A New Method to Monitor Flood Dynamics Using GPS Dual-Frequency CNR and a Strength-Based Threshold Constraint Strategy

Mingkun Su, Junyao Du, C. L. Philip Chen, Junna Shang, Lingsa PanAlgorithms 2026 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method for monitoring flood dynamics using GPS dual-frequency Carrier-to-Noise Ratio (CNR) signals. By analyzing fluctuations in CNR, particularly focusing on direct signals above a certain strength threshold, the method accurately tracks flood occurrence, peak, and recession, offering a cost-effective and weather-independent flood monitoring solution.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Traditional flood detection methods, like meteorological models and satellite remote sensing, have limitations. Meteorological models depend heavily on the accuracy of numerical models, while satellite methods can be hampered by weather conditions and temporal resolution. Floods, exacerbated by climate change, pose significant threats, necessitating more robust and accessible monitoring tools. The Carrier-to-Noise Ratio (CNR) of GPS signals is known to be affected by multipath effects, which are amplified in the presence of water due to its higher reflection coefficient compared to dry soil. This paper addresses the challenge of reliably using these CNR fluctuations to monitor the entire flood lifecycle, from its onset to its dissipation, while accounting for variations caused by different GPS satellites and frequencies.

Methods

The core of the proposed method lies in leveraging the sensitivity of GPS CNR to multipath effects caused by water. The authors developed a multi-step approach:

  1. Direct Signal CNR Extraction: To isolate the flood-induced multipath effects from other signal components, they first extract the "direct-signal CNR." This is achieved by applying a third-order polynomial fitting model to the raw CNR data, effectively filtering out indirect signal contributions.
  2. Strength-Based Thresholding: Recognizing that CNR is influenced by signal strength and that lower-strength signals are more susceptible to noise, the method focuses on direct-signal CNR values exceeding 45 dB-Hz. This "strength-constrained" approach aims to reduce the impact of random noise and improve the reliability of the CNR signal.
  3. Dual-Frequency CNR Analysis: The method utilizes both GPS L1 and L2 frequencies. By comparing the CNR between these frequencies and across different satellites, the authors account for inherent signal biases and satellite-specific characteristics.
  4. Threshold Model Establishment: A crucial step involves establishing a "strength-based threshold constraint strategy." This is done by analyzing long-term, non-flood CNR data from 64 globally distributed Multi-GNSS Experiment (MGEX) stations. This model defines the normal fluctuation range of CNR differences between adjacent days for direct-signal CNR values above 45 dB-Hz.
  5. Flood Monitoring: Flood events are detected when the observed CNR bias between consecutive days significantly exceeds this established threshold. The entire flood process is then monitored by tracking these deviations over time.

Datasets

The study utilized two main types of datasets:

  • MGEX Station Data: CNR data from 64 globally distributed MGEX stations were used to establish the dual-frequency CNR threshold model. These datasets were collected on DOY 200 and DOY 201, 2021.
  • Zhengzhou Station Data: Real GPS observation data from a specific station in Zhengzhou city, China, were used for experimental validation. This dataset covered DOY 198 to DOY 203, 2021, and included observations at both L1 and L2 frequencies with a 30-second sampling interval. This data allowed for the detailed tracking of a specific flood event.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • CNR as a Flood Indicator: The fundamental insight is that the CNR of GPS signals is a sensitive indicator of flood events due to the increased multipath effect from water surfaces.
  • Direct Signal is Key: Focusing on the "direct-signal CNR" is critical for isolating flood-related multipath effects from other signal interferences and noise.
  • Strength Matters: Filtering for CNR signals above a certain strength threshold (45 dB-Hz) significantly improves the robustness of the method against random noise.
  • Dual-Frequency Advantage: Utilizing both L1 and L2 frequencies helps to mitigate satellite-specific biases and provides a more comprehensive picture of signal behavior during a flood.
  • Threshold Model is Crucial: A statistically derived threshold model, based on extensive non-flood data, is essential for reliably distinguishing flood-induced CNR anomalies from normal variations.

Key Results

  • Threshold Model Accuracy: The established threshold model for direct-signal CNR (above 45 dB-Hz) showed an average difference between adjacent days of approximately 0.0659 dB-Hz (L1) and 0.0661 dB-Hz (L2).
  • Flood Event Detection: The method successfully identified the flood event in Zhengzhou, China, with the flood appearing around 16:04 PM on DOY 200, 2021.
  • Flood Progression Tracking: The study accurately tracked the flood's progression, noting a peak around 5:05 AM on DOY 202, 2021, and a complete recession by approximately 8:54 AM on the same day.
  • Improved Accuracy: The direct-signal CNR threshold was found to be significantly lower (approx. 0.07 dB-Hz) than the original CNR threshold (approx. 0.48 dB-Hz), demonstrating the effectiveness of the proposed method in improving accuracy by mitigating indirect signal influences.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest future research directions:

  • Receiver Dependency: CNR measurements can be influenced by receiver type, antenna characteristics, and firmware. While ensemble averaging was used, receiver-specific calibration might be needed for low-cost devices.
  • Environmental Interference: Other environmental factors like snow cover, vegetation, wet soil, and surrounding structures can also cause multipath effects and CNR variations, potentially leading to false positives. Future work could explore integrating auxiliary data (e.g., land cover, meteorological data) to improve discrimination.
  • Geographic Applicability: In non-urban or mountainous regions, sparse GNSS coverage and strong terrain-induced multipath effects might limit the method's applicability, potentially requiring site-specific thresholds.
  • False Positives: Temporary obstructions, construction, severe weather, or equipment malfunctions could also trigger false alarms. Future work could incorporate temporal consistency checks, spatial coherence analysis, and machine learning for adaptive thresholding.
  • Further Investigation: The authors suggest refining the threshold model with multi-event and multi-region datasets, exploring data fusion with SAR or optical observations, and using electromagnetic modeling to better understand signal-water interactions.

Summary updated

Abstract

The strength of a GPS carrier-to-noise ratio (CNR) signal is closely influenced by the multipath effect. This effect becomes more pronounced during flood events, as the reflection coefficient of water is significantly higher than that of dry soil. Consequently, the CNR measurements of GPS signals are impacted by floods. Based on this theory, the fluctuation of the CNR during a flood can be used to accurately monitor the process of a flood from occurrence to recession. Considering that the strength of the CNR largely depends on the satellite and frequency, and the characteristics of the influence of a flood on the CNR are different for each frequency, a new method based on the GPS dual-frequency direct signal CNR and the strength constraint threshold strategy was developed to increase the accuracy of the flood dynamics monitoring process. By using 64 MGEX (Multi-GNSS Experiment) stations distributed globally, an accurate direct-signal CNR threshold model of GPS dual-frequency was established. The threshold model demonstrated that the average difference of the direct-signal CNR, which is larger than 45 dB-Hz, between adjacent days at GPS L1 and L2 frequencies is 0.0659 dB-Hz and 0.0661 dB-Hz, respectively. Moreover, GPS real datasets in Zhengzhou city, China, from DOY (day of year) 199 to DOY 203, 2021, were collected to assess the proposed method. Based on the fluctuation of the direct-signal CNR threshold, the experimental results show that the flood appeared at about 16:04 PM on DOY 200, 2021, reached a peak at approximately 5:05 AM on DOY 202, and totally subsided at about 8:54 AM on DOY 202. Thus, the experiment results reveal that the proposed method accurately monitors the entire process of a flood from occurrence to recession, which provides valuable insights into operational flood dynamics, warning, and monitoring based on the GPS technique.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{su2026new,
  author = {Mingkun Su and Junyao Du and C. L. Philip Chen and Junna Shang and Lingsa Pan},
  title = {{A New Method to Monitor Flood Dynamics Using GPS Dual-Frequency CNR and a Strength-Based Threshold Constraint Strategy}},
  booktitle = {Algorithms},
  year = {2026},
  doi = {10.3390/a19020121},
}
Figure