A Muon-Ion Collider at BNL: the future QCD frontier and path to a new energy frontier of $\mu^+\mu^-$ colliders.

D. Acosta, Wei LiarXiv 2021 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

We propose the development and construction of a novel muon-ion collider (MuIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) as an upgrade to succeed the Electron-Ion Collider (EIC). The BNL facility could accommodate a muon storage beam with an energy up to about 1 TeV. When collided with a 275 GeV hadron beam, the MuIC center-of-mass energy of about 1 TeV will extend the kinematic coverage of deep inelastic scattering (DIS) physics by more than an order of magnitude in $Q^2$ and $x$. This coverage is comparable to the proposed Large Hadron-Electron Collider (LHeC) at CERN but offers complementary kinematics and beam polarization. Furthermore, the MuIC serves as a critical demonstrator for future multi-TeV muon-antimuon colliders.

Introduction: The Muon Advantage

To probe the fundamental structure of matter, physicists utilize Deep Inelastic Scattering (DIS), colliding leptons into nucleons to resolve their internal constituents. While the upcoming Electron-Ion Collider (EIC) at BNL will provide unprecedented detail, it faces an energy ceiling due to synchrotron radiation losses inherent to accelerating electrons in circular paths. Reaching the teraelectronvolt (TeV) scale with electrons requires prohibitively large and expensive circular or linear accelerators.

Muons, being approximately 200 times heavier than electrons, emit negligible synchrotron radiation. This allows them to be accelerated to much higher energies within existing circular infrastructure. The proposed Muon-Ion Collider (MuIC) leverages this advantage to push the QCD frontier while simultaneously maturing the technologies required for a future high-energy muon-antimuon collider.

Facility Design and Methodology

The MuIC design envisions integrating a muon storage ring into the existing RHIC/EIC tunnels at BNL. The study evaluates magnet scenarios ranging from 8.4 T to 16 T, focusing on an 11 T scenario (High-Luminosity LHC technology) that enables a 960 GeV muon beam. Colliding this with a 275 GeV proton beam yields a center-of-mass energy $\sqrt{s} \approx 1$ TeV.

Luminosity estimates using a proton-driver scheme suggest a peak of $5–10 \times 10^{33} \text{ cm}^{-2}\text{s}^{-1}$, making the MuIC competitive with CERN’s LHeC proposal. To validate the facility's physics potential, researchers simulated DIS events using the PYTHIA 8 Monte Carlo generator, comparing the MuIC's reach against HERA, EIC, and LHeC.

Kinematic Reach and Scientific Goals

The primary advantage of the MuIC is its vast expansion of the observable phase space in momentum transfer ($Q^2$) and the Bjorken scaling variable ($x$).

Kinematic coverage in $Q^2$ and $x$ for MuIC compared to EIC, LHeC, and HERA for proton (top) and ion (bottom) targets.

As shown in Figure 1, the MuIC extends the reach of the EIC by more than an order of magnitude. This expanded coverage is essential for investigating gluon saturation—a predicted state where gluons are so densely packed they begin to recombine—and for resolving the "Proton Spin Puzzle" through the use of polarized beams. Additionally, the facility could double as a neutrino source (via muon decay), creating a multi-disciplinary hub for nuclear and high-energy physics.

Detector Kinematics and Performance

The kinematics of MuIC collisions differ significantly from those of the EIC or LHeC. In the EIC, asymmetric beam energies result in highly boosted final states. In contrast, the MuIC's more balanced beam energies (960 GeV vs 275 GeV) lead to more centrally distributed final-state particles, which can simplify aspects of detector design.

Comparison of lepton and hadron kinematics (isolines of energy and pseudorapidity) for MuIC and LHeC.

Figure 2 illustrates the isolines for scattered lepton and hadronic final state (HFS) energy and pseudorapidity. The MuIC provides a more symmetric distribution in the detector's central region compared to the LHeC. The study also evaluated kinematic reconstruction methods, finding that the Double Angle (DA) method offers superior resolution at high $Q^2$, while the Jacquet-Blondel method performs best in the low-$Q^2$ / high-$y$ regime.

Conclusion and Future Outlook

The MuIC represents a cost-effective and scientifically ambitious path forward. By reusing existing BNL infrastructure, it provides a bridge to the TeV scale and a vital testbed for muon collider technology. While significant R&D challenges remain—particularly regarding muon cooling and beam-induced backgrounds—the MuIC could realistically begin construction in the late 2040s. This facility would not only revolutionize our understanding of QCD but also pave the way for the next high-energy frontier in particle physics.

Summary updated

Abstract

We propose the development and construction of a novel muon-ion collider (MuIC) at Brookhaven National Laboratory (BNL) in the USA as an upgrade to succeed the electron-ion collider (EIC) that is scheduled to commence in the early 2030s, by a joint effort of the nuclear and particle physics communities. The BNL facility could accommodate a muon storage beam with an energy up to about 1~TeV with existing magnet technology. When collided with a 275~GeV hadron beam, the MuIC center-of-mass energy of about 1~TeV will extend the kinematic coverage of deep inelastic scattering physics at the EIC (with polarized beams) by more than an order of magnitude in $Q^2$ and $x$, opening a new QCD frontier to address many fundamental scientific questions in nuclear and particle physics. This coverage is comparable to that of the proposed Large Hadron-Electron Collider (LHeC) at CERN, but with complementary lepton and hadron kinematics and beam polarization. Additionally, the developmentof a MuIC at BNL will focus the worldwide R\&D efforts on muon collider technology and serve as a demonstrator toward a future muon-antimuon collider at {$\mathcal O$}(10)~TeV energies, which is an attractive option to reach the next high energy frontier in particle physics at an affordable cost and a smaller footprint than a future circular hadron collider. We discuss here the possible design parameters of the MuIC, kinematic coverage, science cases, and detector design considerations including estimates of resolutions on DIS kinematic variables. A possible road map toward the future MuIC and muon-antimuon colliders is also presented.
BibTeX
@misc{acosta2021muon,
  author = {D. Acosta and Wei Li},
  title = {{A Muon-Ion Collider at BNL: the future QCD frontier and path to a new energy frontier of $\textbackslash\{\}mu^+\textbackslash\{\}mu^-$ colliders.}},
  year = {2021},
  eprint = {2107.02073},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2107.02073},
}

Loading related content...

Figure