A Metagenomic Investigation of Potential Health Risks and Element Cycling Functions of Bacteria and Viruses in Wastewater Treatment Plants

Haozhe Zhao, Yang Mingfei, Xiang Fan, Qian Gui, Hao Yi, Yigang Tong, Wei XiaoViruses 2024 · DOI

TL;DR

This study uses metagenomics to analyze the bacteria and viruses in wastewater treatment plant sludge, revealing a significant presence of pathogenic bacteria and viruses, along with genes conferring antibiotic resistance and virulence. The findings highlight potential public health risks associated with wastewater sludge and underscore the crucial, yet often overlooked, role of viruses in element cycling within these environments.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Wastewater treatment plants (WWTPs) are known to concentrate viruses at levels far exceeding natural environments, raising concerns about potential human and animal health risks. While research has focused on bacterial pathogens and their roles in WWTPs, the viral communities (viromes) and their contributions to both health risks and essential biogeochemical cycles (like carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus) remain poorly understood. Specifically, the paper aims to:

  • Characterize the pathogenic bacterial and viral composition in WWTP sludge.
  • Identify and quantify genes associated with antibiotic resistance, virulence, and toxins within the viral communities.
  • Investigate the functional roles of viruses in element cycling through auxiliary metabolic genes (AMGs).
  • Assess the potential public health implications of these findings, particularly concerning wastewater reuse.

Methods

The researchers employed a comprehensive metagenomic approach:

  • Sample Collection: Activated sludge samples were collected from two WWTPs on a university campus.
  • DNA Extraction: Separate DNA extraction protocols were used for prokaryotes and viruses. Prokaryotic DNA was extracted using a kit, while viral DNA was concentrated and purified using a phenol-chloroform method.
  • 16S rRNA Gene Amplicon Sequencing: This was used to characterize the bacterial community composition and identify pathogenic bacteria. Paired-end sequencing on an Illumina platform was followed by bioinformatic analysis using dada2 and the Silva database for ASV generation and classification. The Multiple Bacterial Pathogen Detection Pipeline (MBPD) was specifically used for identifying zoonotic pathogens.
  • Shotgun Metagenomic Sequencing (Virome): Viral DNA was sequenced on an Illumina PE150 platform. Clean reads were assembled into contigs using metaSPAdes.
  • Viral Contig Identification: Tools like VirSorter2 and CheckV were used to identify and filter viral contigs, followed by dereplication with CD-HIT-est.
  • Viral Annotation and Host Prediction: Kraken2 was used for taxonomic annotation of viral sequences, with Bracken for abundance estimation. The Virus-Host DB was used to identify human-infecting viruses. Phage lifestyles were predicted using PhaTYP, and host prediction was performed using CHERRY.
  • Functional Gene Prediction: Prokka was used for gene prediction. Carbohydrate-active enzymes were annotated using dbCAN2. Nitrogen and phosphorus metabolism genes were identified by comparing sequences to the NCycDB and PCycDB databases. PathoFact was employed to predict antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), virulence factors, and toxin genes.

Datasets

The study utilized activated sludge samples from two wastewater treatment plants located on a university campus in China. No new benchmark datasets were introduced; rather, existing databases were used for annotation and classification (e.g., Silva 16S rRNA database, Virus-Host DB, NCycDB, PCycDB, VFDB).

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Viruses as reservoirs of risk: The study strongly suggests that viral communities in WWTP sludge are not just passive passengers but active contributors to public health risks through the carriage of pathogenic genes.
  • Beyond bacteria: The viral contribution to element cycling: The research highlights that viruses possess a significant repertoire of auxiliary metabolic genes (AMGs) that actively participate in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycling, influencing the overall efficiency of wastewater treatment.
  • Dominance of lytic phages: The prevalence of lytic phages suggests a dynamic interaction with bacterial hosts, potentially influencing bacterial community structure and function.
  • Host specificity of phages: The identification of specific bacterial hosts for phages (e.g., Lactobacillus, Streptococcus, Staphylococcus) provides insights into the ecological interactions within the WWTP environment.
  • Potential for horizontal gene transfer: The presence of ARGs and virulence factors on viral genomes raises concerns about their potential transfer to other bacteria, contributing to the spread of antimicrobial resistance and pathogenicity.

Key Results

  • Pathogenic Bacteria: 242 ASVs (41.22% of total reads) were identified as pathogenic bacteria, with Arcobacter being the most dominant (6.79% of total reads).
  • Viral Composition: 613 viral genera were identified, with Aorunvirus being the most abundant (41.85%).
  • Human/Animal Pathogenic Viruses: Approximately 0.66% of the virome was associated with human and animal diseases, with Orthoherpesviridae and Poxviridae being notable families.
  • Phage Lifestyle: Over 60% of the virome consisted of lytic phages.
  • Viral Host Prediction: Phages primarily infected Lactobacillus (37.11%), Streptococcus (21.11%), and Staphylococcus (7.11%).
  • Auxiliary Metabolic Genes (AMGs): A significant abundance of AMGs involved in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycling was detected within the virome.
  • Antibiotic Resistance Genes (ARGs): A total of 113 ARGs were detected, covering major antibiotic classes.
  • Virulence Factors and Toxin Genes: The clpP gene was a prominent virulence factor (4.78%), and the RecT gene was the most abundant toxin gene (73.48%).

Limitations and Future Work

  • Host Prediction Limitations: While host prediction was performed, the paper notes that many viral sequences had low annotation scores, suggesting the presence of novel viruses not yet characterized in existing databases. This implies that current host prediction models may have limitations for novel viral discovery.
  • Functional Interpretation: While AMGs were identified, their precise impact on specific biogeochemical processes within the WWTP environment requires further in-depth investigation.
  • Wastewater Reuse Implications: The study raises concerns about the safety of reclaimed water, suggesting that future work should focus on developing strategies to mitigate these risks and enhance the efficiency of wastewater treatment and resource utilization.
  • Broader Environmental Context: While this study focused on campus WWTPs, future research could explore variations in viral communities and their associated risks across different types of WWTPs and geographical locations.
  • Interactions between Bacteria and Viruses: Further research could delve deeper into the complex interplay between pathogenic bacteria and viruses, and how their co-occurrence influences overall health risks and treatment efficacy.

Summary updated

Abstract

The concentration of viruses in sewage sludge is significantly higher (10-1000-fold) than that found in natural environments, posing a potential risk for human and animal health. However, the composition of these viruses and their role in the transfer of pathogenic factors, as well as their role in the carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycles remain poorly understood. In this study, we employed a shotgun metagenomic approach to investigate the pathogenic bacteria and viral composition and function in two wastewater treatment plants located on a campus. Our analysis revealed the presence of 1334 amplicon sequence variants (ASVs) across six sludge samples, with 242 ASVs (41.22% of total reads) identified as pathogenic bacteria. <i>Arcobacter</i> was found to be the most dominant pathogen accounting for 6.79% of total reads. The virome analysis identified 613 viral genera with <i>Aorunvirus</i> being the most abundant genus at 41.85%. Approximately 0.66% of these viruses were associated with human and animal diseases. More than 60% of the virome consisted of lytic phages. Host prediction analysis revealed that the phages primarily infected <i>Lactobacillus</i> (37.11%), <i>Streptococcus</i> (21.11%), and <i>Staphylococcus</i> (7.11%). Furthermore, our investigation revealed an abundance of auxiliary metabolic genes (AMGs) involved in carbon, nitrogen, and phosphorus cycling within the virome. We also detected a total of 113 antibiotic resistance genes (ARGs), covering major classes of antibiotics across all samples analyzed. Additionally, our findings indicated the presence of virulence factors including the <i>clpP</i> gene accounting for approximately 4.78%, along with toxin genes such as the <i>RecT</i> gene representing approximately 73.48% of all detected virulence factors and toxin genes among all samples analyzed. This study expands our understanding regarding both pathogenic bacteria and viruses present within sewage sludge while providing valuable insights into their ecological functions.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{zhao2024metagenomic,
  author = {Haozhe Zhao and Yang Mingfei and Xiang Fan and Qian Gui and Hao Yi and Yigang Tong and Wei Xiao},
  title = {{A Metagenomic Investigation of Potential Health Risks and Element Cycling Functions of Bacteria and Viruses in Wastewater Treatment Plants}},
  booktitle = {Viruses},
  year = {2024},
  doi = {10.3390/v16040535},
}
Figure