A Novel Calculation Method of Process Load for Extra-Large Section Tunnels

Hongjie Gao, Ping He, Zheng Chen, Xinyu LiSymmetry 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "process design load" calculation method for extra-large section tunnels, addressing the limitations of traditional "state design" methods that overlook construction sequencing. By simulating excavation in stages and accounting for the influence of each step, the new method provides more accurate load predictions, validated against real-world data from the massive Liantang Tunnel.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The increasing demand for high-capacity transportation has led to the development of extra-large section highway tunnels. However, traditional methods for calculating the loads and surrounding rock pressures on these tunnels, which typically assume a single, instantaneous excavation (state design), are proving inadequate. These methods fail to account for the complex, multi-stage construction processes (e.g., sequential excavation, benching) employed in modern tunnel engineering. This oversight can lead to inaccurate load estimations, potentially compromising tunnel safety and design efficiency. The paper specifically targets this gap by proposing a method that considers the dynamic nature of tunnel construction.

Methods

The core of this paper is the development of a "process design load" calculation method. This approach contrasts with traditional "state design" methods by breaking down the excavation of an extra-large tunnel into a series of smaller, manageable steps, akin to excavating multiple small-span tunnels sequentially.

Key methodological elements include:

  • Simplification of Excavation: Complex excavation sequences (like double sidewall heading or median septum methods) are simplified into a series of "pilot tunnels."
  • Influence Coefficient ($\eta$): This new parameter quantifies how the excavation of one pilot tunnel affects the loosening load or scope of an adjacent pilot tunnel.
  • Weight Coefficient ($\alpha$): This coefficient represents the proportion of the vertical uniform load contributed by each pilot tunnel to the overall tunnel load.
  • Integration of Existing Theories: The process load calculation leverages established theories like Protodyakonov's theory and the Code for the Design of Road Tunnels for calculating the load of individual pilot tunnels.
  • Step-by-Step Calculation: The method involves calculating the load for each pilot tunnel, then combining these loads using the influence and weight coefficients to determine the overall process load.

Datasets

  • Liantang Tunnel Data: The primary dataset used for validation consists of on-site monitored surrounding rock pressure data from the Liantang Tunnel in Shenzhen, China. This data was collected during the tunnel's construction and second lining phase.
  • Geological and Mechanical Parameters: Mechanical parameters of the surrounding rock for various sections of the Liantang Tunnel (e.g., bulk density, cohesion, internal friction angle, RQD) were obtained from geological investigations and laboratory tests.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Construction Process Matters: The most significant insight is that the sequence and method of excavation profoundly impact the surrounding rock pressure, especially in extra-large tunnels. Ignoring this dynamic aspect leads to inaccurate load predictions.
  • "Process Load" vs. "State Load": The paper clearly distinguishes between "state load" (static, single excavation) and "process load" (dynamic, sequential excavation), highlighting the limitations of the former for modern tunnel projects.
  • Influence and Weight Coefficients: The introduction of $\eta$ and $\alpha$ provides a quantitative framework to model the interdependencies between excavation steps and their contribution to the overall load.
  • Validation is Crucial: The comparison of calculated process loads with actual monitored data from the Liantang Tunnel demonstrates the practical applicability and improved accuracy of the proposed method.

Key Results

  • Improved Accuracy: The calculated surrounding rock pressures using the process design method were found to be closer to the measured values compared to traditional state design methods. For instance, in the maximum section, the process load calculation yielded a value of 107.35 kPa (Protodyakonov) and 115.83 kPa (Code for Road Tunnels), which are significantly closer to the measured 94.34 kPa than the state design loads (125.81 kPa and 151.24 kPa, respectively).
  • Safety Factor: The process design method's results provided a more conservative and safer load estimation, indicating a better safety factor.
  • Methodological Agreement: Protodyakonov's theory and the Code for the Design of Road Tunnels, when applied within the process design framework, showed good agreement with each other, reinforcing the validity of the approach.
  • Impact of Excavation Sequence: The study showed that different excavation sequences within the same method (e.g., double sidewall heading) could lead to variations in calculated loads, underscoring the importance of detailed construction planning.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Subjectivity of Influence Coefficient: The authors acknowledge that the influence coefficient ($\eta$) was assigned based on expert opinion and engineering experience, introducing a degree of subjectivity. They suggest that further improvement is needed through extensive on-site testing and theoretical analysis.
  • Simplifications: The model assumes symmetrical tunnel sections and horizontal ground surface, which may not always reflect real-world conditions.
  • Future Research: The authors propose developing calculation methods for process loads that more accurately represent actual engineering realities, particularly concerning non-symmetrical conditions and more complex ground environments. Further research into refining the influence coefficient and exploring more advanced numerical modeling techniques is also suggested.

Summary updated

Abstract

The calculation of load and surrounding rock pressure of extra-large-section tunnels serves as an important premise for the design and construction of tunnel projects with extra-large sections. Based on the large-span section of the Shenzhen Liantang Tunnel (China), which is the largest highway tunnel in the world to date, this paper discusses the challenges existing in the calculation method of state load and surrounding rock pressure for extra-large-section tunnels and puts forward a novel calculation method for process load, which is suitable for extra-large-section highway tunnels. In the current work, we derived the related application correlations and improved the specific application steps, methods, and project models of the proposed calculation method. Both the rationality and feasibility of the calculation method were verified from a practical perspective by comparing the on-site data of surrounding rock pressure at the Liantang Tunnel with the calculated load, which provides a fundamental basis for the process design of tunnels.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{gao2019novel,
  author = {Hongjie Gao and Ping He and Zheng Chen and Xinyu Li},
  title = {{A Novel Calculation Method of Process Load for Extra-Large Section Tunnels}},
  booktitle = {Symmetry},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/sym11101228},
}
Figure