A new conjecture concerning the Diophantine equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$

Zhenfu Cao, Xiaolei Dong, Zhong LiProceedings of the Japan Academy Series A Mathematical Sciences 2002 · DOI

Abstract

In this paper, we utilize recent advancements in the theory of primitive divisors to address a specific case of a long-standing conjecture in number theory. We prove that for constants $a, b,$ and $c$ derived from Gaussian integers under specific modular constraints, the exponential Diophantine equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$ possesses exactly one unique solution in positive integers. This result leverages the landmark work of Bilu, Hanrot, and Voutier on Lucas sequences to constrain the possible values of the exponents $y$ and $z$.

Introduction

Diophantine equations—polynomial equations requiring integer solutions—represent some of the oldest problems in mathematics. While the Pythagorean theorem $a^2 + b^2 = c^2$ is well-understood, "exponential" Diophantine equations, where the exponents themselves are variables, present a significantly higher level of complexity.

In 1993, N. Terai conjectured that for a primitive Pythagorean triple $(a, b, c)$ satisfying $a^2 + b^2 = c^2$, the equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$ should have only the solution $(a, 2, 2)$. This paper, published in the Proceedings of the Japan Academy, extends this line of inquiry to a more generalized class of equations, providing a rigorous proof for a specific set of conditions where the bases are generated by powers of Gaussian integers.

Mathematical Framework

The authors focus on equations where the bases $a, b,$ and $c$ are generated through Gaussian integers (complex numbers of the form $m + ni$). Specifically, they consider the real and imaginary parts of the expression $(m + \sqrt{-1})^r$.

Lucas Sequences and Gaussian Integers

The values $a$ and $b$ are defined as:

  • $a = |V_r|$
  • $b = |U_r|$
  • $c = m^2 + 1$

Here, $V_r$ and $U_r$ are integers satisfying the relation $(m + \sqrt{-1})^r = V_r + U_r \sqrt{-1}$. This formulation links the Diophantine problem to the theory of Lucas sequences—sequences defined by linear recurrences, similar to the Fibonacci sequence.

The Theory of Primitive Divisors

The core of the proof relies on the landmark 2001 result by Bilu, Hanrot, and Voutier concerning primitive divisors. A primitive divisor of the $n$-th term in a Lucas sequence is a prime factor that has not appeared in any preceding term. Bilu et al. established that for any index $n > 30$, such a divisor must exist.

By applying this theory, the authors demonstrate that any hypothetical second solution to $x^2 + b^y = c^z$ would contradict the established properties of these sequences. The proof involves a systematic examination of "defective" cases—small values of $n$ where primitive divisors might be absent—to confirm that no alternative solutions exist.

Key Insights and Constraints

A significant contribution of this research is the refinement of the conjecture's parameters. The authors highlight that without the constraint $y, z > 1$, the conjecture fails. They provide a concrete counterexample using $\epsilon = 7 + 4\sqrt{3}$ to demonstrate that multiple solutions can exist if these constraints are relaxed.

Furthermore, the proof assumes that $b$ is a prime power ($b = p^k$) and satisfies the condition $b \equiv 3 \pmod 4$. These restrictions allow for the application of specific lemmas regarding primitive divisors, effectively narrowing the possible values for the exponents until only the unique solution remains.

Main Results

The primary result of the paper is summarized in the following theorem:

Theorem: Let $a = |V_r|$, $b = |U_r|$, and $c = m^2 + 1$. If $b$ is a prime power such that $b \equiv 3 \pmod 4$, then the Diophantine equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$ has only the positive integer solution $(x, y, z) = (a, 2, r)$, where $r > 1$ is an odd integer and $m$ is an even natural number.

From this theorem, the authors derive a notable corollary: For any $m > 1$, if $3m^2 - 1$ is a prime power, then the equation $x^2 + (3m^2 - 1)^y = (m^2 + 1)^z$ has only the solution $(m^3 - 3m, 2, 3)$.

Conclusion

While this paper provides a definitive proof for a specific class of exponential Diophantine equations, it also underscores the difficulty of the general problem. The current proof is limited by the requirement that $b$ be a prime power and the specific modular constraint $b \equiv 3 \pmod 4$. Future research may focus on relaxing these conditions, particularly investigating cases where $b$ is a composite number with multiple distinct prime factors. However, as the authors note, proving the general version of the conjecture remains a formidable challenge that likely requires the development of new analytical techniques beyond the current understanding of Lucas sequences.

Summary updated

Abstract

In this paper, using a recent result of Bilu, Hanrot and Voutier on primitive divisors, we prove that if $a = |V_r|$, $b = |U_r|$, $c = m^2 + 1$, and $b \equiv 3 \pmod{4}$ is a prime power, then the Diophantine equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$ has only the positive integer solution $(x,y,z) = (a,2,r)$, where $r > 1$ is an odd integer, $m \in \mathbf{N}$ with $2 \mid m$ and the integers $U_r$, $V_r$ satisfy $(m + \sqrt{-1} )^r = V_r + U_r \sqrt{-1}$.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{cao2002new,
  author = {Zhenfu Cao and Xiaolei Dong and Zhong Li},
  title = {{A new conjecture concerning the Diophantine equation $x^2 + b^y = c^z$}},
  booktitle = {Proceedings of the Japan Academy Series A Mathematical Sciences},
  year = {2002},
  doi = {10.3792/pjaa.78.199},
}
Figure