sediment biology. In this study, we develop a new sampling device in order to achieve a convenient and economic pressure sampling for hadal sediments. The overall structure, as well as the key component such as the pressure-holding part, and the sealing structure are designed. The feasibility of the device was verified through field tests. Furthermore, the sampling process is analyzed by the computer simulation. It is found that the sampling length is determined by the open diameter and the installation position of the core keepers. According to the simulation, the structure is optimized, which is beneficial to the further improvement of the sampling length.
BibTeX
@article{chen2020novel,
  author = {Jiawang Chen and Yue Huang and Yuan Lin and Peng Zhou and Yuping Fang and Xiaoling Le and Yuhong Wang},
  title = {{A Novel Sediment Pressure Sampling Device Carried by a Hadal-Rated Lander}},
  journal = {Journal of Marine Science and Engineering},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.3390/jmse8110839},
}
Figure