A New Scope and Domain Measure Comparison Method for Global Convergence Analysis in Evolutionary Computation

Liu-Yue Luo, Zhi-Hui Zhan, Kay Chen Tan, Jun ZhangarXiv 2025 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Theoretical analysis of Evolutionary Computation (EC) algorithms often struggles with the complexity of proving global convergence, particularly for modern adaptive methods. This paper introduces the Scope and Domain Measure Comparison (SDMC) method, a simplified framework that bypasses the mathematical hurdles of traditional Markov chain modeling. By focusing on the geometric measure of an algorithm's search scope, the authors demonstrate that stable convergence and global convergence are often mutually exclusive. This insight allows for more robust algorithm design, as evidenced by significant performance gains in modified Particle Swarm Optimization (PSO) variants.

Theoretical Landscape of Convergence

In the field of Evolutionary Computation, "convergence" is a multifaceted term. Researchers typically distinguish between stable convergence—where individuals in a population stop moving or settle into a specific region—and global convergence, which guarantees that the algorithm will eventually locate the global optimum.

Hierarchy of theoretical analysis in Evolutionary Computation.

As shown in the hierarchy above, global convergence analysis is a critical branch of theoretical study that operates independently of specific problem information. However, establishing these proofs has historically been a significant challenge for the community.

Limitations of Traditional Methods

Traditionally, proving global convergence required modeling an algorithm as a homogeneous Markov chain. While mathematically rigorous, this approach faces two major hurdles. First, the complexity of the modeling is prone to error. Second, many high-performance modern algorithms use time-varying parameters (such as shrinking inertia weights), which makes them incompatible with the "homogeneous" requirement of standard Markov models.

The relationship between different classes of global convergence EC algorithms and the limitations of traditional Markov chain modeling.

The Venn diagram illustrates that traditional methods, such as Rudolph’s method, only recognize a subset of globally convergent algorithms. Many effective algorithms fall outside this scope because they cannot be modeled as homogeneous Markov chains or do not sample the global optimum area in every single generation.

The SDMC Framework

The proposed Scope and Domain Measure Comparison (SDMC) method offers a more flexible alternative. Instead of tracking every state transition, SDMC evaluates the "measure" (geometric volume) of the algorithm's search scope over time.

Core Logic

If the union of an algorithm's search scopes over a finite number of generations covers the entire feasible domain, the algorithm is considered globally convergent. This approach allows researchers to analyze adaptive algorithms without worrying about changing parameters, as long as the probability of reaching any point in the search space remains non-zero.

The Mutual Exclusivity Theorem

A pivotal contribution of this research is the formal proof that stable convergence and global convergence are often at odds. If an algorithm is designed to ensure all individuals eventually stabilize at a point, it inherently loses the ability to guarantee global convergence. To remain globally convergent, an algorithm must maintain a "leap" capability—the potential to reach any part of the domain indefinitely.

Empirical Validation and Results

The authors applied SDMC to analyze and improve existing algorithms. They discovered that popular methods like Linear Decreasing Inertia Weight PSO (LDIW-PSO) fail global convergence tests because their search scopes eventually vanish.

By applying SDMC insights to the Gene Targeting PSO (GTPSO), the authors replaced a shrinking Gaussian distribution with a constant-width distribution. This theoretical adjustment led to empirical success: the modified GTPSO outperformed the original version on 11 out of 12 standard benchmark functions, including high-dimensional tests up to $DIM=1000$.

Conclusion

The SDMC method provides a practical bridge between complex mathematical theory and algorithm engineering. By simplifying the requirements for global convergence, it enables the design of more reliable optimization tools that can handle the adaptive complexities of modern EC research. Future work will focus on developing measures to compare the relative "strength" of global convergence across different algorithm classes.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{luo2025new,
  author = {Liu-Yue Luo and Zhi-Hui Zhan and Kay Chen Tan and Jun Zhang},
  title = {{A New Scope and Domain Measure Comparison Method for Global Convergence Analysis in Evolutionary Computation}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2505.04089},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2505.04089},
}
Figure