A New Dual-Mass MEMS Gyroscope Fault Diagnosis Platform

Rang Cui, Tiancheng Ma, Wenjie Zhang, Min Zhang, Longkang Chang, Ziyuan Wang, Jingzehua Xu, Wei Wei, Huiliang CaoMicromachines 2023 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, self-feedback fault diagnosis platform for dual-mass MEMS gyroscopes, built using MATLAB/Simulink. The platform can effectively identify seven types of gyroscope signals, achieving up to 92.86% accuracy in simulations and 100% accuracy on real-world drift fault data, addressing the challenge of limited fault datasets.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

MEMS gyroscopes are critical components in navigation systems, and their reliability is paramount. However, ensuring this reliability is challenging due to the complexity of modern systems, which increases the likelihood of failures. Diagnosing faults in these gyroscopes is crucial for maintaining navigation accuracy and safety. The primary hurdles in developing effective fault diagnosis systems are the high cost of fabricating gyroscopes and the difficulty in obtaining comprehensive fault datasets. This makes it hard to train and validate robust diagnostic models. This paper aims to overcome these challenges by proposing a flexible, self-feedback platform that can simulate faults, extract features, and classify them, while also allowing for real-world data verification.

Methods

The core of this work is a novel "self-feedback development framework" for a dual-mass MEMS gyroscope fault diagnosis platform. This platform integrates several key components:

  • Dual-mass MEMS Gyroscope Simulink Structure Model: A detailed simulation model of the gyroscope's mechanical structure, including drive and sense modes, coupling, and thermal noise, is developed in Simulink.
  • Measurement and Control System Simulation: The platform simulates the gyroscope's measurement and control system, allowing for realistic signal generation.
  • Fault Signal Generation: The platform can generate seven distinct signal types: normal, bias, blocking, drift, multiplicity, periodic, and internal fault. This is crucial for creating a diverse dataset for training and testing.
  • Data Feature Extraction: Variational Mode Decomposition (VMD) is used to decompose the gyroscope signals into intrinsic mode components (IMFs). Subsequently, Sample Entropy (SE) is applied to extract features from these IMFs, capturing the signal's complexity and self-similarity.
  • Classification Algorithms: Six different machine learning algorithms were evaluated for fault classification: Extreme Learning Machine (ELM), Support Vector Machine (SVM), K-Nearest Neighbors (KNN), Naive Bayes (NB), Neural Network (NN), and Decision Tree Algorithm (DTA).
  • Self-Feedback Loop: The platform is designed as a complete self-feedback system, allowing for simulation, feature extraction, classification, and then verification with real data. It also includes interfaces for users to program and test their own algorithms.

Datasets

The paper utilizes simulated datasets generated by the platform for training and testing. Specifically, sixty-seven sets of signals were generated, with forty sets used for training and twenty-seven for testing. The platform can generate seven types of signals: normal, bias, blocking, drift, multiplicative, periodic, and internal fault.

For experimental verification, a drift fault dataset was collected from an actual dual-mass MEMS gyroscope under varying temperature conditions.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The Power of Simulation for Fault Diagnosis: The platform's ability to generate diverse fault types in a simulated environment is a significant advantage, overcoming the practical difficulties of acquiring real-world fault data.
  • VMD and SE as Effective Feature Extractors: The combination of Variational Mode Decomposition (VMD) and Sample Entropy (SE) proves to be a robust method for extracting meaningful features from gyroscope signals, even in the presence of noise and faults.
  • ELM and SVM as Top Performers: Among the tested algorithms, ELM and SVM demonstrated superior performance in classifying gyroscope faults, highlighting their suitability for this application.
  • Real-World Validation is Crucial: The successful validation of the ELM algorithm on actual drift fault data, achieving 100% accuracy, underscores the platform's practical applicability and the effectiveness of the developed fault diagnosis approach.
  • Flexibility for Algorithm Development: The platform's design, with its open interfaces for custom algorithms, makes it a valuable tool for researchers to test and refine new fault diagnosis techniques.

Key Results

  • Simulation Accuracy: The ELM and SVM algorithms achieved the highest classification accuracy on the simulated test set, reaching 92.86%.
  • Specific Fault Identification: ELM and SVM were able to identify 100% of bias, blocking, drift, periodic, and internal fault signals in the simulation.
  • Experimental Verification: The ELM algorithm, when applied to real drift fault data collected under temperature variations, achieved 100% recognition accuracy, successfully identifying all drift faults.
  • Algorithm Comparison: While ELM and SVM performed best, other algorithms like KNN and NB showed decent accuracy (around 89.29%), with varying performance across different fault types. NN and DTA had slightly lower accuracies (85.71% and 82.14%, respectively).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Limited Fault Types in Real Data: While the platform can simulate seven fault types, the experimental verification primarily focused on drift faults. Expanding real-world data collection to include a wider range of fault types would further strengthen the validation.
  • Generalizability to Other Gyroscope Types: The platform is specifically designed for dual-mass MEMS gyroscopes. Future work could explore its adaptability to other gyroscope architectures.
  • Real-time Implementation: The current platform is a simulation and development framework. Implementing this system for real-time fault diagnosis in actual navigation systems would be a logical next step.
  • Algorithm Optimization: The paper mentions reserving interfaces for users to optimize algorithms. Further research could focus on developing more advanced or specialized algorithms for even higher accuracy and faster detection.

Summary updated

Abstract

MEMS gyroscopes are one of the core components of inertial navigation systems. The maintenance of high reliability is critical for ensuring the stable operation of the gyroscope. Considering the production cost of gyroscopes and the inconvenience of obtaining a fault dataset, in this study, a self-feedback development framework is proposed, in which a dualmass MEMS gyroscope fault diagnosis platform is designed based on MATLAB/Simulink simulation, data feature extraction, and classification prediction algorithm and real data feedback verification. The platform integrates the dualmass MEMS gyroscope Simulink structure model and the measurement and control system, and reserves various algorithm interfaces for users to independently program, which can effectively identify and classify seven kinds of signals of the gyroscope: normal, bias, blocking, drift, multiplicity, cycle and internal fault. After feature extraction, six algorithms, ELM, SVM, KNN, NB, NN, and DTA, were respectively used for classification prediction. The ELM and SVM algorithms had the best effect, and the accuracy of the test set was up to 92.86%. Finally, the ELM algorithm is used to verify the actual drift fault dataset, and all of them are successfully identified.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cui2023new,
  author = {Rang Cui and Tiancheng Ma and Wenjie Zhang and Min Zhang and Longkang Chang and Ziyuan Wang and Jingzehua Xu and Wei Wei and Huiliang Cao},
  title = {{A New Dual-Mass MEMS Gyroscope Fault Diagnosis Platform}},
  booktitle = {Micromachines},
  year = {2023},
  doi = {10.3390/mi14061177},
}
Figure