A New Encrypted Data Switching Protocol: Bridging IBE and ABE Without Loss of Data Confidentiality

Kai He, Yijun Mao, Jianting Ning, Kaitai Liang, Xinyi Huang, Emmanouil Panaousis, George LoukasIEEE Access 2019 · DOI

Abstract

Modern cloud storage necessitates flexible yet secure data sharing mechanisms. While Identity-Based Encryption (IBE) and Attribute-Based Encryption (ABE) offer robust protection for specific users and groups respectively, they are typically incompatible, requiring decryption and re-encryption to switch formats. This paper, published in IEEE Access, introduces a novel Encryption Switching Protocol (ESP) that enables a semi-trusted proxy to convert data between IBE and ABE formats without ever accessing the raw plaintext. By leveraging Proxy Re-Encryption (PRE) and established cryptographic schemes, the protocol ensures data confidentiality while significantly reducing the computational burden on end-users.

Introduction

In the landscape of cloud-based data management, two primary encryption paradigms dominate: Identity-Based Encryption (IBE) and Attribute-Based Encryption (ABE). IBE allows data to be targeted to a specific recipient (e.g., "[email protected]"), whereas ABE enables access based on descriptive attributes (e.g., "Manager" in "Accounting").

A significant challenge arises when data needs to transition between these formats. Traditionally, this requires a gateway to decrypt the data and then re-encrypt it in the new format. This "static" approach creates a critical security vulnerability, as the gateway temporarily possesses the raw, sensitive data. To address this, the authors propose a "bridge" protocol that transforms the mathematical "envelope" of the ciphertext without opening it, maintaining end-to-end confidentiality during the transition.

Methods

The proposed Encryption Switching Protocol (ESP) is built upon the foundation of Proxy Re-Encryption (PRE). In this framework, a data owner provides a semi-trusted proxy (such as a cloud provider) with a re-encryption key. This key allows the proxy to perform mathematical transformations on the ciphertext to change its encryption format without gaining any knowledge of the underlying plaintext.

Technical Components

  • Cryptographic Foundations: The protocol integrates two well-vetted schemes: Waters-ABE for attribute-based logic and Boneh-Boyen IBE (BB-IBE) for identity-based logic.
  • Bidirectional Conversion: Unlike previous unidirectional attempts, this protocol supports both ABE $\rightarrow$ IBE and IBE $\rightarrow$ ABE transitions.
  • Security Analysis: The construction is proven secure in the Standard Model against Chosen Plaintext Attacks (CPA). The security proof relies on the $q$-decisional parallel bilinear Diffie-Hellman exponent assumption, a rigorous standard in modern cryptography.

Performance Evaluation

The researchers evaluated the protocol's performance using the MIRACL library on an Intel i7 processor, simulating access policies with 10 to 100 attributes. The performance was compared against a "naive" approach where the client manually downloads, decrypts, and re-uploads data.

Computational Efficiency

A primary advantage of the ESP is the offloading of computational tasks. ABE decryption is typically "heavy," with complexity increasing linearly with the number of attributes. By converting ABE ciphertexts to IBE at the cloud level, the end-user only needs to perform a "light" IBE decryption, which takes constant time regardless of the original policy's complexity.

Key Results

  • ABE $\rightarrow$ IBE: For a policy with 100 attributes, re-encryption at the cloud proxy takes approximately 0.88 seconds. The subsequent decryption for the user is highly efficient, requiring only 0.1 seconds.
  • IBE $\rightarrow$ ABE: This direction is more computationally intensive due to the inherent complexity of ABE structures, with decryption taking roughly 2.5 seconds.
  • Communication Overhead: The protocol significantly reduces the data volume the client must transmit and receive compared to naive decryption/re-encryption methods.

Discussion and Conclusion

The ESP provides a robust solution for dynamic data sharing in the cloud. It features collusion resistance, ensuring that even if the cloud proxy and a recipient cooperate, they cannot recover the original sender's secret keys. Furthermore, its "plug-in" architecture allows it to work with existing cryptographic standards rather than requiring a complete overhaul of encryption systems.

Limitations and Future Directions

While the protocol achieves sub-second speeds for many operations, the 2.5-second latency for IBE $\rightarrow$ ABE conversion may be prohibitive for real-time or low-power IoT applications. Future research will focus on strengthening security by moving from CPA to Chosen Ciphertext Attack (CCA) security and exploring simulation-based security models to provide even stronger guarantees against sophisticated adversaries.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{he2019new,
  author = {Kai He and Yijun Mao and Jianting Ning and Kaitai Liang and Xinyi Huang and Emmanouil Panaousis and George Loukas},
  title = {{A New Encrypted Data Switching Protocol: Bridging IBE and ABE Without Loss of Data Confidentiality}},
  journal = {IEEE Access},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1109/access.2019.2906290},
}
Figure