Abstract
We report the first model of fat and carb oxidation integrating ketogenesis, a key condition that influences weight loss and maintenance. The model was developed from fundamental mass balance laws and a biochemical process unit approach. We tested the model with a pilot study in 16 healthy subjects exposed to short-term ketogenic interventions of exercise, fasting, and ketogenic meal while controlling the baseline at 4 different conditions: 1- normal diet/energy balance, 2- ketogenic diet/energy balance, 3- normal diet/negative energy balance, and 4- ketogenic diet/negative energy balance. We evaluated the ketogenesis contributions to fat and carb oxidation rates from the new model with a previously widely used model and found that the new model exhibits better predictive performance of fat and carb oxidation rate during ketogenesis. In addition, the new model’s fat and carb oxidation was correlated with 5 different ketones excretion rates and concentrations. Finally, the new model demonstrated value to discriminate between fat oxidation from adipose tissue and diet fat, which enabled individualization of different metabolic responses among the study subjects.
Introduction
Traditional metabolic models, such as the Frayn equations, have long relied on indirect calorimetry to estimate fat and carbohydrate oxidation. However, these models assume complete fat oxidation—an assumption that fails during ketogenic states induced by fasting, intense exercise, or specific diets. In these states, fat is partially oxidized into ketone bodies, leading to significant inaccuracies in metabolic assessment. This paper presents the Ketogenesis-Integrated Model (KIM), a novel framework that incorporates ketone production into the calculation of fuel oxidation rates, providing a more accurate picture of human metabolism.
Methods
The KIM was developed using fundamental mass balance laws and stoichiometry, adding specific terms for the production of three major ketone bodies: acetoacetate, acetone, and beta-hydroxybutyrate (BHB). The model was validated through an 8-week crossover pilot study involving 16 healthy subjects (9 males, 7 females).
As shown in Figure 1, the study was divided into four 2-week blocks comparing normal and ketogenic diets under both energy balance and negative energy balance conditions. Within each block, interventions including exercise, fasting, and ketogenic meals were used to stimulate ketone production. Researchers monitored ketone levels across four biological matrices: breath (acetone), skin (acetone), blood (BHB), and urine (acetoacetate and BHB).
Key Results and Insights
The KIM model demonstrated a 39% higher fat oxidation rate compared to traditional models during ketogenic conditions, effectively capturing the "missing" fat oxidation previously overlooked by standard equations.
Key findings from the multi-matrix sensing (Figure 2) and model application include:
- Predictive Performance: Fat oxidation rates showed an exceptional correlation with breath acetone excretion ($R^2 = 0.96$) and skin acetone excretion ($R^2 = 0.73$).
- Dietary Differentiation: The model detected 2 to 3 times higher fat oxidation on ketogenic diets ($p = 0.0002$) and allowed researchers to distinguish between the oxidation of dietary fat and stored adipose tissue.
- Metabolic Phenotyping: Subjects were categorized into three groups based on their adipose tissue mobilization response, highlighting the model's utility for personalized nutrition and weight loss tracking.
- Non-Starvation Gluconeogenesis: The model observed the body producing glucose from fat-derived glycerol or lactate during ketogenic interventions, a process termed "non-starvation gluconeogenesis."
Discussion and Limitations
While the KIM offers a significant advancement in metabolic modeling, it currently assumes a metabolic steady state and does not account for the utilization of ketones as fuel, which may be relevant in long-term keto-adaptation. Future applications include clinical studies in populations with obesity or Type 2 Diabetes and the development of wearable technology for real-time, individualized metabolic tracking.
Reference: Nguyen, N. A., et al. (2025). A Novel Ketogenesis-Integrated Model of Fat and Carbohydrate Oxidation. Research Square (Preprint). DOI: 10.21203/rs.3.rs-5932521/v1
Summary updated