A New Atlas Localization Approach for Subthalamic Nucleus Utilizing Chinese Visible Human Head Datasets

Jingjing Rong, Qinghua Wang, Kaijun Liu, Liwen Tan, Ran Xu, Shaoxiang Zhang, Qiyu Li, Yaling HanPLoS 2013 · DOI

Abstract

Chinese Visible Human (CVH) head datasets offer a high-resolution alternative to traditional brain atlases for locating the subthalamic nucleus (STN) in Chinese populations. This study demonstrates that CVH datasets can serve as an accurate anatomical reference, providing average coordinate values for the STN's gravity center and physical ranges to assist in surgical planning for Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS).

Introduction

Deep Brain Stimulation (DBS) of the subthalamic nucleus (STN) is a highly effective treatment for advanced Parkinson’s disease. However, the STN is notoriously difficult to visualize on standard MRI scans because it is small, biconvex, and often lacks clear contrast with surrounding tissues.

To compensate, surgeons often rely on "brain atlases" (such as the Schaltenbrand-Wahren or Mai atlases) to estimate the STN's location. However, most existing atlases are based on a small number of Western/White brains and utilize post-mortem tissue that may have shrunk or deformed during processing. Furthermore, significant morphological differences exist between Chinese and White brain structures, meaning Western-centric atlases may lead to placement errors in Chinese populations. This research proposes a population-specific approach using high-resolution Chinese Visible Human (CVH) datasets.

Methods

The researchers proposed a localization approach based on the Chinese Visible Human (CVH) datasets. Unlike MRI, CVH datasets are created by milling frozen cadaveric heads at ultra-thin intervals (as small as 0.2 mm) and taking high-resolution digital photographs. This preserves "real color" and prevents the tissue deformation common in traditional histological atlases.

Methodological flowchart for the proposed STN localization approach.

The study involved several key steps:

  1. Creating an Average Model: Data from four CVH head datasets (CVH-1, 2, 4, and 5) were used to establish a standardized "Average CVH" model.
  2. MRI Registration: T2-weighted MRIs from 30 Chinese patients (aged 27 to 65) were registered to this CVH model within a shared stereotactic space.
  3. Fiducial Mapping: The team identified several anatomical landmarks (fiducials) common to both MRI and CVH, including the Anterior Commissure (AC), Posterior Commissure (PC), and the Red Nucleus (RN).
  4. Validation: Because the STN is hard to see on MRI but the Red Nucleus (RN) is clear, they used the RN as a proxy to test the accuracy of their registration and localization methods.
Axial MRI slices illustrating the registration and fiducial identification process.

Key Results

  • High Accuracy in X and Y: The mean errors for locating the Red Nucleus in the X (lateral) and Y (anterior-posterior) directions were at the sub-millimeter level, ranging from approximately 0.32 mm to 0.51 mm.
  • Z-Axis Challenge: The Z-direction (superior-inferior) showed higher variability, with mean errors around 1.07 mm. The authors attribute this to significant individual differences in the vertical "stacking" of brain structures.
  • Reference Coordinates: The study provides a specific table of average coordinate values for the STN gravity center in Chinese subjects, which can serve as a direct reference for surgeons during preoperative planning.

Discussion and Insights

The study confirms that while the STN is nearly invisible on 2D MRI, it is vividly clear in the CVH datasets. This allows for the measurement of the STN's "gravity center" and its physical ranges with high confidence. The Red Nucleus (RN) proved to be a reliable proxy for validation, as its position is highly correlated with other landmarks like the putamen and the width of the third ventricle.

Interestingly, the researchers found that the lowest mean errors occurred when no fiducial-based scaling was used to locate the RN between the MRI and the CVH model. This suggests that the relative position of these deep brain structures is remarkably consistent across individuals when referenced to the midpoint of the AC-PC line. Furthermore, the paper highlights that Chinese brains tend to be "rounder" while White brains are "longer," reinforcing the need for population-specific atlases in neurosurgery.

Limitations and Future Work

The primary limitation is the small sample size of the CVH datasets (only four individuals). While these provide high-resolution "ground truth," they may not capture the full spectrum of anatomical diversity. Future work will likely involve increasing the number of CVH datasets to create a more robust statistical atlas and exploring whether automated segmentation algorithms can further refine the registration between a patient's live MRI and the static CVH atlas.

Summary updated

Abstract

CVH head datasets can be used as brain atlas for Chinese STN localization. Moreover, average coordinate values of the gravity center and the ranges of STN in CVH can be considered as references for locating STN.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{rong2013new,
  author = {Jingjing Rong and Qinghua Wang and Kaijun Liu and Liwen Tan and Ran Xu and Shaoxiang Zhang and Qiyu Li and Yaling Han},
  title = {{A New Atlas Localization Approach for Subthalamic Nucleus Utilizing Chinese Visible Human Head Datasets}},
  booktitle = {PLoS},
  year = {2013},
  doi = {10.1371/journal.pone.0057264},
}
Figure