A multidisciplinary effort to increase COVID-19 vaccination among the older adults

Aminath Shiwaza Moosa, Yi M. S. Wee, Meng H. Jaw, Qifan F. Tan, Wan L. D. Tse, Chui Y. Loke, Guan L. A. Ee, Chee C. D. Ng, Wai K. Aau, Yi Ling Eileen Koh, Ngiap Chuan TanFrontiers in Public Health 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

The COVE (COVID-19 Vaccination for the Elderly) program in Singapore successfully boosted vaccination rates among high-risk older adults from 84.6% to 96.3%. By utilizing a multidisciplinary team to conduct personalized phone outreach and integrating real-time electronic medical record (EMR) alerts, the initiative converted over 60% of a previously unvaccinated "laggard" group within just three months.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Even in countries with high vaccine availability, the "last mile" of reaching the most vulnerable populations—specifically older adults—remains a significant public health hurdle. In Singapore, by mid-2021, a stubborn percentage of adults aged 60+ remained unvaccinated despite nationwide campaigns.

The authors identify that this group isn't a monolith; their hesitation stems from a mix of misinformation, fear of side effects (especially regarding pre-existing chronic conditions), and physical access barriers. The paper evaluates whether a proactive, person-centric intervention led by trusted healthcare workers could address these specific concerns more effectively than mass media messaging.

Methods

The researchers implemented the COVE program, a two-phase outreach strategy managed by SingHealth Polyclinics (SHP):

  1. Phase I (High-Touch): Healthcare volunteers personally called unvaccinated adults aged 70+ to assess their intent, address specific medical fears, and immediately facilitate appointment scheduling.
  2. Phase II (Scalable Outreach): For those uncontactable in Phase I and the 60–69 age group, the team deployed SMS reminders and physical letters.
  3. EMR Integration: A crucial technical component was a "nudge" embedded in the Electronic Medical Record system. When a clinician (doctor, nurse, or pharmacist) opened the file of an unvaccinated patient for any reason, a prompt appeared: "Patient has no record of COVID-19 vaccination. Offer vaccination if eligible."
  4. Multidisciplinary Team: 178 staff members from 19 different departments—including finance, HR, and nursing—were trained to handle these conversations, ensuring the burden didn't fall solely on clinical staff.

Datasets

The study utilized the SHP Patient Registry, extracting data from the SingHealth-Integrated Health Information Systems Electronic Health Intelligence System (eHINTS).

  • Initial Cohort: 21,663 unvaccinated adults aged 60–109.
  • Contextual Data: The researchers linked these records with sociodemographic data, including the Community Health Assist Scheme (CHAS) and Medifund status (proxies for socioeconomic status), and existing records of non-communicable diseases.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • The "Ambivalent Middle": Only 24% of the contacted group "outright rejected" the vaccine. The majority were either planning to vaccinate but hadn't (39%) or were seeking more clinical information (25%). This suggests that "vaccine hesitancy" is often just "vaccine procrastination" or a need for personalized reassurance.
  • The Power of the "Nudge": By integrating alerts into the EMR, the program turned routine check-ups for unrelated issues (like diabetes or hypertension) into opportunities for vaccination.
  • Addressing the "Laggard" Profile: According to the diffusion of innovation theory, the remaining unvaccinated individuals (the "laggards") are the most skeptical of change. The study found that personal phone calls in the patient's preferred language or dialect were essential to bridge the trust gap that mass media could not.
  • Access vs. Ideology: 8% of the group cited physical barriers (being homebound or having mobility issues). This highlighted the need for mobile vaccination teams rather than just more clinics.

Key Results

The intervention yielded significant quantitative shifts in a population that had previously resisted vaccination:

  • Overall Impact: Vaccination coverage in the SHP registry rose from 84.6% to 96.3%.
  • Conversion Rate: Of the 21,663 targeted unvaccinated individuals, 60.4% (13,082) received at least one dose within three months of the program's start.
  • Response Breakdown: Among those reached by phone, 81% of those who "intended to vaccinate" followed through, and even 41% of those who initially "outright rejected" the vaccine eventually received a dose.
  • Safety Reassurance: While 3% of respondents feared adverse effects would worsen their chronic conditions, the personalized clinical advice provided during the calls helped mitigate these fears.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several constraints:

  • Lack of a Control Group: As this was an urgent public health intervention during a pandemic, a randomized controlled trial was not ethically or practically feasible.
  • Data Fidelity: The content of phone conversations varied based on the volunteer and the patient’s specific concerns, making it difficult to pinpoint exactly which "argument" was most effective.
  • The "Digital Divide": About 40% of Singaporean residents aged 75+ do not use handphones, limiting the effectiveness of Phase II (SMS).
  • Future Directions: The authors suggest that future programs should involve community partners (social services) earlier to identify and assist socially isolated seniors who may not even be in the polyclinic registry.

Summary updated

Abstract

The COVE program increased the COVID-19 vaccination uptake of older adults from 84.6 to 96.3%. A person-centric proactive approach by healthcare workers addressed vaccine hesitancy and optimized vaccination. The outreach scheduling of vaccination appointments is key in promoting vaccination uptake among older adults.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{moosa2022multidisciplinary,
  author = {Aminath Shiwaza Moosa and Yi M. S. Wee and Meng H. Jaw and Qifan F. Tan and Wan L. D. Tse and Chui Y. Loke and Guan L. A. Ee and Chee C. D. Ng and Wai K. Aau and Yi Ling Eileen Koh and Ngiap Chuan Tan},
  title = {{A multidisciplinary effort to increase COVID-19 vaccination among the older adults}},
  booktitle = {Frontiers in Public Health},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.3389/fpubh.2022.904161},
}
Figure