A New Comprehensive Evaluation Method for Construction Results of the Power System Communication Networks

Biyao Huang, Guojun Liu, Huixia Ding, Yunpo Wang, Qi Yang, Ying Zhang2015 · DOI

Abstract

The communication channel, which provides information transmission for remote monitoring, control, and protection, plays a vital role in the development of smart grids. As the world's largest electric power communication network has been established in China, sophisticated professional management is increasingly necessary. This paper proposes a comprehensive evaluation method for construction results using a top-down analysis approach, combining the Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) and Fuzzy Decision Theory (FDT) to quantify planning, construction, and management performance.

Introduction

Modern power enterprises depend heavily on high-speed, broadband communication networks for office automation and management information. These networks carry critical business data and guarantee the security and stability of grid operations. However, evaluating the success of massive infrastructure projects is complex due to the diversity of qualitative and quantitative factors involved. Traditional management often lacks a standardized, top-down method to synthesize metrics like "growth rate of optical cables" and "investment effectiveness" into a single, credible score. This research addresses this gap by providing a mathematical framework to bridge raw technical data with high-level decision-making.

Methodology

The proposed evaluation framework utilizes a two-stage hybrid approach:

1. Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP)

AHP is employed to determine the relative weights of various factors. The evaluation is organized into a three-level hierarchy:

  • Top Level (A): Overall Construction Result.
  • Middle Level (B): Equipment Levels (B1), Network Reliability (B2), and Effectiveness of Investment (B3).
  • Bottom Level (C): Nine specific indices (C1–C9), including business growth rates, resource utilization, and price-per-capacity.
Hierarchical structure of the power system communication network evaluation model.

Weights are calculated using pairwise comparison matrices based on a 1-9 scale. For instance, the relative importance of the middle-level indices (B1, B2, B3) is determined through a matrix that compares each factor against the others to derive priority eigenvectors.

Pairwise comparison matrix for the middle-level indices (B1, B2, B3) relative to the top-level goal (A).

2. Fuzzy Decision Theory (FDT)

To handle the inherent uncertainty in multi-criteria decision-making, FDT maps raw index values into a standardized scoring system (0–100). This allows for the comparison of disparate metrics by normalizing them into fuzzy scores. The final comprehensive score is the weighted sum of these fuzzy scores across all nine sub-indices.

Results and Discussion

The model was tested using statistical data from the State Grid Corporation of China across four anonymized provinces (K1, K2, K3, and K4).

Performance Ranking

The comprehensive scores revealed a clear hierarchy of construction success:

  • K4: 44.164 (Highest)
  • K3: 41.067
  • K1: 39.623
  • K2: 36.190

Key Insights

  • Priority of Investment: In the AHP model, "Effectiveness of Investment" (B3) received the highest weight (0.5936), significantly more than "Equipment Levels" (0.1570). This indicates that economic efficiency is a primary driver in modern utility management.
  • Structured Reliability: By grouping technical metrics like "Network Connectivity" under "Reliability," the model ensures that hardware performance is evaluated based on its contribution to operational stability.
  • Standardization: The fuzzy scoring mechanism successfully allowed managers to compare disparate metrics, such as comparing price-per-length directly against optical cable coverage.

Conclusion

This hybrid AHP-FDT framework provides a robust, quantitative tool for evaluating power system communication networks. While effective, future improvements could include refining fuzzy scoring intervals based on larger historical datasets and integrating real-time data for dynamic evaluation. Additionally, formalizing the expert consensus process for initial AHP weighting would further enhance the model's objectivity.

Summary updated

Abstract

The communication channel, which is used to provide information transmitting in remote monitoring, control and protection, plays an important role in the development of smart grid.Moreover, office automation and management information of the power enterprises are depending more and more on the broad-band and high speed communication network [1].We can see that, electric power communication network carries the major business, and provides important guarantee to the security and stability of the grid operation and enterprise management.As the world largest electric power communication network has been built in China, more sophisticatedly professional management is needed.For example, reasonable and scientific evaluation for construction results of the power system communication network can quantify the planning, construction and management of the power system communication network, and provide necessary basis for decision making with certain credibility [2].Our motivation of the present work lies in building the comprehensive evaluation for construction results of the power system communication networks with the top-down analysis, which has not been studied yet.Based on
BibTeX
@misc{huang2015new,
  author = {Biyao Huang and Guojun Liu and Huixia Ding and Yunpo Wang and Qi Yang and Ying Zhang},
  title = {{A New Comprehensive Evaluation Method for Construction Results of the Power System Communication Networks}},
  year = {2015},
  doi = {10.2991/itms-15.2015.171},
}
Figure