A Novel Integrated Structure with a Radial Displacement Sensor and a Permanent Magnet Biased Radial Magnetic Bearing

Jinji Sun, Yin Zhang2014 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel integrated design that combines a radial displacement sensor with a permanent magnet biased radial magnetic bearing for high-speed magnetically suspended motors (HSMSMs). This integration significantly reduces the axial length of HSMSMs, leading to increased maximum speeds and improved rotor modal shapes, while maintaining accurate displacement detection and good temperature stability.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

High-speed magnetically suspended motors (HSMSMs) are crucial for applications requiring high rotational speeds without mechanical friction, such as flywheels and compressors. A key challenge in HSMSM design is managing their axial length, which directly impacts the maximum achievable speed and rotor dynamics. Traditional designs often require separate radial displacement sensors, which are typically installed outside the magnetic bearing coils. This separation necessitates a larger axial footprint and can lead to lower rotor modal shapes, limiting the motor's high-speed capabilities. Furthermore, existing eddy current sensors, commonly used for displacement detection, are susceptible to magnetic field interference and environmental factors like temperature and vibration, affecting their reliability and compactness.

Methods

The core innovation of this paper is the development of an integrated structure that embeds radial displacement sensor probes directly within the permanent magnet biased radial magnetic bearing. Specifically, the sensor probes are strategically placed on adjacent stator poles in the axial direction, leveraging the available space within the magnetic bearing. The preamplifier circuits for these sensors are located externally to the HSMSM and connected via shielded cables. This design choice decouples the sensitive preamplifier electronics from the high-temperature and vibration-prone environment of the motor's core. The paper details the mechanical design, including the arrangement of magnetic poles, coils, permanent magnets, and sensor bases, and presents 3D Finite Element Method (FEM) analysis to assess magnetic field distribution and its potential impact on the sensors. Experimental tests were conducted to validate the performance of the integrated structure in terms of displacement detection accuracy, linearity, and temperature stability.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on the design and experimental validation of a novel hardware structure.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Space Saving through Integration: By integrating the displacement sensor probes into the magnetic bearing structure, the overall axial length of the HSMSM can be significantly reduced. This is a critical factor for achieving higher rotational speeds.
  • Improved Rotor Dynamics: The reduction in axial length and the resulting increase in rotor modal shape directly contribute to a higher maximum critical speed for the motor, enhancing its high-speed performance.
  • Enhanced Environmental Robustness: Separating the preamplifier circuits from the sensor probes and the core motor environment shields them from temperature fluctuations and vibrations, leading to improved reliability and stability.
  • Minimal Magnetic Field Interference: FEM analysis demonstrates that the magnetic field at the sensor probe locations is weak, ensuring that the magnetic bearing's operation does not significantly interfere with the displacement sensor's readings.
  • Good Sensor Performance: Experimental results confirm that the integrated structure maintains good linearity in displacement detection and exhibits acceptable temperature characteristics, validating the design's effectiveness.

Key Results

  • The proposed integrated structure can reduce the axial length of a 4 kW HSMSM system by 9%.
  • This reduction in axial length leads to an approximate 16% increase in the first bending mode, consequently increasing the maximum critical speed.
  • FEM analysis confirmed that the magnetic field at the sensor probe locations is weak, indicating no significant influence from the radial magnetic bearing.
  • Experimental tests showed good linearity between displacement and output voltage, meeting sensor demands.
  • The temperature drift of the sensor circuit showed an output voltage ripple of approximately 4% as the temperature varied from 20 °C to 70 °C.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Temperature Drift of Sensor Probes: While the sensor circuit's temperature drift is addressed, the paper notes that the temperature of the sensor probes themselves can reach higher levels (up to 98 °C in experiments). The paper suggests that coil current curves can effectively reflect this temperature drift, implying that direct compensation for probe temperature might be a future consideration.
  • Material Selection for Detector: The paper briefly mentions that detector materials like 45# or 40Cr steel can be used for stability, but a more in-depth discussion on material optimization for the sensor probes could be a future avenue.
  • Further Optimization: While the integration offers significant benefits, further optimization of the sensor probe placement and preamplifier design could potentially yield even greater improvements in accuracy and temperature compensation.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{sun2014novel,
  author = {Jinji Sun and Yin Zhang},
  title = {{A Novel Integrated Structure with a Radial Displacement Sensor and a Permanent Magnet Biased Radial Magnetic Bearing}},
  year = {2014},
  doi = {10.3390/s140201950},
}
Figure