A Novel Hybrid Error Criterion-Based Active Control Method for on-Line Milling Vibration Suppression with Piezoelectric Actuators and Sensors

Xingwu Zhang, Chenxi Wang, Robert X. Gao, Ruqiang Yan, Xuefeng Chen, Shibin WangSensors 2016 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel frequency-domain LMS active control method for suppressing vibrations during milling processes. By combining a global frequency error with a specific frequency node error, the method enhances adaptability and anti-interference capabilities, leading to improved machining quality and surface finish, as demonstrated through simulations and experiments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Milling vibrations are a significant issue in manufacturing, negatively impacting machining quality, precision, and tool lifespan. While traditional methods exist to mitigate these vibrations, such as adjusting machining parameters or using passive control, they often fall short in adaptability and real-time effectiveness. Existing active vibration control methods, while promising, can suffer from issues like local optima, reduced adaptability, and susceptibility to interference, especially when relying solely on time-domain error criteria. This paper aims to address these limitations by proposing a more robust and efficient active control strategy specifically for on-line milling vibration suppression.

Methods

The core of the proposed method is a frequency-domain Least Mean Squares (LMS) algorithm. Unlike traditional time-domain LMS, the frequency-domain approach is less sensitive to transient responses and better suited for periodic vibrations, which are common in milling. A key innovation is the use of only one Fast Fourier Transform (FFT) per control cycle, eliminating the need for an Inverse FFT (IFFT), which simplifies the control flow and reduces processing time.

The paper introduces a novel hybrid error criterion to improve the algorithm's performance. This criterion combines:

  • Global frequency error (J): This measures the overall difference between the desired and actual vibration response across the entire frequency spectrum. It's used for updating the control weights.
  • Frequency node error (Jn): This specifically targets the amplitude of characteristic frequencies, which are crucial for vibration suppression.

This hybrid approach is designed to enhance adaptability and anti-interference by ensuring that both the overall vibration and specific critical frequencies are effectively managed. The control parameters are optimized using a steepest descent procedure. Additionally, a "protection algorithm" is incorporated to prevent the control process from diverging or exceeding operational limits, thereby enhancing system reliability and safety.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on simulations and experimental setups using specific hardware and controlled vibration sources rather than pre-existing datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Frequency-domain LMS is more efficient for milling: By operating in the frequency domain and using only one FFT per cycle, the method achieves faster processing and is better suited for the periodic nature of milling vibrations.
  • Hybrid error criterion is crucial for robustness: Simply using global frequency error can miss critical frequency components, while solely focusing on frequency node error can lead to unacceptable outcomes. The combination of both significantly improves adaptability and anti-interference.
  • A "protection algorithm" is vital for practical implementation: Real-world systems can be unpredictable. Adding a safety net to prevent control divergence or parameter overreach is essential for reliable operation and preventing hardware damage.
  • Active control directly improves surface finish: The experimental results clearly demonstrate that suppressing vibrations leads to a visibly smoother and less rough surface on the machined workpiece.

Key Results

  • Simulation: The spindle-based simulation showed that the proposed method effectively reached the control destination for both single-frequency and multi-frequency sinusoidal vibration signals.
  • Experiment: In the milling experiment on an aluminum plate, the active control system significantly reduced vibration amplitude and energy, particularly in the low-frequency range (over 50% reduction in energy).
  • Qualitative Improvement: The machined aluminum plate exhibited a noticeably improved surface finish when the active control system was engaged compared to when it was off, visually confirming the effectiveness of vibration suppression.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limitations: The paper notes that while the method performs well, the control process can oscillate slightly when dealing with multifrequency vibration sources, suggesting room for further refinement. The authors also acknowledge that vibration is only one factor affecting machining quality, with faults being another significant concern.
  • Future Work: The authors plan to integrate condition monitoring, fault diagnosis, and active vibration suppression units into machine tools. This aims to create a more comprehensive system for improving the overall reliability and performance of machine tools.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{zhang2016novel,
  author = {Xingwu Zhang and Chenxi Wang and Robert X. Gao and Ruqiang Yan and Xuefeng Chen and Shibin Wang},
  title = {{A Novel Hybrid Error Criterion-Based Active Control Method for on-Line Milling Vibration Suppression with Piezoelectric Actuators and Sensors}},
  journal = {Sensors},
  year = {2016},
  doi = {10.3390/s16010068},
}
Figure