A Non-perturbative Approach to Computing Seismic Normal Modes in Rotating Planets

Jia Shi, Ruipeng Li, Yuanzhe Xi, Yousef Saad, Maarten V. de HoopJ. Sci. Comput 2022 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, non-perturbative computational method to accurately calculate seismic normal modes in rotating planets, even with complex internal structures. This approach overcomes limitations of existing methods, enabling more precise modeling of planetary interiors and dynamics.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding seismic normal modes is crucial for probing the internal structure of planets, from their composition to temperature and anisotropy. However, accurately computing these modes, especially in rotating planets with fluid cores and complex heterogeneities, is computationally challenging. Existing methods often rely on approximations (like perturbation theory for rotation) or struggle with separating "essential" spectral components from the "point" spectrum (the physically relevant seismic modes). This paper aims to provide a unified, accurate, and efficient method that handles these complexities without resorting to approximations.

Methods

The authors present a Continuous Galerkin mixed finite-element method (FEM) to discretize the elastic-gravitational system of equations for rotating planets. Key innovations include:

  • Polynomial Filtering Eigensolver: This technique is crucial for separating the "essential spectrum" (which can arise from fluid regions and lead to spurious oscillations) from the "point spectrum" (the physically relevant seismic modes). This allows for accurate computation of the desired normal modes.
  • Mixed FEM: This approach discretizes the system using both displacement and pressure (or related variables) to handle fluid regions effectively.
  • Fast Multipole Method (FMM): Used to efficiently compute the self-gravitation effects, which are essential for planetary dynamics.
  • Fully Unstructured Tetrahedral Meshes: Allows for flexible modeling of complex geometries and heterogeneities within both solid and fluid planetary regions.
  • Extended Lanczos Vectors and Polynomial Filtering: Employed to solve the resulting generalized eigenvalue problem efficiently, especially for large-scale problems.

Datasets

The paper uses existing planetary models for validation:

  • Constant elastic balls: Used to validate results in the non-rotating case against analytical solutions.
  • Isotropic Earth models: Standard radial models (like PREM) are used for comparison with existing "radial" algorithms.
  • Earth and Mars models: Various heterogeneous models, including those incorporating crustal variations and core-mantle boundary topography, are used to study the effects of heterogeneity and rotation. Specific models mentioned include PREM, MIT models, and Mars models based on mineral physics calculations.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Separating Essential from Point Spectrum is Crucial: The paper highlights that ignoring the "essential spectrum" can lead to inaccurate or polluted results, especially in the presence of fluid layers. Their polynomial filtering approach effectively addresses this.
  • Non-Perturbative Approach for Rotation: By incorporating rotation directly into the FEM formulation and using advanced eigensolvers, they can compute modes in rotating planets without relying on perturbation theory, which is limited to slow rotation.
  • Unified Framework for Heterogeneity: The use of unstructured meshes and FEM allows for the modeling of arbitrary heterogeneities in both solid and fluid parts of a planet, a significant step beyond methods that assume spherical symmetry.
  • Computational Efficiency: The combination of FEM, FMM, and parallel eigensolvers enables the computation of normal modes for complex, large-scale planetary models.

Key Results

  • Validation: The method is validated against analytical solutions for simple cases and against existing algorithms for radial Earth models.
  • Accuracy: The method demonstrates high accuracy, with errors in eigenfrequencies typically below 0.3 µHz for Earth models and showing good convergence for Mars models.
  • Computational Performance: The paper showcases the scalability of their parallel algorithms on supercomputers, handling models with millions of elements.
  • Modeling Effects: The study successfully computes eigenfrequencies for various Earth and Mars models, demonstrating the ability to study the combined effects of rotation, heterogeneity, and self-gravitation on normal modes.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Slow Rotation Regime for Validation: While the method is designed for rotating planets, validation in the general rotating case is limited to the slowly-rotating regime where perturbation theory can still be applied, as independent algorithms for general rotating cases are scarce.
  • Viscoelastic Relaxation: The authors suggest that extending the model to include viscoelastic relaxation (e.g., Maxwell and Burger models) would be a valuable future direction, leading to nonlinear eigenvalue problems.
  • Non-Hydrostatic Assumption for Mars: For Mars, the assumption of hydrostatic equilibrium is noted to fail, requiring estimations based on linear interpolation of ellipticities.
  • Computational Cost: While efficient, the computation for very large models still requires significant computational resources.

The paper concludes by emphasizing the successful development of a robust method for computing seismic normal modes in complex, rotating planets, paving the way for more accurate geophysical modeling.

Summary updated

Abstract

A continuous Galerkin method based approach is presented to compute the seismic normal modes of rotating planets. Special care is taken to separate out the essential spectrum in the presence of a fluid outer core using a polynomial filtering eigensolver. The relevant elastic-gravitational system of equations, including the Coriolis force, is subjected to a mixed finite-element method, while self-gravitation is accounted for with the fast multipole method. Our discretization utilizes fully unstructured tetrahedral meshes for both solid and fluid regions. The relevant eigenvalue problem is solved by a combination of several highly parallel and computationally efficient methods. We validate our three-dimensional results in the non-rotating case using analytical results for constant elastic balls, as well as numerical results for an isotropic Earth model from standard “radial” algorithms. We also validate the computations in the rotating case, but only in the slowly-rotating regime where perturbation theory applies, because no other independent algorithms are available in the general case. The algorithm and code are used to compute the point spectra of eigenfrequencies in several Earth and Mars models studying the effects of heterogeneity on a large range of scales.
BibTeX
@article{shi2022non,
  author = {Jia Shi and Ruipeng Li and Yuanzhe Xi and Yousef Saad and Maarten V. de Hoop},
  title = {{A Non-perturbative Approach to Computing Seismic Normal Modes in Rotating Planets}},
  journal = {J. Sci. Comput.},
  year = {2022},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=D1G2JAt-yP},
}
Figure