A new section of shoulder magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) used to assess the fat infiltration of the rotator cuff muscles

Guoyin Zhang, Qi Hu, Jianmin Zhang, Lei Ying, De-Rong Hang, Xiaobo Zhou, Qingguo ZhangJournal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research 2025 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have identified a more reliable MRI slice, termed the "r-view" (at the suprascapular notch), for assessing fat infiltration in rotator cuff muscles. Unlike the traditional "Y-view," this new section remains accurate even when severe tendon retraction pulls muscle tissue away from the lateral shoulder, potentially preventing the misclassification of reparable tears as irreparable.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

When a rotator cuff tendon tears, the muscle doesn't just sit still; it often undergoes fatty infiltration—where muscle fibers are replaced by fat— and atrophy. Clinicians use the "Goutallier classification" (a 0–4 scale) to grade this fat. If the grade is too high (3 or 4), surgery is often avoided because the muscle is considered too "low quality" to heal.

The gold standard for this assessment has been the scapular Y-view on an MRI. However, there is a geometric catch: when a tear is massive, the muscle retracts medially (toward the spine). The traditional Y-view is a lateral slice. In severe cases, the Y-view might only show the thickened, retracted tendon stump rather than the actual muscle bulk. This leads to an overestimation of fat infiltration, potentially denying patients beneficial surgery based on a "false" reading of muscle quality.

Methods

The study retrospectively analyzed MRI data from 91 patients with rotator cuff tears. The researchers employed a few key classifications:

  • Patte Classification: Used to group patients by the severity of tendon retraction (Stage 1: near insertion; Stage 2: at humeral head; Stage 3: at glenoid level).
  • Goutallier Classification: Used by three independent orthopedic surgeons to grade fatty infiltration.
  • The "r-view": A sagittal section at the level of the suprascapular notch. It is named for the bony anatomy's resemblance to the lowercase letter "r."

To test reliability, the authors calculated Interclass and Intraclass Correlation Coefficients (ICCs) to see how much the three surgeons agreed with each other (inter-observer) and how much they agreed with their own previous readings (intra-observer).

Datasets

The study used a clinical dataset of 91 patients who underwent 1.5-T shoulder MRIs between April 2023 and January 2024.

  • Demographics: 31 men, 60 women; mean age 63.6 years.
  • Grouping: Patients were split into three groups based on retraction (Group 1: n=29; Group 2: n=32; Group 3: n=30).
  • Exclusions: Patients with prior shoulder surgery, dislocations, or abnormal bone structures were excluded to ensure a clean comparison of the MRI views.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Retraction Trap": In Group 3 (most severe retraction), there was a statistically significant difference ($P < 0.01$) between the Y-view and r-view grades. The Y-view consistently suggested worse fat infiltration because it was looking at the "empty" space or the scarred tendon stump left behind by the retreating muscle.
  • Anatomical Sweet Spot: Previous studies suggested the maximum cross-sectional area of the supraspinatus is located at the 0.6–0.7 position of the scapula. The r-view hits exactly this region, providing a "fuller" look at the muscle bulk compared to the more lateral Y-view.
  • Consistency is King: The r-view showed higher ICCs across the board. This suggests that the landmarks for the r-view (the suprascapular notch) are easier for surgeons to identify consistently than the "vaguely defined" Y-view, which can vary depending on exactly which slice a radiologist selects.

Key Results

  • Superior Agreement: For the r-view, both inter-observer and intra-observer ICCs were $\ge$ 0.80, indicating "excellent" agreement and reproducibility.
  • Reliability in Severe Cases: In patients with the most severe retraction (Group 3), the r-view remained highly reliable, whereas the Y-view's reliability declined as the muscle bulk moved out of frame.
  • Clinical Impact: The study found that a higher proportion of individuals were classified as Goutallier grade 3–4 (the "no surgery" zone) when using the Y-view compared to the r-view. Using the r-view could "rescue" these patients for surgical consideration.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Sex Imbalance: The study had nearly twice as many female patients as male patients, which might introduce biological variables not fully accounted for.
  • Sample Size: With only about 30 patients per group, larger cohorts are needed to generalize the findings.
  • Lack of "Ground Truth": The study compares two imaging techniques but does not correlate them with "gold standard" invasive measures like muscle biopsies or direct surgical observation of the muscle tissue.
  • Prognostic Validation: Future research needs to track whether patients cleared for surgery via the r-view actually have better post-operative outcomes compared to those graded by the Y-view.

Summary updated

Abstract

Level III.
BibTeX
@article{zhang2025new,
  author = {Guoyin Zhang and Qi Hu and Jianmin Zhang and Lei Ying and De-Rong Hang and Xiaobo Zhou and Qingguo Zhang},
  title = {{A new section of shoulder magnetic resonance imaging (MRI) used to assess the fat infiltration of the rotator cuff muscles}},
  journal = {Journal of Orthopaedic Surgery and Research},
  year = {2025},
  doi = {10.1186/s13018-025-05832-x},
}
Figure