A novel method to enhance the sensitivity of marker detection using a refined hierarchical prior of tissue similarities

Shahin Mohammadi, Ananth GramabioRxiv 2015 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a new statistical method to improve the identification of "tissue-selective" genes, which are crucial for understanding how different cell types and tissues function. By first removing the influence of "housekeeping" genes (those active in almost all cells) and then building a hierarchical map of tissue similarities, their approach significantly boosts the signal-to-noise ratio, leading to more accurate and comprehensive marker discovery.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding how a single totipotent cell differentiates into the vast array of specialized cells in our bodies is a fundamental biological question. This process is driven by genes that are selectively expressed in specific tissues, orchestrating unique cellular functions and often playing a role in tissue-specific diseases. However, identifying these tissue-selective genes is challenging due to two main issues:

  1. The "Housekeeping" Gene Noise: Many genes are universally expressed across all tissues to maintain basic cellular functions. These "housekeeping" genes can mask the subtle expression patterns of tissue-specific genes, making them harder to detect.
  2. Tissue Similarity Complexity: Simply counting how many tissues a gene is expressed in isn't enough to determine its specificity. The similarity between the tissues where a gene is active is also crucial. A gene expressed in many similar tissues might be less specific than one expressed in a few distinct tissues.

Existing methods struggle to effectively disentangle these complexities, leading to lower sensitivity and reliability in marker detection, especially when limited data is available.

Methods

The authors propose a novel statistical framework with several key steps:

  1. Deflating Housekeeping Gene Influence: They use Singular Value Decomposition (SVD) to estimate a "housekeeping signature" from the raw gene expression data. This signature is then used to adjust the expression profiles of each tissue, effectively "peeling off" the common signal from housekeeping genes. This is termed the "Peeling the Common Signature" (PCS) method.
  2. Building a Hierarchical Tissue Similarity Map: The adjusted transcriptional signatures are used to calculate pairwise tissue similarities. These similarities are then used to cluster tissues into groups that share similar functional profiles. This process is applied iteratively to create a refined hierarchy of tissue relationships.
  3. Reducing the Gene Expression Space: Using the identified tissue clusters, the authors further reduce the dimensionality of the gene expression data. Each cluster is represented by a unique signature, creating a more focused and informative subspace for marker identification.
  4. Novel Marker Detection: Within this reduced, refined subspace, a new method is employed to identify genes that are preferentially expressed. This method considers factors like expression domain restriction, reproducibility, and relative expression levels.

Datasets

The primary dataset used is the Genomics Institute of the Novartis Research Foundation (GNF) Gene Atlas. This dataset contains expression profiles for 84 human tissues and cell-types.

For validation, they also utilize:

  • Immune Response In Silico (IRIS) dataset: A gold standard for immune-cell specific markers.
  • Human Protein Atlas: A recently published map of the human tissue proteome, used as a gold standard for brain-specific genes.

The paper does not introduce a new benchmark dataset but rather uses existing ones for evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Housekeeping genes are a major confounder: Their pervasive expression significantly inflates tissue similarity scores, making it difficult to distinguish true tissue-specific signals. Removing this "noise" is critical.
  • Tissue similarity is hierarchical and nuanced: Simply counting tissues isn't sufficient. The relationships between tissues matter, and a hierarchical approach can capture these complex similarities and differences.
  • Reducing the data space enhances sensitivity: By focusing on groups of similar tissues and their representative signatures, the method can better pinpoint genes that are truly specific to those contexts.
  • The method is robust to limited data: The approach shows promise even when the number of available expression datasets is limited, a common challenge in biological research.

Key Results

  • The PCS method successfully reduces the expression levels of housekeeping genes (e.g., GAPDH and β-actin) across tissues, as demonstrated by median score changes from positive to negative values.
  • Adjusted transcriptional similarities are centered around zero, indicating that most tissues are functionally unrelated after accounting for housekeeping genes, while also revealing meaningful similarities between related tissues.
  • In case studies on immune cells and brain tissues, their method significantly outperforms existing state-of-the-art approaches in terms of both the coverage and reliability of identified tissue-selective genes.
  • When validating brain-specific genes against the Human Protein Atlas, their method shows high overlap and strong performance, particularly in identifying genes related to brain-specific disorders.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The authors acknowledge that while their method improves sensitivity, it might not be perfect for all gene types. For instance, for NK cell markers, a significant drop in expression after the first cell-type might be an artifact of a lower number of available markers. The paper also notes that the specificity and accuracy calculations in Table 4 are approximations due to the nature of the gold standard dataset.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their framework can be applied to construct similar datasets for other human tissues to identify tissue-specific genes. They also highlight the potential for these tissue-selective genes to enhance our understanding of differentiating biochemical features, disease progression, and to identify specific biomarkers and therapeutic targets. The paper also hints at the potential for developing integrative methods to combine results from different marker detection approaches.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Motivation Identification of biochemical processes that drive the transformation of a totipotent cell into various cell types is essential to our understanding of living systems. This complex machinery determines how tissues differ in terms of their anatomy, physiology, morphology, and, more importantly, how various cellular control mechanisms contribute to the observed similarities/ differences. Tissue-selective genes orchestrate various aspects of cellular machinery in different tissues, and are known to be implicated in a number of tissue-specific pathologies. Results We propose a novel statistical approach that identifies and removes the effect of universally expressed genes in groups of tissues. This allows us to better characterize tissue similarities, as well as to identify tissue-selective genes. We use our method to construct a reliable hierarchy of tissue similarities. The groupings of tissues in this hierarchy are used to specify successively refined priors for identifying tissue-selective functions and their corresponding genes in the reduced subspace. We show that our refinement process enhances the signal-to-noise ratio in the identification of markers. Using case studies of immune cells and brain tissues, we show that our approach significantly outperforms the state-of-the-art methods, both in terms of coverage and reliability of the predicted tissue-selective genes. Conclusions Our statistical approach provides a general framework for enhancing the sensitivity of marker detection methods, which can be used in conjunction with other techniques. Even in cases where the number of available expression datasets is limited, we show that our marker detection method outperforms existing techniques. We present detailed validation on immune cells and brain tissues in this paper. Our approach can be applied to construct similar datasets of other human tissues as well, for identifying tissue-specific genes. We demonstrate how these tissue-selective genes enhance our understanding of differentiating biochemical features of brain tissues, shed light on how tissue-selective pathologies progress, and help us identify specific biomarkers and targets for future interventions.
BibTeX
@misc{mohammadi2015novel,
  author = {Shahin Mohammadi and Ananth Grama},
  title = {{A novel method to enhance the sensitivity of marker detection using a refined hierarchical prior of tissue similarities}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.1101/020685},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure