Abstract
In recent years, 3D printing (3DP) has gained importance in various fields. This technology has numerous applications, particularly in medicine. This contribution provides an overview on the state of the art of 3DP in medicine and showcases its current use in different medical disciplines and for medical education. In this meta-review, we provide a detailed listing of systematic reviews on this topic as this technology has become increasingly applied in modern medicine. We identified 134 relevant systematic reviews on medical 3DP in the medical search engine PubMed until 2023. 3DP has applications in various medical specialties, but is mainly used in orthopedics, oral and maxillofacial surgery, dentistry, cardiology and neurosurgery. In surgical contexts, the adoption of 3DP contributes to a reduction in operation time, reduced blood loss, minimized fluoroscopy time and an overall improved surgical outcome. Nevertheless, the primary use of 3DP is observed in non-invasive applications, particularly in the creation of patient-specific models (PSM). These PSMs enhance the visualization of patients’ anatomy and pathology, thereby facilitating surgical planning and execution, medical education and patient counseling. The current significance of 3DP in medicine offers a compelling perspective on the potential for more individualized and personalized medical treatments in the future.
Introduction: Addressing Information Overload in Medical 3DP
The literature on medical 3D printing (3DP) has seen exponential growth, with over 30,000 articles currently indexed on PubMed. For clinicians, engineers, and hospital administrators, this volume of information presents a significant challenge. Discerning which applications are clinically proven, which materials are most effective, and whether the investment in 3DP hardware translates to improved patient outcomes or cost savings is increasingly difficult.
This paper addresses this "information overload" by performing a meta-review—a systematic review of existing systematic reviews. The authors aim to categorize the current state of the art, identify the most impacted medical specialties, and quantify the tangible benefits of 3DP technology.
Methods and Classification
The authors conducted a systematic search of PubMed for "3D printing," filtered for systematic reviews published up to early 2024. Following PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) guidelines, they narrowed an initial pool of 261 papers to a final set of 134 relevant systematic reviews.
A core contribution of this study is a novel classification system based on the degree of invasiveness, which helps organize the diverse applications of 3DP:
- Non-invasive: External models for planning or education (e.g., anatomical heart models).
- On-body: Devices in contact with skin (e.g., prosthetics or splints).
- Invasive non-permanent: Tools used during surgery but removed (e.g., surgical drill guides).
- Invasive permanent: Long-term implants (e.g., cranial plates or dental implants).
For each review, data were extracted regarding medical fields, materials (polymers, metals, ceramics, organics), costs, production time, and clinical outcomes.
Key Insights and Clinical Results
The meta-review highlights several critical trends and measurable benefits across medical disciplines:
Dominance of Orthopedics and OMFS
Orthopedics (n=34) and Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery (OMFS, n=12) are the clear leaders in 3DP adoption. These fields benefit most from the ability to translate complex 3D bone geometry into physical models or precise cutting guides.
Patient-Specific Models (PSMs)
The most widespread use of 3DP is for non-invasive PSMs rather than permanent implants. These models allow surgeons to "pre-play" a surgery, significantly reducing the cognitive load during the actual procedure and facilitating better patient counseling.
Measurable Surgical Efficiency
Across multiple reviews, 3DP was shown to reduce operation time by anywhere from 0.72 to 258 minutes. Significant reductions were also reported in intraoperative blood loss and fluoroscopy (X-ray) time, particularly in complex spinal and pelvic surgeries.
Economic and Material Trends
The review catalogs a vast array of materials beyond standard plastics, including Titanium, Cobalt-Chrome, Hydroxyapatite, and even "jellywax" for simulating soft tissue. Furthermore, while high-end industrial printers can cost $200,000, individual models can be produced for as little as $0.60, suggesting that low-cost, in-hospital 3DP labs are becoming increasingly viable.
Limitations and Future Directions
Despite the promising results, several gaps remain:
- Search Scope: By limiting the search to PubMed, technical engineering papers in non-medical databases may have been missed.
- Long-Term Data: There is a notable absence of long-term follow-up studies on the degradation and biological tolerability of 3D-printed permanent polymer implants.
- Standardization: There is a pressing need for standardized safety regulations and sterilization protocols, especially for "in-hospital" manufacturing.
- Evidence Quality: Many systematic reviews noted a lack of high-quality Randomized Controlled Trials (RCTs), suggesting a need for more rigorous clinical validation.
Future work should focus on integrating 3DP with technologies like Augmented Reality (AR) and developing more "bio-fidelic" materials that better mimic human tissue properties.
Summary updated