A new section of shoulder magnetic resonance imaging(MRI) used to assess fat infiltration of rotator cuff muscles

Guoyin Zhang, Qi Hu, Jianmin Zhang, Lei Ying, De-Rong Hang, Xiaobo Zhou, Qingguo ZhangResearch Square 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Standard shoulder MRI protocols often overestimate muscle degeneration in patients with severe rotator cuff tears because the traditional "Y-view" looks at a section where retracted muscles appear artificially atrophied. This paper proposes a more medial sagittal section—the "r-view"—which provides a clearer, more reliable assessment of fat infiltration, potentially preventing surgeons from misclassifying reparable tears as irreparable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a rotator cuff tendon tears and retracts, the attached muscle doesn't just sit still; it pulls back toward the body (medialization) and begins to atrophy. A key factor in deciding whether to perform surgery is the "Goutallier classification," a grading system for how much fat has infiltrated the muscle. High fat content usually means a poor surgical outcome.

The clinical standard for this assessment is the scapular Y-view on an MRI. However, the authors noticed a major flaw: in massive tears, the muscle retracts so far that the Y-view only captures the thickened, "bunched up" end of the tendon and atrophied muscle tips. This leads to an overestimation of fatty degeneration. If a surgeon thinks a muscle is "all fat," they might opt against a repair that could have actually been successful.

Methods

The researchers conducted a retrospective study of 91 patients with MRI-confirmed rotator cuff tears. They categorized these patients into three groups based on the severity of tendon retraction (using the Patte classification):

  1. Group 1: Minimal retraction (near the bone insertion).
  2. Group 2: Retraction to the level of the humeral head.
  3. Group 3: Severe retraction to the level of the glenoid (the shoulder socket).

The team introduced the "r-view"—a sagittal MRI section taken at the level of the suprascapular notch. It is named "r-view" because the bony anatomy in this specific slice resembles the lowercase letter "r."

Three orthopedic surgeons independently graded the fat infiltration in both the traditional Y-view and the new r-view using the Goutallier scale. The researchers then used Interclass and Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICCs) to measure how much the surgeons agreed with each other (inter-observer) and how consistent they were with themselves over time (intra-observer).

Datasets

The study utilized a clinical dataset of 91 patients treated at the Taizhou Hospital of Zhejiang Province between April 2023 and January 2024.

  • Demographics: Mean age of 63.6 years; 31 men and 60 women.
  • Imaging: 1.5-T MRI scans of the shoulder.
  • Benchmarks: No external datasets were used; the study compared the new r-view against the established Y-view benchmark within the same patient cohort.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "r-view" is Medial and Stable: Because the r-view is located further toward the midline of the body than the Y-view, it captures the actual muscle belly of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus, even when they are severely retracted.
  • Reliability Overcomes Complexity: Assessing fat in a "messy" retracted tear is hard. The study found that surgeons agreed with each other significantly more often when looking at the r-view than the Y-view, especially in complex cases.
  • Avoiding the "False Positive" for Fat: The most striking insight is that the Y-view often makes a muscle look worse than it is. In severe tears (Group 3), the r-view showed significantly lower grades of fat infiltration. This suggests the Y-view might be "tricking" surgeons into seeing more fat than actually exists.

Key Results

  • Superior Reliability: In the r-view, the inter-observer agreement (ICC) was ≥ 0.80 across all groups, which is considered "excellent." In contrast, reliability in the Y-view dropped as the tears became more severe (falling to 0.67 for the supraspinatus in Group 3).
  • Significant Differences in Severe Cases: For patients with the most severe retraction (Group 3), there was a statistically significant difference ($P < 0.01$) between the two views. The Y-view consistently yielded higher (worse) Goutallier grades.
  • Repeatability: Intra-observer reliability for the r-view was also excellent (ICC ≥ 0.80), indicating that the view is easy for clinicians to interpret consistently.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations:

  • Sample Size: With only about 30 patients per group, the study is relatively small.
  • Lack of a "Gold Standard": While the r-view is more reliable (consistent), the study didn't compare MRI findings to a biopsy or surgical "ground truth" to definitively prove it is more accurate, though the anatomical logic is sound.
  • Clinical Correlation: The study doesn't yet show if using the r-view actually leads to better surgical outcomes or changed treatment plans.

Future Work: The researchers suggest larger studies to validate these findings and investigate whether the r-view is a better predictor of post-operative success in massive rotator cuff repairs.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> <bold>Background</bold> Accurately assessing the degree of fat infiltration in the rotator cuff muscles is essential. However, in patients with massive rotator cuff tears and significant retractions, assessing fat infiltration of the rotator cuff in the traditional scapular Y-view of Shoulder MRI is not very accurate. <bold>Purpose</bold> This study aimed to evaluate the reliability and reproducibility of the suprascapular notch sagittal section (r-view) for assessing fatty infiltration in the supraspinatus and infraspinatus muscles, with comparative analysis against the Y-view assessment results. <bold>Methods</bold> Magnetic resonance imaging data from 91 patients with rotator cuff tears(RTCs) were retrospectively analyzed. The patients were divided into three groups on the basis of the extent of retraction of rotator cuff tears. Fat infiltration of rotator cuff muscles was independently graded by three orthopedic surgeons via the Goutallier classification. The interclass and intraclass correlation coefficients(ICCs) were calculated to assess the consistency and repeatability of grading fat infiltration in the supraspinatus and infraspinatus using Y view and r view. The Wilcoxon rank-sum test was used to compare categorical variables of 3 groups (fat infiltration of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus graded in Y view and r view). <bold>Results</bold> In the 3 groups of patients, regardless of the supraspinatus or the infraspinatus, the interclass coefficients of fat infiltration grade in the r view were ≥ 0.80, with excellent interobserver agreement and reliability of evaluation. The intraclass coefficients of each reader for grading fat infiltration of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus in the r view were ≥ 0.80, indicating excellent intraobserver agreement and reproducibility. In the group with the most severe rotator cuff tear retraction, there was a significant difference in the degree of fat infiltration between Y view and r view. (P &lt; 0.01) <bold>Conclusion</bold> The r view utilized in this study is a new section for assessing the fat infiltration of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus. In contrast to the conventional Y view, assessing fatty infiltration of the supraspinatus and infraspinatus muscles in the r view demonstrates better reliability and reproducibility, with less influence from tendon retraction. <bold>Levels of Evidence</bold>: Level III
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2025new,
  author = {Guoyin Zhang and Qi Hu and Jianmin Zhang and Lei Ying and De-Rong Hang and Xiaobo Zhou and Qingguo Zhang},
  title = {{A new section of shoulder magnetic resonance imaging(MRI) used to assess fat infiltration of rotator cuff muscles}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.3.rs-5962402/v1},
}
Figure