A Novel Balanced Reporting Innovation with Data Governance Evolution (BRIDGE) Method

Kunihiko Takamatsu, Sayaka Matsumoto, Koichi Akashi, Hibiki Ito, Takafumi Kirimura, Taion Kunisaki, Kenya Bannaka, Ikuhiro Noda, Ryosuke Kozaki, Aoi Kishida, Katsuhiko Murakami, Yasuo Nakata, Masao MoriIIAI 2025 · DOI

Abstract

The era of Society 5.0 demands both creativity and systematic knowledge implementation in organizational settings. However, there exists a significant gap between understanding new knowledge and its practical application. This paper proposes the Balanced Reporting Innovation with Data Governance Evolution (BRIDGE) method as a novel approach to facilitate the transition from intellectual understanding to unconscious competence in implementing new knowledge. Through the lens of Eduinformatics, we demonstrate how the BRIDGE method effectively integrates abductive reasoning for innovation while ensuring organizational acceptance. Using a case study from institutional research practices, we show how the method provides a structured transition period where traditional and innovative approaches coexist, enabling organizations to maintain operational continuity while implementing new methodologies. The BRIDGE method addresses the fundamental challenge of knowledge acceptance by acknowledging that while creativity and abduction are essential for generating new knowledge, successful implementation requires careful consideration of organizational dynamics. Our findings suggest that this method can be adapted for various organizational contexts where new knowledge needs to be effectively implemented and accepted, providing a practical framework for bridging the gap between innovation and adoption.

Introduction: The Knowledge Acceptance Gap

In the transition toward "Society 5.0," organizations face a persistent challenge: the gap between the creation of innovative tools and their actual adoption by stakeholders. While researchers utilize abductive reasoning to develop sophisticated automated systems, practitioners often resist these changes due to a fear of losing "data continuity"—the ability to compare new results with years of historical, manually generated data.

This bottleneck is best understood through Kirkpatrick’s levels of evaluation. As shown in Figure 1, a significant hurdle exists between Level 2 (Learning/Understanding) and Level 3 (Behavior/Implementation). Practitioners may understand that a new system is superior, but they often do not change their behavior until they trust the new system's reliability and comparability.

Kirkpatrick's levels of evaluation highlighting the gap between learning and behavioral implementation.

The BRIDGE Methodology

The paper introduces the BRIDGE (Balanced Reporting Innovation with Data Governance Evolution) method, developed through the framework of Eduinformatics. Eduinformatics is an interdisciplinary field that applies informatics to solve educational and organizational challenges by bridging the gap between problems and solving methods.

The conceptual framework of Eduinformatics, integrating Education and Informatics.

Core Components of the BRIDGE Method

  1. Parallel Implementation Strategy: Instead of a disruptive "hard cutover," the BRIDGE method proposes a transition period (e.g., one academic year) where reports are generated using both traditional manual workflows and new automated pipelines simultaneously. This "parallel run" allows stakeholders to verify the accuracy and continuity of the new system against the old.
  2. Technical Stack Transition: The method moves from manual Excel/Word workflows to an automated pipeline using Python for data processing and Quarto for report generation. Quarto was specifically selected for its ability to output to Microsoft Word, allowing non-technical staff to add qualitative "human-in-the-loop" insights.
  3. The ABDU-M Matrix: This framework helps researchers categorize tasks by abstractness and urgency, facilitating the generation of meaningful hypotheses (abduction) from complex datasets while maintaining a stable data governance foundation.

Case Study: Institutional Research at Institute of Science Tokyo

The BRIDGE method was applied to student survey data at the Institute of Science Tokyo. By implementing a parallel-run strategy for the 2024 academic year, the researchers successfully negotiated the transition with departments that were initially resistant to automation.

Key Results

  • Stakeholder Acceptance: The proposal of a "bridge" year mitigated fears regarding data comparability, leading to organizational buy-in.
  • Operational Efficiency: The Python/Quarto pipeline eliminated manual transcription errors and allowed for near-instantaneous updates to reports when underlying data changed.
  • Data Continuity: Publishing both versions of reports ensured that historical trends remained interpretable during the transition to full automation in 2025.

Conclusion

The BRIDGE method demonstrates that organizational resistance to innovation is often a rational response to the need for stability. By treating "comparability" as a core requirement rather than an obstacle, the method provides a structured path from intellectual understanding to unconscious competence. This framework offers a scalable solution for organizations seeking to implement data-driven innovations without sacrificing operational continuity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The era of Society 5.0 demands both creativity and systematic knowledge implementation in organizational settings. However, there exists a significant gap between understanding new knowledge and its practical application. This paper proposes the Balanced Reporting Innovation with Data Governance Evolution (BRIDGE) method as a novel approach to facilitate the transition from intellectual understanding to unconscious competence in implementing new knowledge. Through the lens of Eduinformatics, we demonstrate how the BRIDGE method effectively integrates abductive reasoning for innovation while ensuring organizational acceptance. Using a case study from institutional research practices, we show how the method provides a structured transition period where traditional and innovative approaches coexist, enabling organizations to maintain operational continuity while implementing new methodologies. The BRIDGE method addresses the fundamental challenge of knowledge acceptance by acknowledging that while creativity and abduction are essential for generating new knowledge, successful implementation requires careful consideration of organizational dynamics. Our findings suggest that this method can be adapted for various organizational contexts where new knowledge needs to be effectively implemented and accepted, providing a practical framework for bridging the gap between innovation and adoption.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{takamatsu2025novel,
  author = {Kunihiko Takamatsu and Sayaka Matsumoto and Koichi Akashi and Hibiki Ito and Takafumi Kirimura and Taion Kunisaki and Kenya Bannaka and Ikuhiro Noda and Ryosuke Kozaki and Aoi Kishida and Katsuhiko Murakami and Yasuo Nakata and Masao Mori},
  title = {{A Novel Balanced Reporting Innovation with Data Governance Evolution (BRIDGE) Method}},
  booktitle = {IIAI},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.52731/lbds.v005.352},
}
Figure