A new graph-based surrogate model for rapid prediction of crashworthiness performance of vehicle panel components

Haoran Li, Yingxue Zhao, Haosu Zhou, Tobias Pfaff, Nan LiarXiv 2025 · arXiv · OpenReview

Abstract

During the design cycle of safety-critical vehicle components such as B-pillars, crashworthiness performance is a key metric for passenger protection assessment. Traditional finite element (FE) simulations involve complex modeling and high computational demand. While machine learning surrogate models offer rapid predictions, they often struggle with complex 3D geometries and temporal stability. This paper proposes Recurrent Graph U-Net (ReGUNet), a new graph-based surrogate model for crashworthiness analysis. ReGUNet adopts a U-Net architecture with multiple graph downsampling and upsampling layers to improve efficiency and accuracy, while a recurrent mechanism enhances the stability of temporal predictions. Evaluated on a B-pillar side-crash case study, ReGUNet achieved a relative error of only 0.74% for maximum intrusion, reducing average prediction error by over 51% compared to baseline models with significantly improved computational efficiency.

Introduction

In automotive engineering, crashworthiness—the ability of a vehicle to protect its occupants during a collision—is a non-negotiable safety metric. Traditionally, engineers rely on high-fidelity Finite Element (FE) simulations to test designs. While accurate, these simulations are computationally expensive, often taking hours or days to run. This creates a bottleneck during the design phase, where engineers must iterate through hundreds of geometric variations.

Machine learning surrogate models aim to provide near-instant predictions by "learning" the underlying physics. However, standard neural networks struggle with the irregular, non-Euclidean geometry of 3D vehicle parts. While Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) are better suited for this data, they face two primary challenges: efficiency when processing thousands of nodes in a fine mesh, and temporal instability, where small errors accumulate over time steps, leading to physically unrealistic "rollout errors."

Methodology: The ReGUNet Architecture

ReGUNet addresses these challenges through three main innovations:

1. Graph U-Net Architecture

Similar to U-Nets used in image processing, ReGUNet utilizes hierarchical downsampling and upsampling layers. By creating "coarsened" versions of the mesh, information can travel across the entire component much faster. This allows the model to capture long-range physical dependencies—such as how an impact at the base of a pillar affects its top—without requiring hundreds of expensive message-passing steps.

The hierarchical graph coarsening process used in ReGUNet to enable multi-scale feature learning.

2. Recurrence (Re-MP)

The model incorporates a recurrent mechanism (similar to a Gated Recurrent Unit) that propagates a "hidden state" across time steps. This acts as a temporal memory, ensuring that the prediction at step t+1 is physically consistent with step t, significantly smoothing the resulting deformation and preventing digital noise or "waviness."

3. Hybrid Downsampling

The model uses a two-tier approach: standard message passing at the finest level to handle varying mesh sizes, and "non-shareable weight" layers (DS-NW) at coarser levels. These DS-NW layers assign unique, trainable weights to specific edges, boosting accuracy for the shared structural features of the component.

Experimental Setup and Dataset

The model was trained and evaluated on a custom dataset of side-impact crash tests for a B-pillar component. Data was generated using high-fidelity FE simulations (PAM-CRASH), resulting in 200 samples (100 training, 50 validation, 50 testing). The geometry of the B-pillar was modified using mesh morphing and Latin Hypercube Sampling to ensure a diverse range of designs.

Overview of the B-pillar component (a), its graph representation (b), and the temporal sequence of deformation (c).

Each sample consists of a sequence of 12 graphs representing the component's deformation over 18 milliseconds. The use of multi-scale passing proved essential; by downsampling, the "receptive field" of the network grows, allowing it to understand the global structure of the part rather than just local clusters.

Key Results

ReGUNet demonstrates significant improvements over existing graph-based approaches:

  • High Precision: The model predicted maximum B-pillar intrusion with a maximum relative error of only 0.74%.
  • Superior Accuracy: ReGUNet reduced the mean prediction error by 51% compared to the best-performing baseline that lacked downsampling.
  • Efficiency: The model used significantly less GPU memory (9.5 GB) compared to a non-downsampled recurrent baseline (20.3 GB), proving that hierarchical structures are essential for scaling GNNs to industrial-sized meshes.
  • Stability: The "rollout error" was significantly lower and grew more slowly than in non-recurrent models, maintaining physical realism throughout the crash sequence.

Conclusion

ReGUNet represents a major step forward in applying deep learning to safety-critical automotive design. By combining hierarchical graph structures with temporal recurrence, the model achieves industrial-grade accuracy and efficiency. Future work will focus on extending the model to predict other vital metrics like crash force distribution and testing it on more complex, multi-part assemblies.

Summary updated

Abstract

During the design cycle of safety critical vehicle components such as B-pillars, crashworthiness performance is a key metric for passenger protection assessment in vehicle accidents. Traditional finite element simulations for crashworthiness analysis involve complex modelling, leading to an increased computational demand. Although a few machine learning-based surrogate models have been developed for rapid predictions for crashworthiness analysis, they exhibit limitations in detailed representation of complex 3D components. Graph Neural Networks (GNNs) have emerged as a promising solution for processing data with complex structures. However, existing GNN models often lack sufficient accuracy and computational efficiency to meet industrial demands. This paper proposes Recurrent Graph U-Net (ReGUNet), a new graph-based surrogate model for crashworthiness analysis of vehicle panel components. ReGUNet adoptes a U-Net architecture with multiple graph downsampling and upsampling layers, which improves the model's computational efficiency and accuracy; the introduction of recurrence enhances the accuracy and stability of temporal predictions over multiple time steps. ReGUNet is evaluated through a case study of side crash testing of a B-pillar component with variation in geometric design. The trained model demonstrates great accuracy in predicting the dynamic behaviour of previously unseen component designs within a relative error of 0.74% for the maximum B-pillar intrusion. Compared to the baseline models, ReGUNet can reduce the averaged mean prediction error of the component's deformation by more than 51% with significant improvement in computational efficiency. Provided enhanced accuracy and efficiency, ReGUNet shows greater potential in accurate predictions of large and complex graphs compared to existing models.
BibTeX
@misc{li2025new,
  author = {Haoran Li and Yingxue Zhao and Haosu Zhou and Tobias Pfaff and Nan Li},
  title = {{A new graph-based surrogate model for rapid prediction of crashworthiness performance of vehicle panel components}},
  year = {2025},
  eprint = {2503.17386},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2503.17386},
}
Figure