A model of decentralized vision in the sea urchin Diadema africanum

Tianshu Li, John D. Kirwan, Maria Ina Arnone, Dan‐Eric Nilsson, Giancarlo La CamerabioRxiv 2022 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper presents a novel computational model of decentralized vision in sea urchins, explaining how these eyeless creatures can navigate using light. The model successfully predicts their movement behavior and offers a mechanistic understanding of visual processing in a decentralized nervous system.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Sea urchins, despite lacking eyes, can detect light and orient themselves towards or away from visual stimuli. This ability is remarkable because it suggests a sophisticated visual processing system without a centralized brain. While photoreceptor cells (PRCs) on their body surface are known to detect light, the precise neural mechanisms by which this information is integrated and translated into directed movement have remained elusive. This paper aims to bridge this gap by proposing a detailed, step-by-step model of how sea urchins might achieve this "decentralized vision."

Methods

The authors developed a computational model that simulates the sea urchin's nervous system, focusing on three key components:

  • Photoreceptor Cells (PRCs): These are modeled as being distributed along the sea urchin's ambulacra (five radial grooves on its body). Each PRC has an "acceptance angle," determining how wide a field of view it can detect.
  • Radial Nerve (RN) Neurons: These neurons receive input from the PRCs and also interact with each other. They are modeled as processing inhibitory signals from PRCs and excitatory signals from neighboring RNs.
  • Oral Nerve Ring (ONR) Neurons: This ring-like structure encircles the mouth and is thought to integrate information from the RNs. The model includes both inhibitory (iONR) and excitatory (eONR) neurons within the ONR.

The core of the model's "vision" lies in how it processes information: PRCs detect light, which inhibits RNs. RNs then influence iONR neurons, which in turn inhibit eONR neurons. This "double inhibition" pathway is crucial. The activity of the eONR neurons is then read out using a "population vector" mechanism. This vector represents the collective "vote" of eONR neurons, indicating the direction of the detected stimulus. If the population vector's strength exceeds a certain threshold, the sea urchin is considered to have detected the stimulus and initiates movement. The model also incorporates a dynamic movement component, where the animal takes small steps and adjusts its direction based on the current population vector.

Datasets

The model was trained and evaluated using previously published behavioral data from experiments on the sea urchin Diadema africanum (Kirwan et al., 2018). These experiments involved presenting the animals with various visual stimuli (bars and difference-of-Gaussians patterns) in a circular arena and recording their movement. The paper does not introduce new datasets but rather uses existing experimental results to validate its model.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Decentralized Vision is Plausible: The model demonstrates that a complex visual processing system, capable of directional movement, can be implemented without a centralized brain, relying instead on distributed neural networks.
  • The Power of "Double Inhibition": The proposed mechanism where PRCs inhibit RNs, which then inhibit iONR neurons that inhibit eONR neurons, is a key insight. This "double inhibition" pathway allows for sensitive detection and integration of light signals.
  • Population Vector as a Readout: The use of a population vector to interpret the collective activity of eONR neurons provides a robust way to extract directional information from a distributed neural network. This concept, borrowed from primate motor cortex studies, is shown to be applicable in a decentralized system.
  • Stimulus-Dependent Vision: The model highlights how the sea urchin's ability to detect stimuli depends not only on the stimulus itself but also on its orientation relative to the animal's body, particularly due to the arrangement of PRCs and the lack of them between ambulacra.

Key Results

The model successfully reproduced the experimental findings of Kirwan et al. (2018) regarding the movement behavior of Diadema africanum. Specifically:

  • The model accurately predicted that sea urchins would move randomly in response to uniform stimuli or simple bars.
  • It also correctly predicted significant movement towards a more complex stimulus (a 69° difference-of-Gaussians), while showing less or no movement towards a 29° difference-of-Gaussians or a 40° bar stimulus.
  • The dynamic model of movement also captured the observed trajectories and final positions of the animals.
  • The model's predictions were shown to be robust to variations in key parameters like the PRCs' acceptance angle and their spatial distribution.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge several limitations and suggest avenues for future research:

  • Anatomical Detail: The model relies on some assumptions about neural connectivity and function due to the limited detailed anatomical knowledge of echinoderm nervous systems. Future experimental work is needed to clarify these connections.
  • PRC Distribution: While the model assumes a uniform distribution of PRCs, their actual distribution might be more complex. However, the model's robustness to variations in this parameter suggests this might not be a critical limitation.
  • Stimulus Interpretation: The model currently uses a population vector for movement direction. The authors suggest that this vector could also incorporate other factors like motivation, which would require further investigation.
  • Experimental Validation: The paper makes several testable predictions about neural properties and behavioral responses to different stimuli, which can guide future experimental studies. Specifically, future research could investigate the nature of neural connectivity, the electrophysiological responses of neurons, and the aggregate response of ONR neurons to various stimuli.

Summary updated

Abstract

A bstract Sea urchins can detect light and move in relation to luminous stimuli despite lacking eyes. They presumably detect light through photoreceptor cells distributed on their body surface. However, there is currently no mechanistic explanation of how these animals can process light to detect visual stimuli and produce oriented movement. Here, we present a model of decentralized vision in echinoderms that includes all known processing stages, from photoreceptor cells to radial nerve neurons to neurons contained in the oral nerve ring encircling the mouth of the animals. In the model, light stimuli captured by photoreceptor cells produce neural activity in the radial nerve neurons. In turn, neural activity in the radial nerves is integrated in the oral nerve ring to produce a profile of neural activity reaching spatially across several ambulacra. This neural activity is read out to produce a model of movement. The model captures previously published data on the behavior of sea urchin Diadema africanum probed with a variety of physical stimuli. The specific pattern of neural connections used in the model makes testable predictions on the properties of single neurons and aggregate neural behavior in Diadema africanum and other echinoderms, offering a potential understanding of the mechanism of visual orientation in these animals.
BibTeX
@misc{li2022model,
  author = {Tianshu Li and John D. Kirwan and Maria Ina Arnone and Dan‐Eric Nilsson and Giancarlo La Camera},
  title = {{A model of decentralized vision in the sea urchin <i>Diadema africanum</i>}},
  year = {2022},
  doi = {10.1101/2022.05.03.490537},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}

Loading related content...

Figure