A matrix model for 2D quantum gravity defined by Causal dynamical triangulations

J. Ambjørn, R. Loll, Y. Watabiki, W. Westra, Stefan ZohrenPhysics 2008 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper establishes a crucial link between Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT), a promising approach to quantum gravity, and matrix models. The authors demonstrate that the complex Dyson-Schwinger equations governing the CDT string field theory can be precisely reproduced by a specific type of cubic matrix model, offering a powerful new tool for understanding 2D quantum gravity.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Quantum gravity, the quest to unify gravity with quantum mechanics, is notoriously difficult. Two-dimensional quantum gravity, while simpler, still presents significant challenges. Causal Dynamical Triangulations (CDT) has emerged as a compelling framework for studying 2D quantum gravity, particularly because it naturally incorporates causality and allows for topology changes in spacetime. Recently, a string field theory formulation of CDT was developed, but understanding its full implications and finding simpler calculational tools remained an open problem. Specifically, the authors sought to determine if this CDT string field theory could be represented by a matrix model, a well-established technique in 2D quantum gravity and string theory that often simplifies calculations through large-N expansions.

Methods

The core of this paper lies in demonstrating the equivalence between the Dyson-Schwinger equations derived from the CDT string field theory and those arising from a specific cubic matrix model.

  1. CDT String Field Theory: The authors build upon their previous work [11] which formulated a string field theory for CDT. This theory describes the causal propagation of spatial universes and allows for their merging and splitting, representing topology changes. The theory is characterized by a Hamiltonian that includes terms for universe propagation, splitting, and merging, with coupling constants that govern these processes.
  2. Dyson-Schwinger Equations: The dynamics of the CDT string field theory are encoded in its Dyson-Schwinger equations, which are derived from the time-independence of the theory's partition function. These equations are a set of integral equations that relate correlation functions (amplitudes) of the theory.
  3. Matrix Model: The paper proposes a specific cubic matrix model. Matrix models involve integrating over Hermitian matrices, and their properties are often studied through large-N expansions, where N is the size of the matrix. The authors focus on the loop equations and Dyson-Schwinger equations that arise from these matrix integrals.
  4. Equivalence Demonstration: The crucial step is showing that the Dyson-Schwinger equations derived from the CDT string field theory are identical to those obtained from the proposed cubic matrix model. This involves comparing the structure and content of these equations, particularly after introducing specific notations and expansions (like the Laplace transform and genus expansion).

Datasets

Not discussed in the paper.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Matrix Model Equivalence: The most significant insight is the direct correspondence between the CDT string field theory and a cubic matrix model. This is not just a formal similarity; the Dyson-Schwinger equations are shown to be identical.
  • No Special Double-Scaling Limit: Unlike traditional matrix models for 2D quantum gravity, where a specific "double-scaling limit" (fine-tuning of coupling constants) is needed to reach the continuum theory, this CDT matrix model formulation does not require such a fine-tuning. This suggests a more direct and robust connection to continuum quantum gravity.
  • Dijkgraaf-Vafa Connection: The identified matrix model also appears in the Dijkgraaf-Vafa correspondence, which relates matrix models to N=1 supersymmetric gauge theories. This connection is further strengthened by requiring the superpotential in that context to be "renormalizable," hinting at deeper underlying structures.
  • Representation of Original CDT: The result implies that the matrix model provides a representation of the original, strictly causal CDT formulation, which did not allow for topology change. This offers a way to study the simpler causal CDT model using the powerful tools of matrix models.

Key Results

The paper demonstrates that the Dyson-Schwinger equations for the CDT string field theory are precisely reproduced by a cubic matrix model. This is shown by comparing the structure of the equations derived from both frameworks. Specifically, the multi-loop correlators of the CDT string field theory, when expanded in terms of the genus of the worldsheet (analogous to the large-N expansion in matrix models), match the correlators of the matrix model. The paper explicitly derives and compares the first few Dyson-Schwinger equations for both approaches, confirming the equivalence.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Causality Violation in Matrix Model: The paper notes that the matrix model formulation, while reproducing the CDT string field theory, arises from a "generalized" (and therefore slightly causality-violating) geometry. The authors discuss how to recover the strictly causal CDT model by taking a specific limit (g → 0 and a specific shrinkage of the cut).
  • Virasoro Operators: The authors suggest that the existence of a matrix model description automatically implies the existence of Virasoro-like operators, which are related to reparametrizations of time in string theory. They propose that exploring this in the CDT context could lead to simpler and more transparent results than in non-critical string theory.
  • Further Analysis: The paper sets the stage for further analysis, including a deeper investigation into the Virasoro algebra and its implications for the CDT model, and potentially extending these findings to higher dimensions.

Summary updated

Abstract

A novel continuum theory of two-dimensional quantum gravity, based on a version of Causal Dynamical Triangulations which incorporates topology change, has recently been formulated as a genuine string field theory in zero-dimensional target space [J. Ambjørn, R. Loll, Y. Watabiki, W. Westra, S. Zohren, arXiv: 0802.0719]. Here we show that the Dyson–Schwinger equations of this string field theory are reproduced by a cubic matrix model. This matrix model also appears in the so-called Dijkgraaf–Vafa correspondence if the superpotential there is required to be renormalizable. In the spirit of this model, as well as the original large-N expansion by 't Hooft, we need no special double-scaling limit involving a fine tuning of coupling constants to obtain the continuum quantum-gravitational theory. Our result also implies a matrix model representation of the original, strictly causal quantum gravity model.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{ambjrn2008matrix,
  author = {J. Ambjørn and R. Loll and Y. Watabiki and W. Westra and Stefan Zohren},
  title = {{A matrix model for 2D quantum gravity defined by Causal dynamical triangulations}},
  booktitle = {Physics},
  year = {2008},
  doi = {10.1016/j.physletb.2008.06.026},
}
Figure