A noteworthy issue: microbiome data variation depending on sampling methods in skin microecology studies in acne vulgaris patients

Detian Xu, Qi Chen, Jiayi Yang, Guorong Yan, Linglin Zhang, Xiaojing Liu, Peiru Wang, Jia Liu, Xiuli WangFrontiers in Immunology 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

This study demonstrates that how you sample the skin—whether by swabbing the surface, pulling out follicular "plugs," or extracting acne comedones—drastically changes the microbiome data you collect. The researchers found that surface swabs fail to capture the unique microbial communities living deep within acne lesions, highlighting a critical need for standardized sampling in dermatological research.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The skin is a complex, three-dimensional landscape filled with "niches" like hair follicles, sweat glands, and sebaceous (oil) glands. Each niche has its own environment: the surface is oxygen-rich (aerobic), while the deep follicle is oxygen-poor (anaerobic).

Most microbiome studies rely on simple skin swabbing because it is non-invasive and easy. However, acne vulgaris is a disease of the pilosebaceous unit (PSU)—the deep part of the pore. If researchers only swab the surface, are they actually seeing the microbes responsible for acne, or just the "passers-by" on the surface? This paper investigates whether common sampling methods are interchangeable or if they provide fundamentally different biological "snapshots."

Methods

The researchers recruited 10 patients with mild-to-moderate acne and compared three distinct sampling methods on the same skin areas:

  1. Swab Sampling (S1): The standard method using sterile cotton swabs rubbed on the skin surface.
  2. Modified Standardized Skin Surface Biopsy (S2): A more specialized technique using a 20% gelatin and carbon powder mixture applied to cigarette paper. When peeled off, it pulls out "follicular casts"—the contents of the pores—without the need for invasive surgery.
  3. Individual Comedo Extraction (S3): Using a clinical acne extractor to physically remove the "plug" (comedo) from an active acne lesion.

The team then extracted DNA from these samples and performed high-throughput sequencing (16S rRNA for bacteria and 18S-ITS for fungi) to map the microbial communities.

Datasets

The study generated a primary dataset consisting of 30 samples (3 methods × 10 patients).

  • Bacterial data: 1,454,362 sequences (16S rRNA V3-V4 region).
  • Fungal data: 1,406,999 sequences (18S-ITS region). The trial was registered under the Chinese Clinical Trial Registry (identifier: ChiCTR-CPC-17012398).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Niche" Dictates the Population: Microbes aren't distributed randomly. Proteobacteria were abundant on the surface (S1), while Bacteroidota dominated the follicular casts (S2).
  • The Comedo is a Unique Micro-environment: The actual acne plug (S3) showed significantly higher levels of Staphylococcus and Malassezia (a fungus) compared to the surface or non-lesional pores. This suggests that the blockage itself creates a specific ecological "fortress" for these organisms.
  • Methodological Bias: The study reveals a major "aha moment": microbiome data is as much a reflection of the sampling tool as it is of the patient's health. A study using swabs might conclude a patient has a "healthy" profile, while a comedo extraction from the same spot might show significant dysbiosis (imbalance).

Key Results

  • Bacteria: Staphylococcus spp. were significantly higher in the extracted comedones (S3) than in surface swabs (S1) or follicular casts (S2) ($P < 0.05$).
  • Fungi: Malassezia spp. followed a similar pattern, being significantly more prevalent in the S3 samples ($P < 0.05$).
  • Diversity: PCA (Principal Component Analysis) plots showed that samples clustered more tightly by sampling method than by individual patient, proving that the method is a dominant variable in the resulting data.
  • S2 vs. S3: Interestingly, the modified biopsy (S2) was effective at capturing "normal" follicular contents but failed to capture the specific microbial signature of a well-developed acne comedo (S3).

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: With only 10 patients, the study is a pilot. Larger cohorts are needed to confirm these trends across different ethnicities and skin types.
  • Severity: The study only looked at mild-to-moderate acne; the microbiome of severe cystic acne might behave differently.
  • Static Snapshot: This was a cross-sectional study. Future work should include longitudinal sampling to see how these niche-specific microbiomes change during treatment.
  • Standardization: While S3 (extraction) provides the most relevant data for acne, it is harder to standardize than a swab. The authors call for a push toward "standardizing S3 for clinical use" to make future acne research more comparable.

Summary updated

Abstract

http://www.chictr.org.cn, identifier ChiCTR-CPC-17012398.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{xu2025noteworthy,
  author = {Detian Xu and Qi Chen and Jiayi Yang and Guorong Yan and Linglin Zhang and Xiaojing Liu and Peiru Wang and Jia Liu and Xiuli Wang},
  title = {{A noteworthy issue: microbiome data variation depending on sampling methods in skin microecology studies in acne vulgaris patients}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Immunology},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.3389/fimmu.2025.1566786},
}
Figure