A note on 2×2 block-diagonal preconditioning

Ben S. Southworth, Samuel S. OlivierarXiv 2020 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper investigates the convergence of block-diagonal preconditioners for solving 2x2 block linear systems, particularly when the Schur complement is exact. It demonstrates that, contrary to common assumptions for saddle-point systems, these preconditioners do not guarantee fixed-iteration convergence for general systems. The study also provides insights into when approximate Schur complements can be as effective as exact ones, even outperforming block-triangular methods in specific scenarios.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Solving large systems of linear equations is a cornerstone of scientific computing. For certain types of matrices, particularly those arising from discretizing partial differential equations, a common strategy is to use iterative methods. Preconditioners are crucial components of these iterative solvers, aiming to transform the original system into one that converges much faster. For 2x2 block matrices, block-triangular and block-LDU preconditioners with exact Schur complements are known to converge quickly (in at most two iterations). Similarly, for saddle-point matrices (where the (2,2) block is zero), block-diagonal preconditioners with exact Schur complements offer good convergence. However, the behavior of block-diagonal preconditioners with exact Schur complements for general 2x2 block matrices (where the (2,2) block is non-zero and not necessarily part of a saddle-point structure) was less understood. This paper aims to clarify this behavior, specifically addressing whether fixed-iteration convergence can be guaranteed and exploring the performance of approximate Schur complements.

Methods

The paper employs a theoretical approach, focusing on analyzing the eigenvalues of the preconditioned operator. For a 2x2 block matrix $A = \begin{pmatrix} A_{11} & A_{12} \\ A_{21} & A_{22} \end{pmatrix}$, the authors consider block-diagonal preconditioners of the form $D = \begin{pmatrix} D_{11} & 0 \\ 0 & D_{22} \end{pmatrix}$, where $D_{11}$ and $D_{22}$ are approximations of $A_{11}^{-1}$ and $A_{22}^{-1}$ (or related Schur complements). The core of the analysis involves deriving the spectrum (eigenvalues) of the preconditioned matrix $D^{-1}A$. This is achieved by transforming the problem into generalized eigenvalue problems involving the blocks of $A$ and their Schur complements. The authors then analyze these spectra to understand convergence properties for minimal residual methods (like GMRES). They also construct specific examples to illustrate their theoretical findings and compare the performance of different preconditioning strategies.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper focuses on theoretical analysis and uses constructed examples rather than real-world datasets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Block-diagonal preconditioners are not universally optimal: For general 2x2 block matrices (non-saddle-point), block-diagonal preconditioners with exact Schur complements do not guarantee convergence in a fixed number of iterations for minimal residual methods. This is a key departure from the known behavior for saddle-point systems.
  • Schur complement approximation matters: The performance of block-diagonal preconditioners can be sensitive to how well the Schur complement is approximated. In some cases, an approximate Schur complement can lead to convergence as fast as, or even faster than, a block-triangular preconditioner.
  • Symmetry and structure influence convergence: The paper highlights that for symmetric matrices, the behavior of preconditioners can differ, and the structure of the blocks (e.g., positive definite vs. indefinite) plays a significant role in convergence rates.
  • Practical implications for transport problems: The analysis is motivated by and applied to neutral-particle transport simulations, where different preconditioning strategies can have a substantial impact on computational cost.

Key Results

  • Theoretical Derivation: The paper provides a detailed derivation of the spectrum of preconditioned operators for various block-diagonal preconditioners ($D_+, D_-$) applied to general 2x2 block matrices. This spectrum is shown to be a nonlinear function of the generalized eigenvalues of the matrix blocks and their Schur complements.
  • Non-fixed Iteration Convergence: The derived spectra reveal that for general 2x2 block matrices, the eigenvalues of the preconditioned operator can lead to convergence that is not bounded by a small, fixed number of iterations, unlike the cases for saddle-point systems or block-triangular preconditioners.
  • Approximate vs. Exact Schur Complements: Examples are presented showing that block-diagonal preconditioning with an approximate Schur complement can perform comparably to or even better than block-triangular preconditioning. Conversely, exact Schur complements don't always offer a significant advantage over diagonal-only approximations in certain scenarios.
  • Application Example: In the context of neutral-particle transport, the paper illustrates that for certain problems, block-triangular or block-LDU preconditioners can be significantly faster than block-diagonal ones. However, for other problems, block-diagonal preconditioning might be superior in terms of speed and simplicity, especially when constructing the Schur complement is challenging.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Focus on 2x2 Blocks: The analysis is specifically for 2x2 block matrices. Extending these results to larger block sizes would be a natural next step.
  • Exact Schur Complement Analysis: While the paper explores approximate Schur complements, the primary theoretical focus is on the exact case. Further investigation into the optimal approximation strategies for block-diagonal preconditioners could be beneficial.
  • "Optimal" Operator Question: The paper poses an open question about whether there's a "different 'optimal' operator for the (2,2)-block" in block-diagonal preconditioning, suggesting avenues for future research into designing more effective preconditioners.
  • Practical Implementation Challenges: The paper touches upon the difficulty of constructing exact Schur complements in practical applications (like the VEF method), highlighting the need for robust approximate methods and careful selection of preconditioner types based on problem characteristics.

Summary updated

Abstract

For 2x2 block matrices, it is well-known that block-triangular or block-LDU preconditioners with an exact Schur complement (inverse) converge in at most two iterations for fixed-point or minimal-residual methods. Similarly, for saddle-point matrices with a zero (2,2)-block, block-diagonal preconditioners converge in at most three iterations for minimal-residual methods, although they may diverge for fixed-point iterations. But, what happens for non-saddle-point matrices and block-diagonal preconditioners with an exact Schur complement? This note proves that minimal-residual methods applied to general 2x2 block matrices, preconditioned with a block-diagonal preconditioner, including an exact Schur complement, do not (necessarily) converge in a fixed number of iterations. Furthermore, examples are constructed where (i) block-diagonal preconditioning with an exact Schur complement converges no faster than block-diagonal preconditioning using diagonal blocks of the matrix, and (ii) block-diagonal preconditioning with an approximate Schur complement converges as fast as the corresponding block-triangular preconditioning. The paper concludes by discussing some practical applications in neutral-particle transport, introducing one algorithm where block-triangular or block-LDU preconditioning are superior to block-diagonal, and a second algorithm where block-diagonal preconditioning is superior both in speed and simplicity.
BibTeX
@misc{southworth2020note,
  author = {Ben S. Southworth and Samuel S. Olivier},
  title = {{A note on 2×2 block-diagonal preconditioning}},
  year = {2020},
  eprint = {2001.00711},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2001.00711},
}

Loading related content...

Figure