A non-adaptive demographic mechanism for genome expansion in Streptomyces

Mallory J. Choudoir, Marko Järvenpää, Pekka Marttinen, Daniel H. BuckleybioRxiv 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This study investigates the puzzle of why some bacteria, like Streptomyces, possess unusually large genomes, a phenomenon that contrasts with the common trend of genome streamlining. The authors propose and provide evidence for a non-adaptive mechanism, termed "genome surfing," driven by demographic range expansion, which can lead to genome expansion by facilitating the accumulation of horizontally acquired genes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Microbial genomes are generally thought to evolve towards streamlining, meaning they become smaller and more efficient by shedding unnecessary genes. This is driven by a natural bias towards deletions over gene acquisitions, coupled with selection for efficiency. However, some microbes, such as Streptomyces, have remarkably large genomes. The mechanisms driving this genome expansion are less understood than those driving genome reduction. This paper aims to explain how such large genomes can arise and persist, particularly in the context of population demographics and evolutionary forces like selection and drift.

Methods

The study employed a multi-pronged approach:

  • Comparative Genomics: They sequenced and analyzed the genomes of 20 Streptomyces strains from distinct geographic regions (Northern-Derived - NDR, and Southern-Derived - SDR clades). This involved comparing genome size, gene content, GC content, and nucleotide diversity.
  • Phylogenetic Analysis: Whole genome alignments were used to reconstruct phylogenetic relationships, helping to understand the evolutionary history and divergence of the NDR and SDR clades.
  • Pangenome Analysis: The entire gene repertoire (pangenome) was analyzed to understand gene presence/absence patterns and frequency distributions across strains and clades.
  • Demographic Simulation: A population model was developed and modified from previous work to simulate gene gain and loss dynamics during population expansion, specifically incorporating relaxed selection and demographic changes. This allowed them to test their "genome surfing" hypothesis.

Datasets

The study utilized genomic data from 20 Streptomyces strains isolated from grassland sites across the United States. These strains were previously described and their genomes sequenced. Additional reference genomes were used for phylogenetic rooting.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Genome Surfing as a Driver of Expansion: The core idea is that during rapid geographic range expansion, populations experience a temporary period of relaxed selection and reduced effective population size. This "genome surfing" allows non-adaptive, horizontally acquired genes to increase in frequency and become established, leading to genome expansion.
  • NDR vs. SDR Divergence: The NDR clade, which likely expanded northward after glaciation, exhibits larger genomes, more genes, and a higher proportion of intermediate-frequency genes compared to the SDR clade. This is consistent with the genome surfing hypothesis.
  • Relaxed Selection in NDR: Evidence suggests that NDR genomes have experienced relaxed selection (indicated by higher KA/KS ratios), which would facilitate the persistence of non-adaptive genes.
  • Demographic History Matters: The study strongly links genome expansion to historical demographic events, specifically post-glacial range expansion, highlighting the importance of population history in shaping genome evolution.
  • Non-Adaptive Processes Can Lead to Large Genomes: The findings challenge the notion that large genomes are solely driven by adaptive selection for metabolic versatility. Instead, non-adaptive processes, amplified by demographic events, can be a significant driver.

Key Results

  • NDR genomes are significantly larger (8.70 ± 0.23 Mb) and contain more genes (7,775 ± 196) than SDR genomes (7.87 ± 0.19 Mb and 7,093 ± 205 genes, respectively).
  • NDR genomes show evidence of relaxed selection, with higher genome-wide KA/KS ratios compared to SDR genomes.
  • The NDR pangenome is larger and contains more clade-specific genes than the SDR pangenome.
  • NDR pangenomes are enriched in intermediate-frequency accessory genes, which are hypothesized to be recently acquired and non-adaptive.
  • Simulations demonstrated that population expansion under relaxed selection can lead to increased intermediate gene frequencies and genome expansion, supporting the genome surfing hypothesis.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Hypothesis Testing: While the study provides strong correlative evidence and simulation support, directly proving the "genome surfing" mechanism in a natural population remains challenging.
  • Adaptive vs. Non-Adaptive Genes: Distinguishing definitively between adaptive and non-adaptive genes, especially those at intermediate frequencies, is complex.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that further research could explore the specific genes involved in this expansion and investigate whether similar non-adaptive mechanisms are at play in other bacterial lineages with large genomes. Understanding the interplay between historical demography and genome evolution in other taxa would also be valuable.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract The evolution of microbial genome size is driven by gene acquisition and loss events that occur at scales from individual genomes to entire pangenomes. The equilibrium between gene gain and loss is shaped by evolutionary forces, including selection and drift, which are in turn influenced by population demographics. There is a well-known bias towards deletion in microbial genomes, which promotes genome streamlining. Less well described are mechanisms that promote genome expansion, giving rise to the many microbes, such as Streptomyces , that have unusually large genomes. We find evidence of genome expansion in Streptomyces sister-taxa, and we hypothesize that a recent demographic range expansion drove increases in genome size through a non-adaptive mechanism. These Streptomyces sister-taxa, NDR (northern-derived) and SDR (southern-derived), represent recently diverged lineages that occupy distinct geographic ranges. Relative to SDR genomes, NDR genomes are larger, have more genes, and their genomes are enriched in intermediate frequency genes. We also find evidence of relaxed selection in NDR genomes relative to SDR genomes. We hypothesize that geographic range expansion, coupled with relaxed selection, facilitated the introgression of non-adaptive horizontally acquired genes, which accumulated at intermediate frequencies through a mechanism known as genome surfing. We show that similar patterns of pangenome structure and genome expansion occur in a simulation that models the effects of population expansion on genome dynamics. We show that non-adaptive evolutionary phenomena can explain expansion of microbial genome size, and suggest that this mechanism might explain why some bacteria with large genomes can be found in soil.
BibTeX
@misc{choudoir2021non,
  author = {Mallory J. Choudoir and Marko Järvenpää and Pekka Marttinen and Daniel H. Buckley},
  title = {{A non-adaptive demographic mechanism for genome expansion in <i>Streptomyces</i>}},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1101/2021.01.09.426074},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure