A Mobile App for the Self-Report of Psychological Well-Being During Pregnancy (BrightSelf): Qualitative Design Study

Kevin Doherty, Marguerite Barry, José Marcano-Belisario, Bérenger Arnaud, Cecily Morrison, Josip Car, Gavin DohertyJMIR Mental Health 2018 · OpenReview

Introduction

Perinatal depression (PND) is a significant public health challenge, affecting approximately 15% of women in the United Kingdom during pregnancy or within the first year postpartum. Despite its prevalence and the severe risks it poses—including being a leading cause of maternal mortality—it is estimated that over 50% of cases go undiagnosed. Traditional screening often relies on retrospective, paper-based questionnaires like the Edinburgh Postnatal Depression Scale (EPDS), which are frequently administered in high-pressure clinical environments. These methods can feel like a "test" to patients, potentially leading to dishonest reporting due to the stigma surrounding mental health.

This paper explores the design of BrightSelf, a mobile application developed to bridge the "medical and informational gap" in early pregnancy. By leveraging mobile technology, the study aims to facilitate low-friction, real-time self-reporting to improve early detection and support for maternal well-being.

Methodology

The development of BrightSelf followed a qualitative design study involving 38 participants. This cohort included 11 pregnant women and mothers, alongside 27 health professionals, including midwives, GPs, psychologists, and psychiatrists.

The research process involved:

  • Iterative Design Sessions: 22 sessions (5 group, 17 individual) were conducted to gather feedback on prototypes and explore the anxieties associated with the pregnancy journey.
  • Thematic Analysis: Researchers analyzed 19 hours of transcribed audio to identify core themes regarding technology use and well-being appraisal in perinatal care.
  • Prototyping: The app was designed to integrate Ecological Momentary Assessment (EMA)—short, frequent "Check-ins" using visual scales—with traditional retrospective surveys, rebranded as "Check Backs" to reduce clinical friction.

Key Design Insights

The study identified several critical factors for the successful implementation of mHealth tools in pregnancy:

Overcoming Stigma

The term "mental health" often carries a heavy clinical stigma. Participants indicated that framing the app around "emotional" or "psychological well-being" made the tool feel more approachable. By positioning the app as a supportive companion rather than a diagnostic monitor, designers can encourage more honest disclosure.

Addressing the "Black Hole" of Care

A significant finding was the identification of a support gap during the first trimester. Many women experience high anxiety between discovering their pregnancy and their first "booking appointment" with a midwife. BrightSelf targets this window, providing a "safe space" for reflection when formal clinical support is least available.

Balancing EMA and Retrospective Reporting

While the EPDS is a clinical standard, users often found it intimidating. In contrast, EMA-based "Check-ins" were perceived as "light-hearted" and easier to integrate into daily life. BrightSelf uses these momentary assessments to build a longitudinal picture of well-being, while "Check Backs" (EPDS) provide the clinical depth necessary for professional review.

Providing Immediate Value

To sustain engagement over a 40-week pregnancy, the app must offer more than just data collection. BrightSelf includes features like an "ideas machine" for micro-interventions and fetus-size comparisons (e.g., "your baby is the size of a lemon"). These elements provide immediate gratification and "value-add" for the user.

Results: Design Implications

The research culminated in four primary design implications for perinatal well-being technologies:

  1. Framing: Use non-clinical language and acknowledge the uniqueness of every pregnancy journey.
  2. Supporting Value: Facilitate both "Turning Inward" (self-reflection) and "Taking Action" (enabling better conversations with healthcare providers).
  3. Shaping Experience: Ensure the reporting process feels supportive and non-intrusive.
  4. Engagement: Use notifications and supplementary content to maintain interest throughout the longitudinal journey.

Conclusion

The BrightSelf study highlights the potential for mobile technology to transform perinatal mental health care by moving toward more frequent, less stigmatized self-reporting. While the initial study was limited by a small, highly educated maternal sample, it provides a robust framework for designing empathetic mHealth tools. Future work will involve multi-site clinical trials to determine if this approach leads to improved detection rates and clinical outcomes for mothers and their children.

Summary updated

Abstract

Background: Maternal mental health impacts both parental well-being and childhood development. In the United Kingdom, 15% of women are affected by depression during pregnancy or within 1 year of giving birth. Suicide is a leading cause of perinatal maternal mortality, and it is estimated that >50% of perinatal depression cases go undiagnosed. Mobile technologies are potentially valuable tools for the early recognition of depressive symptoms, but complex design challenges must be addressed to enable their use in public health screening.Objective: The aim of this study was to explore the issues and challenges surrounding the use of mobile phones for the self-report of psychological well-being during pregnancy.Methods: This paper presents design research carried out as part of the development of BrightSelf, a mobile app for the self-report of psychological well-being during pregnancy. Design sessions were carried out with 38 participants, including pregnant women, mothers, midwives, and other health professionals. Overall, 19 hours of audio were fully transcribed and used as the basis of thematic analysis.Results: The study highlighted anxieties concerning the pregnancy journey, challenges surrounding current approaches to the appraisal of well-being in perinatal care, and the midwife-patient relationship. Designers should consider the framing of perinatal mental health technologies, the experience of self-report, supporting self-awareness and disclosure, providing value to users through both self-report and supplementary features, and designing for longitudinal engagement.Conclusions: This study highlights the needs, motivations, and anxieties of women with respect to technology use in pregnancy and implications for the design of mobile health technologies.JMIR Ment Health 2018;5(4):e10007doi:10.2196/10007
BibTeX
@inproceedings{doherty2018mobile,
  author = {Kevin Doherty and Marguerite Barry and José Marcano-Belisario and Bérenger Arnaud and Cecily Morrison and Josip Car and Gavin Doherty},
  title = {{A Mobile App for the Self-Report of Psychological Well-Being During Pregnancy (BrightSelf): Qualitative Design Study}},
  booktitle = {JMIR Mental Health},
  year = {2018},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=tIrlJZOvKk},
}
Figure