TL;DR
This study introduces a novel dual-task (DT) paradigm involving story recall to better differentiate older adults with mild cognitive impairment (MCI) from those with subjective cognitive decline (SCD) and normal cognition (NC). The findings highlight that specific gait kinematics, particularly knee peak extension angle during DT story recall, are significantly altered in MCI individuals, suggesting this approach could aid in early detection and intervention for cognitive decline.
What Problem Does This Paper Address?
As the global population ages, cognitive decline, including Alzheimer's disease and dementia, poses a significant public health challenge, leading to increased disability and loss of independence. Gait impairment is increasingly recognized as an early indicator of cognitive decline, often preceding noticeable cognitive symptoms. Dual-tasking, which involves performing a motor task (like walking) simultaneously with a cognitive task, is particularly sensitive to these age-related changes. While various DT paradigms exist, their effectiveness in distinguishing between different stages of cognitive impairment, especially between MCI and SCD, remains an area for improvement. This paper aims to address this by developing and evaluating a novel DT paradigm using story recall to identify subtle gait differences in older adults with varying cognitive statuses.
Methods
The researchers employed a cross-sectional, clinical-based study design. Participants were recruited from community-dwelling older adults and categorized into three groups: MCI (n=24), SCD (n=33), and NC (n=26) based on neuropsychological assessments.
The core of the methodology involved a novel dual-task paradigm. Participants performed a single-task (ST) walk and four different DT walks:
- DT calculation: Subtracting serial sevens.
- DT naming animals: Naming animals aloud.
- DT story recall: Repeating a short story.
- DT words recall: Repeating five Chinese words.
Gait kinematics were captured using a Vicon Nexus motion capture system with 51 markers and analyzed with Visual 3D software. Key parameters measured included gait speed, knee peak extension angle, and dual-task cost (DTC). DTC was calculated as the percentage decrement in gait speed during DT compared to ST walking. A mixed-effect linear regression model was used for statistical analysis, controlling for potential covariates like age, gender, BMI, diabetes, depression, and education.
Datasets
Not discussed in the paper. The study utilized data collected from 83 participants recruited for this specific research.
Key Insights and Ideas
- Story Recall as a Sensitive Discriminator: The DT story recall paradigm emerged as particularly effective in highlighting differences in gait kinematics, especially the knee peak extension angle, between individuals with MCI and those with normal cognition. This suggests that memory-related cognitive tasks, when combined with walking, can reveal subtle motor impairments not evident under other DT conditions.
- Knee Kinematics as a Biomarker: A larger knee peak extension angle in the MCI group compared to the NC group during DT story recall and words recall, as well as during ST walking, indicates poorer knee control. This finding is significant as it suggests that impaired knee control during gait could be an early indicator of MCI, potentially contributing to increased fall risk.
- Task-Specific Interference: The study found that different cognitive tasks have varying levels of interference on gait. DT story recall showed a higher dual-task cost (DTC) compared to other DT paradigms, suggesting it places a greater demand on cognitive resources that impact motor performance.
- MCI vs. SCD Distinction: While the study aimed to differentiate between MCI, SCD, and NC, the results suggest that DT story recall is more effective at distinguishing MCI from NC. Further research may be needed to refine DT paradigms for better differentiation between MCI and SCD.
Key Results
- Gait Speed: While gait speed was slower under DT conditions across all groups, the MCI group exhibited slower gait speed compared to SCD and NC groups under all DT conditions. Significant differences in gait speed were observed between MCI and NC groups during DT calculation (p=0.043) and between MCI and SCD groups during DT story recall (p=0.04).
- Knee Peak Extension Angle: The knee peak extension angle was significantly larger in the MCI group compared to the SCD and NC groups under all DT and ST conditions (p<0.01). Specifically, DT story recall and DT words recall showed significant differences between MCI and NC groups (p=0.001).
- Dual-Task Cost (DTC): A significant effect of task on DTC was observed (p<0.001), with DT story recall showing a higher DTC compared to other DT paradigms. The difference in DTC between DT story recall and DT calculation was significant (p<0.001). However, DTC did not significantly differentiate MCI from NC or SCD groups.
Limitations and Future Work
- Cross-Sectional Design: The study's cross-sectional nature limits the ability to establish causality or predict the progression of cognitive decline. Future longitudinal studies are needed to understand the long-term impact of DT performance on cognition.
- Order of DT Paradigms: The DT paradigms were not randomized, which could introduce a learning effect. Future studies should consider randomizing the order of tasks.
- MCI vs. SCD Differentiation: While DT story recall showed promise in differentiating MCI from NC, further refinement of DT paradigms may be necessary for more robust differentiation between MCI and SCD.
- Future Directions: The authors suggest exploring the changes in DT-related brain functional networks in cognitive impairment participants. They also recommend strength training of knee extensors and flexors as a potential intervention to improve knee control during ST and DT walking. Investigating the gait interference of memory tasks in Alzheimer's dementia and SCD populations is also highlighted as an area for future research.
Summary updated