A metagene of NRF2 expression is a prognostic biomarker in all stage colorectal cancer

Séan M. O’Cathail, Chieh‐Hsi Wu, Annabelle Lewis, Chris Holmes, M. Hawkins, Tim MaughanbioRxiv 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

Researchers have developed a new "NRF2 metagene" that acts as a powerful prognostic biomarker for colorectal cancer (CRC) across all stages. This metagene, derived from the expression of 36 specific genes, can predict patient survival outcomes, offering a novel tool for personalized treatment strategies.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Colorectal cancer (CRC) is a complex disease with varying prognoses. While NRF2 overexpression is known to be linked to poor outcomes in some cancers, its specific role and prognostic value in CRC have remained unclear. The challenge lies in identifying reliable biomarkers that can accurately predict patient survival and guide treatment decisions. Current prognostic factors, such as tumor stage, sidedness, and genetic mutations, provide some insight, but a more comprehensive approach is needed to capture the heterogeneity of CRC. The authors hypothesize that a "metagene" – a composite measure of genes regulated by NRF2 – could better represent the overall pathway activity and serve as a more robust prognostic marker.

Methods

The study employed a multi-step approach to develop and validate the NRF2 metagene:

  • Candidate Gene Selection: Genes known to be regulated by NRF2 were identified from existing lung cancer signatures and refined using the Oncomine database for differential expression in colorectal cancer.
  • Metagene Derivation (Training Set): Principal Component Analysis (PCA) was applied to the expression data of these candidate genes. PCA is a dimensionality reduction technique that identifies the principal components (PCs) that explain the most variance in the data. The top PCs were selected to represent the NRF2 pathway.
  • Variable Selection: Supervised variable selection methods (AIC and BIC) were used to determine the most predictive PCs for prognosis.
  • Metagene Construction: The NRF2 metagene was constructed as a weighted average of the expression of genes most strongly correlated with the selected predictive PCs.
  • Validation: The derived NRF2 metagene was validated in four independent datasets. Cox proportional hazard models were used to assess the association between NRF2 metagene expression and patient survival outcomes (Disease-Free Survival - DFS, and Overall Survival - OS). Multivariate analyses were performed to adjust for known prognostic factors.

Datasets

The study utilized several publicly available datasets for training and validation:

  • Training Set: GSE17536
  • Validation Sets:
    • GSE14333 (Stage I-III disease)
    • GSE39582 (Stage I-III and Stage I-IV disease)
    • MRC FOCUS trial (Stage IV metastatic disease)
    • GSE87211 (Rectal cancer)

These datasets collectively included 1,360 patients, making this one of the largest validation analyses for a transcriptomic biomarker in CRC to date.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • NRF2 as a Prognostic Factor in CRC: The study definitively establishes NRF2 pathway activity as a significant predictor of poor prognosis in colorectal cancer, extending beyond its known role in other cancers.
  • The Power of the Metagene Approach: By aggregating the expression of multiple NRF2-regulated genes into a single "metagene," the researchers were able to capture a more comprehensive picture of pathway activation and its prognostic implications, overcoming the limitations of looking at individual genes.
  • NRF2 Enrichment in CMS4: The finding that high NRF2 expression is particularly enriched in Consensus Molecular Subtype 4 (CMS4) is significant. This suggests that NRF2 activation may contribute to the aggressive biological characteristics of CMS4 tumors and could refine our understanding of CRC molecular taxonomy.
  • Cross-Platform and Tissue Type Robustness: The prognostic effect of the NRF2 metagene was consistently observed across different RNA expression platforms and tissue types (fresh frozen and FFPE), highlighting its robustness.

Key Results

  • A 36-gene NRF2 metagene was identified as a prognostic biomarker.
  • High NRF2 metagene expression was significantly associated with worse DFS and OS in stage I-III CRC.
  • High NRF2 metagene expression was also associated with worse OS in stage IV CRC.
  • The prognostic significance of the NRF2 metagene remained independent of known prognostic factors, including stage, adjuvant chemotherapy, BRAF V600E mutation, and mismatch repair status.
  • In the MRC FOCUS trial, high NRF2 expression was associated with worse overall survival in stage IV metastatic patients.
  • In a rectal cancer-specific dataset (GSE87211), high NRF2 expression was associated with worse DFS.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Rectal Cancer Data: The amount of rectal tumor data was limited, and the effect appeared statistically less marked in the rectal-only dataset. However, the authors argue that colon and rectal cancers are molecularly similar and that accounting for sidedness and MSI did not diminish the prognostic significance of NRF2.
  • Alternative Gene Sets: The study used a 36-gene metagene, but NRF2 regulates a large number of genes. The authors acknowledge that an alternative set of NRF2 targets might better represent pathway expression in CRC.
  • Therapeutic Resistance: The difference in prognosis between high and low NRF2 expression could, in part, be due to therapeutic resistance, particularly to 5-fluorouracil. Further research is ongoing to quantify the effect of NRF2 expression on resistance to radiation and chemotherapy.
  • CMS Subtype Role: While NRF2 expression was enriched in CMS4, further study is warranted to understand the exact role of NRF2 in interacting with the current subtype annotations.
  • Diagnostic Tool Potential: The small number of genes required to quantify NRF2 metagene expression makes it a potential candidate for development as a rapid diagnostic tool. Its role as a canonical, cell-intrinsic pathway also makes it a relevant target for novel therapies.

Summary updated

Abstract

ABSTRACT Objective Nrf2 overexpression confers poor prognosis in some cancers but its role in colorectal cancer (CRC) is unknown. Due to its role as a transcription factor we hypothesise a metagene of NRF2 regulated genes could act as a prognostic biomarker in CRC. Design Using known NRF2 regulated genes, we defined an NRF2 metagene to represent the pathway expression using principal component analysis and Cox proportional hazard models. The NRF2 metagene was validated in four independent datasets, including the recently profiled MRC FOCUS randomised controlled trial. Results 36 genes comprised the final prognostic metagene in the training set. 1,360 patients were included in the validation analyses. High NRF2 metagene expression is associated with worse disease free survival (DFS) and overall survival (OS) outcomes in stage I/II/III disease and worse OS in stage IV disease. In multivariate analyses, NRF2 expression remained significant when adjusted for known prognostic factors of adjuvant chemotherapy and stage in stage I/II/III disease, as well as BRAF V600E mutation and sidedness in stage IV disease. NRF2 metagene expression exhibits variation within each of the Consensus Molecular Subtypes (CMS) but high expression is particularly enriched in CMS 4. Conclusion We demonstrate in a large scale analysis that NRF2 expression is a novel biomarker of poor prognosis across all stages of colorectal cancer. Higher expression observed in CMS 4 further refines the molecular taxonomy of colorectal cancer.
BibTeX
@misc{ocathail2019metagene,
  author = {Séan M. O’Cathail and Chieh‐Hsi Wu and Annabelle Lewis and Chris Holmes and M. Hawkins and Tim Maughan},
  title = {{A metagene of NRF2 expression is a prognostic biomarker in all stage colorectal cancer}},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1101/690974},
  howpublished = {bioRxiv},
}
Figure