A Novel Cross-Sensor Transfer Diagnosis Method with Local Attention Mechanism: Applied in a Reciprocating Pump

Chen Wang, Ling Chen, Yongfa Zhang, Liming Zhang, Tian TanSensors 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for diagnosing faults in reciprocating pumps by transferring knowledge learned from sensors at one location to sensors at another, even when data distributions differ. They achieve this by incorporating a "local attention mechanism" into a deep learning model, which helps the model focus on the most critical parts of the vibration signals for accurate fault detection.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Reciprocating pumps are crucial in many industrial settings, but their complex structures and harsh operating environments make fault diagnosis challenging. A major hurdle is the difficulty in consistently placing sensors in the most informative locations (like the pump head) due to space constraints and potential hazards. Often, sensors are placed in less ideal spots (like the machine foot), leading to different data distributions and making it hard to apply models trained on data from one sensor location to another. This "cross-sensor domain transfer" problem is a significant challenge for reliable, real-world fault diagnosis.

Methods

The core of the proposed solution is a cross-sensor transfer diagnosis method built upon a Convolutional Neural Network (CNN) backbone. The novelty lies in two key areas:

  1. Cross-Sensor Transfer Learning: The model is trained on labeled data from one sensor location (source domain) and then applied to diagnose faults using data from a different sensor location (target domain), even when the data distributions differ. This is achieved through domain adaptation techniques that aim to reduce the discrepancies between the source and target data.
  2. Local Attention Mechanism: To improve the model's ability to pinpoint crucial fault indicators within the vibration signals, a "local attention mechanism" is integrated. Unlike global attention, which considers the entire input, local attention focuses on specific, relevant segments of the signal. This is particularly useful for time-series data like vibrations, where subtle changes can signal a fault. The mechanism adaptively assigns weights to different parts of the signal, highlighting the most informative features for diagnosis.

The overall architecture involves:

  • Feature Extraction: Using convolutional layers to process raw vibration signals.
  • Local Attention Module: Enhancing feature representation by focusing on critical signal segments.
  • Domain Adaptation: Employing techniques to bridge the gap between source and target data distributions.
  • Classification: Predicting the health status of the reciprocating pump.

Datasets

The study utilizes vibration signal data collected from a CDWL25-0.4 reciprocating pump. Six vibration sensors were strategically placed on both the pump head and the machine foot. The dataset includes data for a "Normal state" and five types of naturally occurring faults: valve sealing surface compression, valve sealing surface erosion, valve sealing surface depression, check valve guide fracture, and valve assembly corrosion. For each operating condition, 1000 samples of 2048 data points each were collected. The data was split into 80% for training and 20% for testing in both source and target domains.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Sensor Location Matters Dramatically: The study clearly demonstrates that changing sensor locations significantly alters the data distribution, posing a major challenge for direct application of trained models.
  • Attention is Key for Transfer: Attention mechanisms, especially the proposed local variant, are crucial for improving the model's ability to learn transferable features that generalize across different sensor locations.
  • Local Focus Outperforms Global: The local attention mechanism's ability to zoom in on specific signal segments proves more effective for fault diagnosis than broader attention approaches. This is because subtle, localized anomalies are often the tell-tale signs of specific faults.
  • Pump Head is More Informative: Data from the pump head sensors generally leads to higher diagnostic accuracy, suggesting it captures more direct fault-related vibrations. This makes it a valuable source domain for training.
  • Proximity Matters: Even within sensor locations, proximity to the pump's drive mechanism (e.g., measurement points B and E) yields better diagnostic results, likely due to capturing more direct mechanical vibrations.

Key Results

The proposed method, incorporating the local attention mechanism, achieved superior performance compared to baseline CNN and other attention-based models (SENet, ECANet, GANet) in cross-sensor transfer tasks.

  • Task 1 (Pump Head to Machine Foot): The proposed method achieved an average accuracy of 94.15%, significantly outperforming CNN (61.43%), SENet (75.81%), ECANet (78.36%), and GANet (86.01%).
  • Task 2 (Machine Foot to Pump Head): The proposed method achieved an average accuracy of 90.80%, again surpassing CNN (56.81%), SENet (74.79%), ECANet (74.38%), and GANet (81.87%).
  • Visualization: t-SNE plots showed that the proposed method significantly increased the inter-class distance of learned features, leading to better separation and higher accuracy.
  • Confusion Matrices: The confusion matrices confirmed high diagnostic accuracy across all operating conditions, with minimal misclassifications, especially for the normal state.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Fault Classes: The study focused on five specific fault types. Future work could explore a wider range of fault classes.
  • Sensor Locations: While the study explored pump head and machine foot, investigating more complex sensor arrangements and locations could further enhance robustness.
  • Complex Environments: The experiments were conducted in a controlled industrial setting. Applying the method to even more challenging environments with higher noise levels or more complex machinery could be a valuable next step.
  • Real-time Application: While the method shows promise, further research into optimizing it for real-time fault diagnosis would be beneficial.

Summary updated

Abstract

Data-driven mechanical fault diagnosis has been successfully developed in recent years, and the task of training and testing data from the same distribution has been well-solved. However, for some large machines with complex mechanical structures, such as reciprocating pumps, it is often not possible to obtain data from specific sensor locations. When the sensor position is changed, the distribution of the features of the signal data also changes and the fault diagnosis problem becomes more complicated. In this paper, a cross-sensor transfer diagnosis method is proposed, which utilizes the sharing of information collected by sensors between different locations of the machine to complete a more accurate and comprehensive fault diagnosis. To enhance the model's perception ability towards the critical part of the fault signal, the local attention mechanism is embedded into the proposed method. Finally, the proposed method is validated by applying it to experimentally acquired vibration signal data of reciprocating pumps. Excellent performance is demonstrated in terms of fault diagnosis accuracy and sensor generalization capability. The transferability of practical industrial faults among different sensors is confirmed.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{wang2023novel,
  author = {Chen Wang and Ling Chen and Yongfa Zhang and Liming Zhang and Tian Tan},
  title = {{A Novel Cross-Sensor Transfer Diagnosis Method with Local Attention Mechanism: Applied in a Reciprocating Pump}},
  booktitle = {Sensors},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/s23177432},
}
Figure