A mimetic approach to social influence on Instagram

Hubert Etienne, François ChartonarXiv 2023 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

Traditional social media research often focuses on marketing metrics, overlooking the deeper psychological structures of digital influence. This study bridges that gap by applying René Girard’s mimetic theory and Marshall McLuhan’s media theory to Instagram. By analyzing influencer-follower dynamics as a "communication system," the authors reveal how status is maintained through strategic non-reciprocity and specific "reading contracts." Using a "computational philosophy" approach, the research identifies distinct influencer classes and content typologies that drive social comparison and mimicry.

The Problem: Beyond Marketing Metrics

While influencers wield significant political and economic power, academic research frequently remains siloed within marketing, focusing on brand-audience matching. This leaves the psychological mechanisms of influence largely unexamined. The authors argue that metrics like follower counts fail to capture the dynamic, often asymmetric, relationship between creators and their communities. They ask: How does digitalization reshape human behaviors like social comparison and reciprocity?

Methodology: Computational Philosophy

To analyze these dynamics, the researchers developed two original labeling frameworks:

  1. Classification of Influencers per Fame (CIF): Categorizes influencers by the origin of their fame (Organic vs. External) and the type of fame (Person-based vs. Activity-based).
  2. Typology of Influencer Posts (TIP): A three-level system labeling content by its Pictorial (who is shown), Emotional (the "vibe"), and Communicational (message structure) attributes.
Table 1: Classification of Influencers per Fame (CIF) framework.

Key Insights: Mimetic Strategies and the "Coquette"

Drawing on Girardian theory, the authors identify several key strategies used by influencers to manage their status:

  • The "Coquette" Strategy: Influencers (particularly in Classes 1 and 4) often adopt a stance of feigned indifference. By posting "closed" content and following few people, they signal a self-sufficiency that paradoxically increases their desirability to followers.
  • "Shifters" vs. "Keepers": Influencers often face a "double bind" as they grow. "Shifters" successfully transition from activity-based content (e.g., professional skills) to person-based content (private life) to achieve "World Star" status. "Keepers" remain in their niche, maintaining their original contract but often limiting their growth potential.
  • Strategic Non-Reciprocity: On Instagram, a lack of direct interaction is not a failure but a signal of prestige. Followers continue to engage in the hope of receiving a rare "tribute" (e.g., a thank-you post), which triggers massive engagement spikes.

Key Results: Generational Mirroring and Engagement

The study utilized two datasets: S0 (619 accounts for demographic analysis) and S1 (2,142 posts for engagement analysis).

One of the most striking findings is the "Generational Mirroring" effect. The data shows that influence is strongest among peers; approximately two-thirds of followers are within 10 years of the influencer's age.

Figure 1: Age distribution of influencers and age difference between influencers and their followers across the six CIF classes.

Other key results include:

  • Gendered Influence: Person-based influencers (Classes 1 and 4) are predominantly female and followed by women, while activity-based influence often mirrors the gender distribution of the activity itself.
  • Engagement Penalties: Direct calls to action, such as "recommendations" or "charity" posts, often see lower engagement. Followers prefer to mimic an influencer's desires organically rather than being explicitly directed.
  • The Power of Contests: Contests generate roughly 30 times more comments than standard posts by internalizing the brand relationship into the influencer-follower bond.

Conclusion and Future Work

The study highlights the "degree of personification" as a critical factor in maintaining the influencer-follower contract. While limited by a Western-centric sample (US, UK, France) and a cross-sectional snapshot, the work paves the way for longitudinal studies on how influencers navigate "contract breaches" and scandals. Future research could use these frameworks to predict when an influencer's status is at risk of permanent damage.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@misc{etienne2023mimetic,
  author = {Hubert Etienne and François Charton},
  title = {{A mimetic approach to social influence on Instagram}},
  year = {2023},
  eprint = {2305.04985},
  archivePrefix = {arXiv},
  url = {https://arxiv.org/abs/2305.04985},
}
Figure