A Novel Genetic Selection System for Improved Enantioselectivity of Bacillus subtilis Lipase A

Ykelien L. Boersma, Melloney J. Dröge, Almer M. van der Sloot, Tjaard Pijning, Robbert H. Cool, Bauke W. Dijkstra, Wim J. QuaxChemBioChem 2008 · DOI

Abstract

In directed evolution experiments, success often depends on the efficacy of screening or selection methods. Genetic selections have proven to be extremely valuable for evolving enzymes with improved catalytic activity, improved stability, or with altered substrate specificity. In contrast, enantioselectivity is a difficult parameter to select for. In this study, we present a successful strategy that not only selects for catalytic activity, but for the first time also for enantioselectivity, as demonstrated by the selection of Bacillus subtilis lipase A variants with inverted and improved enantioselectivity. A lipase mutant library in an aspartate auxotroph Escherichia coli was plated on minimal medium that was supplemented with the aspartate ester of the desired enantiomer (S)-(+)-1,2-O-isopropylidene-sn-glycerol. To inhibit growth of less enantioselective variants, a covalently binding phosphonate ester of the opposite (R)-(-)-1,2-O-isopropylidene-sn-glycerol enantiomer was added as well. After three selection rounds in which the selection pressure was increased by raising the phosphonate ester concentration, a mutant was selected with an improved enantioselectivity increased from an ee of -29.6 % (conversion 23.4 %) to an ee of +73.1 % (conversion 28.9 %) towards the (S)-(+)-enantiomer. Interestingly, its amino acid sequence showed that the acid of the catalytic triad had migrated to a position further along the loop that connects beta7 and alphaE; this shows that the position of the catalytic acid is not necessarily conserved in this lipase.

Introduction

In industrial chemistry, the production of enantiopure compounds is essential, particularly for the pharmaceutical industry where different enantiomers can have vastly different biological effects. Biocatalysts, such as lipases, are frequently employed for these transformations due to their inherent selectivity. However, natural enzymes often require optimization through directed evolution to meet industrial requirements for specific substrates.

While directed evolution has been highly successful in improving enzyme speed and stability, selecting for enantioselectivity remains a significant bottleneck. Traditional methods rely on screening—testing thousands of individual mutants—which is labor-intensive and limits the diversity that can be explored. This paper describes a high-throughput genetic selection system where bacterial survival is directly linked to the enzyme's ability to distinguish between mirror-image molecules.

The Dual-Selection Strategy

The researchers developed a "live-or-die" selection system using an Escherichia coli host strain that is an aspartate auxotroph, meaning it cannot synthesize the essential amino acid aspartate and will die unless it is provided in the growth medium.

To link survival to enantioselectivity, the team employed a "carrot and stick" approach:

  1. The Positive Selection ("The Carrot"): The bacteria were grown on a medium where the only source of aspartate was an ester of the desired (S)-enantiomer of 1,2-O-isopropylidene-sn-glycerol (IPG). Only bacteria expressing a lipase variant capable of hydrolyzing this specific ester could release aspartate and survive.
  2. The Negative Selection ("The Stick"): To prevent the survival of "promiscuous" enzymes that might hydrolyze both enantiomers, a phosphonate inhibitor of the undesired (R)-enantiomer was added. This inhibitor acts as a suicide substrate, covalently bonding to and permanently inactivating any enzyme that attempts to process the wrong mirror image.
Chemical structures of the substrates (A), aspartate ester 'carrots' (B), and phosphonate inhibitor 'sticks' (C) used in the dual-selection system.

By increasing the concentration of the phosphonate inhibitor over three rounds of selection, the researchers were able to progressively increase the selection pressure, favoring only the most enantioselective variants.

Results and Structural Insights

The selection was applied to a library of approximately 35,000 variants of Bacillus subtilis lipase A (LipA), created by randomizing a loop (residues 132–136) near the active site.

The wild-type LipA originally showed a slight preference for the (R)-enantiomer (ee of -29.6%). After three rounds of selection, the team identified a standout mutant, D133A/V136D. This variant exhibited a complete inversion of selectivity, strongly preferring the (S)-enantiomer with an enantiomeric excess (ee) of +73.1%. Crucially, this improvement in selectivity did not come at the cost of catalytic efficiency; the conversion rate remained robust, increasing slightly from 23.4% to 28.9%.

Kinetic analysis revealed that the $K_M$ for the desired (S)-enantiomer was significantly lowered in the mutant, while the $K_M$ for the undesired (R)-enantiomer increased, providing a clear biochemical basis for the observed selectivity.

Perhaps the most surprising finding was the structural change in the mutant. The "catalytic triad" (Ser77, His156, Asp133) is typically considered a rigid, conserved feature of serine hydrolases. In the selected mutant, the original catalytic acid at position 133 was replaced by Alanine. However, the enzyme remained active because the new Aspartate introduced at position 136 migrated into the active site to fulfill the catalytic role. This "migrating triad" demonstrates a remarkable level of structural plasticity in the lipase active site.

Conclusion

This study demonstrates a powerful and generalizable strategy for the directed evolution of enantioselective enzymes. By combining positive selection for activity with negative selection against the undesired enantiomer, researchers can rapidly explore large mutant libraries. Furthermore, the discovery of the migrating catalytic acid challenges conventional views on the conservation of active site residues and opens new possibilities for enzyme engineering. While the system currently requires periplasmic translocation and custom substrate synthesis, it represents a significant step forward in high-throughput biocatalyst development.

Summary updated

Abstract

In directed evolution experiments, success often depends on the efficacy of screening or selection methods. Genetic selections have proven to be extremely valuable for evolving enzymes with improved catalytic activity, improved stability, or with altered substrate specificity. In contrast, enantioselectivity is a difficult parameter to select for. In this study, we present a successful strategy that not only selects for catalytic activity, but for the first time also for enantioselectivity, as demonstrated by the selection of Bacillus subtilis lipase A variants with inverted and improved enantioselectivity. A lipase mutant library in an aspartate auxotroph Escherichia coli was plated on minimal medium that was supplemented with the aspartate ester of the desired enantiomer (S)-(+)-1,2-O-isopropylidene-sn-glycerol. To inhibit growth of less enantioselective variants, a covalently binding phosphonate ester of the opposite (R)-(-)-1,2-O-isopropylidene-sn-glycerol enantiomer was added as well. After three selection rounds in which the selection pressure was increased by raising the phosphonate ester concentration, a mutant was selected with an improved enantioselectivity increased from an ee of -29.6 % (conversion 23.4 %) to an ee of +73.1 % (conversion 28.9 %) towards the (S)-(+)-enantiomer. Interestingly, its amino acid sequence showed that the acid of the catalytic triad had migrated to a position further along the loop that connects beta7 and alphaE; this shows that the position of the catalytic acid is not necessarily conserved in this lipase.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{boersma2008novel,
  author = {Ykelien L. Boersma and Melloney J. Dröge and Almer M. van der Sloot and Tjaard Pijning and Robbert H. Cool and Bauke W. Dijkstra and Wim J. Quax},
  title = {{A Novel Genetic Selection System for Improved Enantioselectivity of <i>Bacillus subtilis</i> Lipase A}},
  booktitle = {ChemBioChem},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1002/cbic.200700754},
}
Figure