A novel score system to evaluate carbonate reservoir combining microscale and macroscale parameters

Huilin Xu, Guanqun Wang, Wei Xu, Wenjun Luo, Dan Han, Xiong Zhao, Fan Xiao, Haipeng Shao, Jucai Yan, Wei LongJournal of Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology 2024 · DOI

Abstract

The central Sichuan Basin, located in western China, holds great significance in terms of hydrocarbon production, especially in relation to complex carbonate reservoirs, notably the Qixia Formation of the Middle Permian epoch. However, the comprehensive evaluation of this geological formation presents considerable challenges due to complex lithology, limited availability of reservoir property data at various scales, and the absence of a reliable reservoir ranking system. This study integrates advanced technologies like X-ray diffraction, micro-CT, and scanning electron microscope (SEM) techniques in digital drill cutting analysis at the microscale. A novel scoring system has been developed using a prominent component analysis (PCA) approach and an expert scoring system, which incorporates existing conventional well log data and digital cutting analysis. This scoring system has been validated using actual production data, establishing a robust evaluation methodology for assessing exploration potential and optimizing development strategies for carbonate gas reservoirs.

Introduction

Evaluating carbonate reservoirs, particularly the Qixia Formation in China’s Sichuan Basin, is notoriously difficult. These formations are highly heterogeneous, featuring "dual-pore" systems of fractures and vugs (small cavities). Traditional evaluation relies on macroscale well logs, which often lack the resolution to see micro-pores, or physical core samples, which are expensive and difficult to recover in fractured zones where drilling fluid is frequently lost. This data gap makes it hard for engineers to rank reservoirs or make informed development decisions.

Methodology

The study employs a multi-scale integration approach to fill the microscale information gap using "digital cuttings"—the small rock chips produced during drilling—and combining them with standard logging data.

Microscale and Digital Cutting Analysis

The research team utilized X-ray Diffraction (XRD) to identify mineralogy, Micro-CT to reconstruct 3D pore structures at a 1.5 μm resolution, and Scanning Electron Microscopy (SEM) to capture nanoscale porosity. By applying the Lattice Boltzmann method—a fluid dynamics simulation—to the 3D CT models, they calculated absolute permeability, effectively turning rock chips into "digital cores."

Dimensionality Reduction and Scoring

To handle the "curse of dimensionality" from 14 different input parameters, the researchers used Principal Component Analysis (PCA). This identified the most influential factors, which were then combined with an expert-weighted scoring system to create a final "Reservoir Score."

Study Area and Datasets

The study utilized a dataset of 14 drill cutting samples specifically selected from the Middle Permian Qixia Formation in the Gaoshiti-Moxi area of the Sichuan Basin. These samples were chosen to represent both high-potential reservoirs and non-reservoir zones.

Geological map of the study area and distribution of sample wells in the Sichuan Basin.

Key Results and Insights

  • The "90" Threshold: The scoring system produced a clear demarcation line. Wells with a score above 90 were consistently high-producers (reservoirs), while those below 90 showed little to no gas indication (non-reservoirs).
  • High Correlation with Production: The scores showed a strong positive correlation with actual daily production volumes. For example, well GS001-X32 scored a 98 and demonstrated substantial gas flow, while well MX108-b scored an 87 and showed no gas.
  • Dominance of Micro-Porosity: Through PCA, the researchers found that micron-scale porosity is the single most important variable, carrying a weight of 38.4% in the final score.
  • Efficiency: By reducing 14 parameters down to 7 primary controlling factors (Micron-scale porosity, CNL, average pore throat radius, micron permeability, dolomite content, DEN, and AC), the model becomes computationally efficient for rapid field evaluation.

Conclusion and Future Work

This paper demonstrates that with micro-CT and SEM, drill cuttings can provide high-fidelity petrophysical data that macro-logs cannot capture. The successful integration of micro-parameters with macro-parameters provides a holistic view necessary for predicting gas flow in complex carbonates. Future work will focus on expanding the system to evaluate unconventional shale gas reservoirs and automating the analysis pipeline to provide real-time scoring during the drilling process.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The central Sichuan Basin, located in western China, holds great significance in terms of hydrocarbon production, especially in relation to complex carbonate reservoirs, notably the Qixia Formation of the Middle Permian epoch. However, the comprehensive evaluation of this geological formation presents considerable challenges due to complex lithology, limited availability of reservoir property data at various scales, inadequacies in data integration, and the absence of a reliable reservoir ranking system for development decision making. Previous studies primarily relying on conventional data at the reservoir level, such as well logs and geological information, have proven insufficient in accurately characterizing the reservoir. This is especially evident without precise lithological information and detailed knowledge of microscale properties, which are crucial for effective reservoir evaluation. To address these challenges, this study integrates advanced technologies like X-ray diffraction, micro-CT and scanning electron microscope (SEM) techniques in digital drill cutting analysis at the microscale. A novel scoring system has been developed using a prominent component analysis (PCA) approach and an expert scoring system, which incorporates existing conventional well log data and digital cutting analysis. This scoring system has been validated using actual production data, thus establishing a robust evaluation methodology for assessing the exploration potential and optimizing development strategies for carbonate gas reservoirs in the Qixia Formation. The innovative approach, which incorporates parameters at both micro- and macroscales, holds promising potential in facilitating future exploration and development efforts.
BibTeX
@article{xu2024novel,
  author = {Huilin Xu and Guanqun Wang and Wei Xu and Wenjun Luo and Dan Han and Xiong Zhao and Fan Xiao and Haipeng Shao and Jucai Yan and Wei Long},
  title = {{A novel score system to evaluate carbonate reservoir combining microscale and macroscale parameters}},
  journal = {Journal of Petroleum Exploration and Production Technology},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.1007/s13202-024-01755-1},
}
Figure