A model to predict unstable carotid plaques in population with high risk of stroke

Junxiong Yin, Chuanyong Yu, Hongxing Liu, Mingyang Du, Feng Sun, Cheng-Sheng Yu, Lixia Wei, Chongjun Wang, Xiaoshan WangResearch Square 2020 · DOI

Abstract

Traditional screening for stroke risk often focuses on carotid stenosis—the degree of arterial narrowing. However, unstable carotid plaques can trigger strokes even in patients with less than 50% stenosis. This study developed a predictive model to identify unstable carotid plaques in a high-risk population. Analyzing 2,841 individuals from the China National Stroke Screening and Prevention Project (CNSSPP), researchers identified five independent risk factors: male gender, advanced age, marital status, high LDL-C, and low HDL-C. A 10-point scoring system was created with a 6.5-point cutoff, yielding an Area Under the Curve (AUC) of 0.738. This tool allows clinicians to prioritize high-risk patients for carotid ultrasonography and early intervention, potentially preventing strokes before significant arterial blockage occurs.

Introduction

Stroke remains a leading cause of mortality and long-term disability globally. A significant portion of ischemic strokes is attributed to carotid atherosclerosis. While clinical guidelines traditionally emphasize the degree of carotid stenosis (typically >50%) as the primary indicator for intervention, recent evidence suggests that plaque morphology—specifically "instability" or vulnerability—is a critical predictor of embolic events. Unstable plaques, characterized by a thin fibrous cap, large lipid core, or intraplaque hemorrhage, can rupture and cause a stroke regardless of the severity of the narrowing.

Current predictive models often overlook individuals with low-level stenosis who may still harbor these dangerous plaques. To bridge this gap, this study aimed to develop a practical scoring system to identify unstable carotid plaques in individuals already flagged as having a high risk for stroke based on standard clinical factors.

Study Design and Methodology

The researchers conducted a community-based study using data from the China National Stroke Screening and Prevention Project (CNSSPP) in Nanjing.

Flowchart of the study population selection process.

As shown in Figure 1, the study initially screened 34,227 residents, eventually narrowing the focus to 2,841 high-risk individuals. Participants were categorized based on carotid duplex ultrasonography. Plaques were defined as "unstable" if they exhibited hypoechoic or mixed echoes, or showed signs of ulceration. The cohort was split into a Derivation Set (n=1,894) to build the model and a Validation Set (n=947) to test its accuracy.

Identification of Risk Factors

Using multivariable logistic regression, the study identified five independent predictors for the presence of unstable carotid plaques:

  1. Gender: Males were nearly twice as likely to have unstable plaques (OR 1.966).
  2. Age: Risk increased exponentially with age. Compared to the 40–49 age group, those aged 70+ had an Odds Ratio (OR) of 31.267.
  3. Marital Status: Being married was associated with higher risk (OR 1.780), potentially due to shared lifestyle factors or dietary habits in the study region.
  4. LDL-C: High levels of low-density lipoprotein cholesterol were a strong predictor (OR 2.015).
  5. HDL-C: Low levels of high-density lipoprotein cholesterol also significantly increased risk (OR 2.130).

The Predictive Scoring System

To translate these findings into a clinical tool, the researchers developed a 10-point scoring system. The model's performance was evaluated using Receiver Operating Characteristic (ROC) curves.

  • Optimal Cutoff: 6.5 points.
  • Performance: The AUC was 0.738 for the derivation set and 0.737 for the validation set, demonstrating consistent and fair-to-good discriminatory power.
  • Clinical Utility: A score above 6.5 indicates a high probability of unstable plaques, suggesting that these patients should undergo immediate carotid ultrasonography even if they do not meet traditional stenosis criteria.

Discussion and Conclusion

This study shifts the focus of primary stroke prevention from simple arterial narrowing to plaque vulnerability. By identifying high-risk individuals before a major embolic event occurs, clinicians can initiate early interventions such as intensive statin therapy or antiplatelet agents.

While the model is robust, it has limitations. The data is derived from a single center in Nanjing, and the "marriage factor" may reflect specific regional socio-economic conditions that might not apply globally. Furthermore, the cross-sectional design means the model predicts the presence of plaques but does not yet track long-term stroke outcomes. Future research will focus on longitudinal follow-up to validate the impact of this scoring system on actual stroke incidence.

In conclusion, this 10-point model provides a simple, cost-effective method for screening high-risk populations, ensuring that those with vulnerable carotid plaques receive the diagnostic attention and treatment they need to prevent a stroke.

Summary updated

Abstract

<title>Abstract</title> Background : Several models have been developed to predict asymptomatic carotid stenosis (ACS), however these models did not pay much attention to people with lower level of stenosis (<50% or carotid plaques, especially instable carotid plaques) who might benefit from early interventions. Here, we developed a new model to predict unstable carotid plaques through systematic screening in population with high risk of stroke. Methods : Community residents who participated the China National Stroke Screening and Prevention Project (CNSSPP) were screened for their stroke risks. A total of 2841 individuals with high risk of stroke were enrolled in this study, 266 (9.4%) of them were found unstable carotid plaques. A total of 19 risk factors were included in this study. Subjects were randomly distributed into Derivation Set group or Validation Set group. According to their carotid ultrasonography records, subjects in derivation set group were further categorized into unstable plaque group or stable plaque group. Results : 174 cases and 1720 cases from Derivation Set group were categorized into unstable plaque group and stable plaque group respectively. The independent risk factors for carotid unstable plaque were: male (OR 1.966, 95%CI 1.406-2.749),older age (50-59, OR 6.012, 95%CI 1.410-25.629; 60-69, OR 13.915, 95%CI 3.381-57.267;≥70, OR 31.267, 95%CI 7.472-130.83) , married(OR 1.780, 95%CI 1.186-2.672),LDL-C(OR 2.015, 95%CI 1.443-2.814), and HDL-C(OR 2.130, 95%CI 1.360-3.338). A predictive scoring system was generated, ranging from 0-10. The cut-off value of this predictive scoring system is 6.5. The AUC value for derivation and validation set group were 0.738 and 0.737 respectively. Conclusions :For those individuals with high risk of stroke, we developed a new model which could identify those who have a higher chance to have unstable carotid plaques. When an individual’s predictive model score exceeds 6.5, the probability of having carotid unstable plaques is high, and carotid ultrasonography should be conducted accordingly. This model could be helpful in the primary prevention of stroke.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{yin2020model,
  author = {Junxiong Yin and Chuanyong Yu and Hongxing Liu and Mingyang Du and Feng Sun and Cheng-Sheng Yu and Lixia Wei and Chongjun Wang and Xiaoshan Wang},
  title = {{A model to predict unstable carotid plaques in population with high risk of stroke}},
  booktitle = {Research Square},
  year = {2020},
  doi = {10.21203/rs.2.13605/v3},
}
Figure