A model for pion-pion scattering in large-N QCD

G. Veneziano, S. Yankielowicz, E. OnofriJournal of High Energy Physics 2017 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper proposes a toy model for pion-pion scattering in the large-N limit of Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD). The model successfully incorporates key features expected from QCD, such as Regge behavior and asymptotic freedom, by generalizing the classic Lovelace-Shapiro model with an infinite sum of string-like amplitudes.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Understanding the behavior of scattering amplitudes in Quantum Chromodynamics (QCD) is a fundamental challenge. In particular, the "large-N" limit of QCD, where the number of colors (N) is taken to be very large, simplifies the theory and reveals universal properties. Recent work by Caron-Huot et al. suggested that in this limit, scattering amplitudes exhibit an exponential behavior at high energies and fixed ratios of kinematic variables, consistent with string theory. However, this behavior contrasts with the expected power-law (with logarithmic corrections) behavior at fixed angles in the physical region, which arises from asymptotic freedom in QCD. The problem is to construct a model that bridges these seemingly contradictory behaviors while respecting other crucial properties like unitarity and crossing symmetry.

Methods

The authors propose a generalization of the Lovelace-Shapiro model. Instead of a single Regge trajectory, they introduce an infinite sum of amplitudes, each with a different Regge slope, specifically with slopes proportional to $1/k$ for $k=1, 2, 3, \dots$. This "discrete sum" of string-like amplitudes is designed to capture the universal stringy behavior at large positive $t$ while introducing a "bending" of trajectories at negative $t$. This bending leads to a fixed branch point at $J=0$ for $t < t_0 < 0$, which is crucial for reconciling the Regge and fixed-angle limits. They then analyze the consequences of this model, particularly focusing on the constraints imposed by tree-level unitarity, which translates to the positivity of residues of scattering amplitude poles. They employ both analytical and numerical methods, including a spectral method based on Gaussian quadrature, to explore the parameter space defined by the Regge intercept ($\alpha_0$), the power-law exponent ($\beta$), and a related parameter ($\gamma$).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Bridging String Theory and QCD: The core idea is to use a sum of string-like amplitudes to reconcile the exponential behavior expected from string theory at high energies with the power-law behavior dictated by asymptotic freedom in QCD.
  • "Kinked" Regge Trajectories: The infinite sum of amplitudes with decreasing slopes effectively creates Regge trajectories that are linear and parallel at large positive $t$ but develop a "kink" at negative $t$, leading to a branch point at $J=0$. This is a novel way to achieve the desired transition in behavior.
  • Unitarity as a Constraint: Tree-level unitarity, specifically the positivity of pole residues, acts as a powerful constraint on the model's parameters, significantly restricting the allowed parameter space.
  • Critical Landscape: The analysis reveals a "critical landscape" in the parameter space ($\beta, \alpha_0$) where unitarity is satisfied, suggesting that a physically interesting region exists.

Key Results

  • The proposed model successfully reproduces the expected Regge behavior at large positive $t$ and the power-law behavior (with logarithmic corrections) at fixed angles in the physical region.
  • The model exhibits a fixed branch point at $J=0$ for negative $t$, a key feature for reconciling different kinematic regimes.
  • Tree-level unitarity imposes strong constraints, defining a specific region in the parameter space ($\alpha_0, \beta, \gamma$) where the model is consistent. A physically interesting region is identified around $\alpha_0 = 0.5, \beta = 2, \gamma = 3$.
  • Numerical and analytical investigations confirm the existence of this allowed region for unitarity.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Toy Model: The paper explicitly states this is a "toy model" and acknowledges that full consistency would require extension to multi-pion processes and consideration of massive intermediate states, which are not undertaken here.
  • Hidden Degeneracy: The authors note that positivity of residues is a necessary but not sufficient condition for unitarity. A deeper analysis involving higher-point amplitudes might be needed to disentangle potential hidden degeneracies and fully check unitarity.
  • Holographic Interpretation: The authors speculate that the discrete sum over $k$ might hint at an underlying holographic dimension, suggesting future work could explore continuous variations in string slopes and their connection to holographic duality.
  • Folded Strings: The possibility of folded strings is raised as a potential explanation for the origin of the sum over amplitudes with different slopes, suggesting further investigation into these configurations.

Summary updated

Abstract

Following up on recent work by Caron-Huot et al. we consider a generalization of the old Lovelace-Shapiro model as a toy model for ππ scattering satisfying (most of) the properties expected to hold in (’t Hooft’s) large-N limit of massless QCD. In particular, the model has asymptotically linear and parallel Regge trajectories at positive t, a positive leading Regge intercept α 0 < 1, and an effective bending of the trajectories in the negative-t region producing a fixed branch point at J = 0 for t < t 0 < 0. Fixed (physical) angle scattering can be tuned to match the power-like behavior (including logarithmic corrections) predicted by perturbative QCD: A(s, t) ∼ s −β log(s)−γ F (θ). Tree-level unitarity (i.e. positivity of residues for all values of s and J ) imposes strong constraints on the allowed region in the α0-β-γ parameter space, which nicely includes a physically interesting region around α 0 = 0.5, β = 2 and γ = 3. The full consistency of the model would require an extension to multi-pion processes, a program we do not undertake in this paper.
BibTeX
@article{veneziano2017model,
  author = {G. Veneziano and S. Yankielowicz and E. Onofri},
  title = {{A model for pion-pion scattering in large-N QCD}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2017},
  doi = {10.1007/jhep04(2017)151},
}
Figure