A Method for Estimating Urban Flood-Carrying Capacity Using the VIS-W Underlying Surface Model: A Case Study from Wuhan, China

Hongping Zhang, Xinwen Cheng, Jin Lei, Dong Zhao, Tianjing Feng, Kun ZhengWater 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel method to estimate urban flood-carrying capacity by integrating underlying surface characteristics (VIS-W model) with hydrological and terrain data. Applied to Wuhan, China, the method successfully correlates estimated capacity with observed waterlogging points, suggesting its utility for urban flood risk management and mitigation strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Urban flooding is a growing concern, particularly in rapidly developing regions like China, where increased impervious surfaces and altered hydrology exacerbate flood risks. While existing research focuses on flood forecasting and simulation, there's a need for a more comprehensive approach to assess an urban area's inherent capacity to withstand and manage floodwaters. This paper aims to fill this gap by developing a method to estimate urban flood-carrying capacity, considering not just rainfall-runoff dynamics but also the integrated storage and drainage potential of the natural water system within the urban landscape. The study specifically addresses the challenge of quantifying this capacity in a way that can inform practical flood control and management decisions.

Methods

The core of the proposed method involves extending the traditional Vegetation-Impervious Surface-Soil (VIS) model to a Vegetation-Impervious Surface-Soil and Water (VIS-W) model. This extension explicitly incorporates water bodies (rivers, lakes, ponds) as crucial components of the urban hydrological system. The process then involves:

  1. Watershed Delimitation: Using a Digital Elevation Model (DEM), the study area (Wuhan) is divided into sub-watersheds, which serve as the basic units for analysis.
  2. Natural Water System Estimation: The storage capacity of rivers, lakes, and puddles within each sub-watershed is quantified. This involves specific calculations for river storage (based on water level limitations), lake storage (considering normal, pre-pumping, and expansion scenarios), and puddle/pond storage (based on typical sizes and a default water level increase).
  3. Rainfall-Runoff Modeling: A hydrological rainfall-runoff model, utilizing the integrated runoff coefficient derived from the VIS-W model, is employed to estimate the rainwater budget.
  4. Four Basic Abilities Assessment: The flood-carrying capacity is then assessed based on four key abilities:
  5. Rainwater-storing ability: Determined by precipitation intensity over a 6-hour duration.
  6. Rainwater-receiving ability: Estimated by return period interval of 12-hour duration and stream level.
  7. Self-discharging potential: Assessed based on the rainwater flow path and the location of the main outlet (Yangtze River/Han River).
  8. Pumping outward emergency: Evaluated using factors like the amount of low-lying areas and the proximity to outlets.
  9. Final Flood-Carrying Capacity Derivation: The overall flood-carrying capacity is derived by combining these four abilities, categorized into "weak," "normal," and "strong" levels.

Datasets

The study utilized several datasets:

  • District Dataset: Hubei province administrative division data (2016 edition) for Wuhan's boundaries.
  • DEM Dataset: ASTGTM2 2009 dataset from the USGS (30m resolution) for terrain analysis.
  • Land Use Type Information: Remote sensing images from Chinese satellites Gaofen No. one (GF-1) and Gaofen No. two (GF-2) from 2015-2016.
  • Meteorological Data: Daily precipitation, evaporation, and temperature data from the Hubei Meteorological Bureau.
  • Waterlogging Points: Data collected from the Wuhan flood control office for the June 30-July 6, 2016 flood event.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • VIS-W Model's Importance: Explicitly incorporating water bodies into the VIS model (creating VIS-W) is crucial for accurately assessing urban flood capacity, as natural water systems play a significant role in storage and drainage.
  • Multi-faceted Capacity Assessment: Moving beyond simple rainfall-runoff, the four-ability framework (storing, receiving, discharging, pumping emergency) provides a more nuanced understanding of an urban area's resilience.
  • Upstream Dominance of Waterlogging: The finding that 99% of waterlogging points are located upstream highlights the critical role of upstream sub-catchments in contributing to downstream flood issues.
  • Correlation with Waterlogging: A strong correlation was found between lower flood-carrying capacity (weak/normal) and the occurrence of waterlogging points, validating the model's predictive power.
  • Natural Water System Potential: The study suggests that Wuhan has significant untapped potential in its natural water system for flood mitigation, emphasizing the need for better integration of these natural assets into urban drainage strategies.

Key Results

  • The proposed VIS-W model and assessment method were applied to Wuhan's downtown area.
  • An analysis of the July 2016 flood event revealed that 84% of waterlogging points occurred in sub-watersheds classified as "weak" or "normal" in flood-carrying capacity.
  • Conversely, only 16% of waterlogging points were found in "strong" capacity areas.
  • The study found that 99% of waterlogging points were located upstream, based on DEM-derived stream networks.
  • The model successfully identified sub-catchments with overloaded storage capacities during the waterlogging event.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Data Granularity: While the study uses DEM data, finer resolution terrain data could potentially improve watershed delimitation and slope analysis.
  • Model Simplifications: The paper acknowledges that the VIS-W model is a simplification of complex urban hydrological processes.
  • Future Research Directions: The authors suggest future work should focus on:
  • Analyzing the potential for regulating natural water systems in urbanized catchments.
  • Simulating rainfall scenarios using 1D or 2D hydrodynamic models and overlaying them with the current analysis to better understand drainage performance.

Summary updated

Abstract

In 2016, 192 cities, including Wuhan, Nanjing, and Jiujiang, suffered from severe flooding, which raised social and government concerns in China. This paper proposes a method based on the underlying surface to estimate the urban flood-carrying capacity. First, water is extended into the underlying surface vegetation-impervious surface-soil (VIS) model to form the vegetation-impervious surface-soil and water (VIS-W) model. Second, the watershed is delimitated using a digital elevation model (DEM). Third, the natural water system’s storage capacity, including rivers, lakes, and puddles, is estimated. Using the rainfall–runoff hydrology model and the VIS-W model, the storing ability, the receiving ability, the discharge potential, and the emergency of pumping outward are assessed to derive the final flood-carrying capacity. Finally, the result is compared with data on the waterlogging points collected in July 2016 during a flood and waterlogging event in Wuhan. It is found that 84% of waterlogging points are located in the “weak” or “normal” areas, and 16% are located in the “strong” areas. Additionally, 99% of total waterlogging points are located upstream, based on the stream extracted by the DEM. This phenomenon indicates that Wuhan can mitigate flood disasters by fully utilizing the natural water system storage capacity to corporate the city’s drainage schedule.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhang2019method,
  author = {Hongping Zhang and Xinwen Cheng and Jin Lei and Dong Zhao and Tianjing Feng and Kun Zheng},
  title = {{A Method for Estimating Urban Flood-Carrying Capacity Using the VIS-W Underlying Surface Model: A Case Study from Wuhan, China}},
  booktitle = {Water},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.3390/w11112345},
}
Figure