A new classification of congenital abnormalities of UPVS: sonographic appearances, screening strategy and clinical significance

Yue Qin, Huaxuan Wen, Meiling Liang, Dandan Luo, Qing Zeng, Yimei Liao, Mengyu Zhang, Yan Ding, Xin Wen, Ying Tan, Ying Yuan, Shengli LiInsights 2021 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel, comprehensive classification system for congenital abnormalities of the umbilical-portal venous system (UPVS) based on morphological and shunt abnormalities. This new framework aims to improve prenatal diagnosis, guide management, and enhance understanding of these complex fetal conditions.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

The umbilical-portal venous system (UPVS) is crucial for fetal development, ensuring proper blood supply to vital organs. However, congenital anomalies of the UPVS are diverse, making prenatal diagnosis challenging, especially due to the small lumen of these vessels in utero. Existing classifications often focus on shunts rather than comprehensive anatomical abnormalities, leaving a gap in clinical understanding and management. This paper addresses the need for a more unified and detailed classification that integrates embryology, sonographic findings, clinical presentation, and prognosis to aid sonographers and clinicians.

Methods

The authors propose a new classification system for congenital UPVS abnormalities based on a review of existing literature and their own clinical experience. This classification categorizes anomalies into three main types:

  1. Type I: Anatomy and morphological abnormalities of the portal vein.
  2. Type II: Anatomy and morphological abnormalities of the umbilical vein.
  3. Type III: Vascular connection abnormalities (shunts).

For each subtype within these categories, the paper details embryological origins, sonographic manifestations, diagnostic grading (necessary, amenable, difficult, unnecessary), clinical findings and prognosis, and perinatal management strategies. The study emphasizes the importance of a systematic sonographic screening approach.

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper. The paper is a review and proposal of a new classification system, drawing on existing literature and clinical experience rather than a specific dataset for training or evaluation.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • A Unified Classification is Crucial: The sheer diversity and overlap of UPVS anomalies necessitate a comprehensive classification that integrates morphology and shunting to provide a clearer diagnostic and management roadmap.
  • Embryological Understanding is Key: The paper repeatedly links UPVS anomalies back to specific stages and events in embryonic development, highlighting how disruptions in this process lead to various malformations.
  • Sonography is the Primary Tool, but Challenging: While prenatal ultrasound is the main diagnostic modality, the small caliber of fetal UPVS vessels makes accurate assessment difficult, underscoring the need for skilled sonographers and a systematic approach.
  • Prognosis Varies Widely: Congenital UPVS abnormalities have a broad spectrum of prognoses, ranging from conditions that resolve spontaneously to those with severe implications for fetal survival and long-term health. This variability is a critical factor in prenatal counseling.
  • Screening Strategy is Essential: The paper outlines a detailed two-dimensional ultrasound screening strategy focusing on key anatomical structures and connections within the UPVS, emphasizing the use of Doppler for flow assessment.

Key Results

The paper's primary "result" is the proposed new classification system itself. It details:

  • Three Main Types: Morphological abnormalities of the portal vein, umbilical vein, and vascular connection abnormalities.
  • Numerous Subtypes: Within these types, specific anomalies like preduodenal portal vein, persistent right umbilical vein, portal-systemic shunts, and umbilical-systemic shunts are described.
  • Diagnostic Grading: A system of grading diagnostic difficulty (necessary, amenable, difficult, unnecessary) is provided for each subtype.
  • Clinical and Prognostic Profiles: Detailed descriptions of clinical findings, prognosis, and recommended perinatal management for each anomaly are presented in a comprehensive table.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Diagnostic Difficulty: The authors acknowledge that making a definitive prenatal diagnosis for all UPVS abnormalities remains difficult, even with the proposed classification.
  • Limited Prenatal Reporting: For some rare subtypes, there are limited or no reports of prenatal ultrasound diagnosis, suggesting a need for more research and case reporting.
  • Need for Further Validation: While the classification is based on literature and experience, its clinical utility and accuracy would benefit from prospective validation studies.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that their new classification and screening strategy could provide sonographers with clues for diagnosis, prompting a more detailed examination of the entire UPVS, fetal heart, and other anatomical structures when anomalies are detected. This would aid in re-evaluating prognosis and improving prenatal counseling and management.

Summary updated

Abstract

The umbilical-portal venous system (UPVS) plays an important role in embryonic development, as well as a significant blood circulation system to ensure the normal blood supply of fetal heart and brain and other vital organs. Congenital anomalies of UPVS contain many subtypes with a broad spectrum of manifestations and prognoses. Furthermore, because of fetal small lumen of UPVS, the sonographic evaluation remains difficult in utero. Appreciation of normal embryology and anatomy of UPVS is essential to an understanding of sonographic characteristics of anomalies of UPVS and fetal sequential changes. Through reviewing previous references and our experience with congenital abnormalities of UPVS, a new comprehensive classification is proposed. The new classification identifies three types of congenital abnormalities of UPVS based on morphological abnormalities and shunts. The embryology and etiology, sonographic, clinical and prognostic characteristics of each subtype of the new classification are described in detail. Knowledge of congenital abnormalities of UPVS can give sonographers a clue and aid prenatal sonographic diagnosis. The purpose of this article is to help the sonographers to understand the new classification of congenital abnormalities of UPVS, master the sonographic characteristics of each subtype and prenatal ultrasonographic screening strategy, and guide subsequent appropriate counseling and management.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{qin2021new,
  author = {Yue Qin and Huaxuan Wen and Meiling Liang and Dandan Luo and Qing Zeng and Yimei Liao and Mengyu Zhang and Yan Ding and Xin Wen and Ying Tan and Ying Yuan and Shengli Li},
  title = {{A new classification of congenital abnormalities of UPVS: sonographic appearances, screening strategy and clinical significance}},
  booktitle = {Insights},
  year = {2021},
  doi = {10.1186/s13244-021-01068-5},
}
Figure