A Mixture-of-Experts Model for Antonym-Synonym Discrimination

Zhipeng Xie, Nan ZengACL 2021 · OpenReview

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel "Mixture-of-Experts" (MoE) model for distinguishing between antonyms and synonyms, a notoriously difficult task in NLP. By dividing the complex problem into smaller, specialized "expert" sub-problems, their model achieves state-of-the-art performance, demonstrating the power of localized learning for semantic relationships.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Distinguishing between words with opposite meanings (antonyms) and words with similar meanings (synonyms) is a fundamental challenge in Natural Language Processing (NLP). This task, known as Antonym-Synonym Discrimination (ASD), is crucial for various applications like sentiment analysis, textual entailment, and machine translation. The core difficulty lies in the fact that antonyms and synonyms often appear in very similar linguistic contexts, making it hard to tell them apart based solely on their usage. Traditional approaches have either relied on specific lexical patterns, which suffer from limited coverage, or distributional methods that analyze word co-occurrences, which can struggle with the nuances of semantic opposition.

Methods

The paper proposes a "Mixture-of-Experts" (MoE) model, dubbed MoE-ASD, to tackle the ASD problem. The core idea is inspired by two hypotheses:

  1. Hypothesis (a): Antonymous words are similar across most semantic dimensions but differ significantly in a few key dimensions.
  2. Hypothesis (b): These "salient" dimensions can vary greatly for different antonym pairs.

To address hypothesis (b), the MoE framework is employed. The model divides the overall semantic space into multiple "subspaces." Each subspace is handled by a specialized "localized expert" that focuses on learning the distinguishing features within that specific subspace. A "gating mechanism" is trained jointly with these experts to dynamically determine how to combine their outputs for a final decision.

Each localized expert takes a word pair (w₁, w₂) as input and first distills a small number of "salient dimensions" from their pre-trained word embeddings. This is done by projecting the embeddings into a lower-dimensional space. A relational feature vector is then constructed from these distilled dimensions, incorporating the sum, absolute difference, cosine similarity, and a "Negation-Prefix" feature (indicating if prefixes like "un-", "non-", "anti-" are present). This feature vector is then fed into a Multi-Layer Perceptron (MLP) to produce an antonymy score for that expert. The gating mechanism then calculates weights for each expert's score, and the final score is a weighted average of these expert scores.

A key aspect of their approach is its symmetry. Both the localized experts and the gating mechanism are designed to be symmetric with respect to the input word pair, meaning the order of words doesn't affect the outcome. This is a deliberate choice to align with the symmetric nature of synonymy and antonymy relationships, unlike some other methods that might implicitly assume asymmetry.

Datasets

The authors evaluate their model on a dataset previously created from WordNet and Wordnik, which contains word pairs of antonyms and synonyms grouped by part of speech (Adjective, Noun, Verb). The dataset is split into training, validation, and testing sets, with a 1:1 ratio of antonyms to synonyms within each group. They also perform experiments on "lexical-split" datasets to mitigate potential biases from lexical memorization, ensuring zero lexical overlap between training and testing sets.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Divide and Conquer for Semantics: The MoE approach effectively breaks down the complex task of antonym-synonym discrimination into manageable, specialized sub-problems. This "divide and conquer" strategy proves more effective than a single, monolithic model trying to grasp all semantic nuances at once.
  • Salient Dimensions are Key: The hypothesis that antonyms differ in only a few "salient" dimensions is strongly supported by their findings. The model achieves peak performance when using only a small number of these distilled dimensions (specifically, du=4).
  • Dynamic Expert Weighting: The gating mechanism's ability to dynamically weigh the contributions of different experts based on the input word pair is crucial. This allows the model to adapt its strategy for different types of word pairs.
  • Symmetry Matters: Explicitly enforcing symmetry in the model architecture aligns well with the inherent symmetric nature of synonymy and antonymy, distinguishing it from other state-of-the-art methods.

Key Results

The MoE-ASD model consistently outperforms existing state-of-the-art methods across Adjective, Noun, and Verb categories, achieving high F1 scores. For instance, on the vanilla word embeddings evaluation (Table 2), their model achieves an F1 score of 0.892 for Adjectives, 0.809 for Verbs, and 0.869 for Nouns. When using dLCE embeddings (Table 3), they also show superior performance. The ablation studies (Table 4) reveal that all the proposed features (prefix, cosine similarity, absolute difference, sum) contribute to the model's performance, with different parts of speech showing varying sensitivities to each feature.

Limitations and Future Work

The authors acknowledge that the performance on Noun classes is relatively lower compared to Verbs and Adjectives. They hypothesize this might be due to the greater prevalence of polysemy (words having multiple meanings) among nouns, which complicates semantic distinction.

Future work could explore further optimization of the number of experts and salient dimensions. The paper also suggests that the observed differences in feature sensitivity across parts of speech warrant further investigation. Additionally, while their model shows strong performance, the paper mentions that existing ASD methods using dLCE embeddings sometimes achieve better results, though this might be due to overfitting. Further research could explore how to leverage such contextualized embeddings more effectively without succumbing to overfitting.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@inproceedings{xie2021mixture,
  author = {Zhipeng Xie and Nan Zeng},
  title = {{A Mixture-of-Experts Model for Antonym-Synonym Discrimination}},
  booktitle = {Annual Meeting of the Association for Computational Linguistics},
  year = {2021},
  url = {https://openreview.net/forum?id=ACfaeiS0xT},
}
Figure