A Mass‐Spectrometry‐Based Approach to Distinguish Annular and Specific Lipid Binding to Membrane Proteins

Jani Reddy Bolla, Robin A. Corey, Cagla Sahin, Joseph Gault, Alissa M. Hummer, Jonathan T. S. Hopper, David P. Lane, David Drew, Timothy M. Allison, Phillip J. Stansfeld, Carol V. Robinson, Michael LandrehAngewandte 2019 · DOI

TL;DR

This paper introduces a novel mass spectrometry-based method to differentiate between transient, "annular" lipids that loosely associate with membrane proteins and tightly bound, "non-annular" lipids crucial for protein function. By observing how readily different lipids are displaced by detergents, the researchers can now probe specific lipid-protein interactions, offering a powerful new tool for understanding membrane protein behavior.

What Problem Does This Paper Address?

Membrane proteins are essential cellular machines embedded in lipid bilayers, and their function is intimately linked to the lipids surrounding them. However, distinguishing between the vast number of lipids that transiently interact with a protein (annular lipids) and the few that bind specifically and functionally (non-annular lipids) has been a major challenge. Annular lipids primarily serve to maintain the protein's folded state by providing a compatible environment, while non-annular lipids often play critical roles in stabilizing protein complexes, regulating activity, or acting as substrates. Traditional methods often disrupt these delicate interactions, making it difficult to study them in their native-like state. This paper aims to develop a method to specifically identify and characterize these non-annular lipids.

Methods

The core of this study relies on native mass spectrometry (nMS). This technique allows researchers to analyze intact protein complexes in the gas phase, preserving their non-covalent interactions, including lipid binding. The novel approach involves taking detergent-solubilized membrane proteins, which are often purified with associated lipids, and then exposing them to increasing concentrations of detergent.

The key idea is that detergents compete with lipids for binding sites on the protein. By monitoring the protein-lipid complexes using nMS as detergent concentration increases, the researchers can observe which lipids are displaced. Lipids that are easily displaced are considered "annular" and rapidly exchanging, while those that remain bound even at high detergent concentrations are inferred to be "non-annular" and specifically bound.

To complement the experimental nMS data, the researchers also employed coarse-grained molecular dynamics (CG-MD) simulations. These simulations were used to model the behavior of lipids around the proteins and to calculate lipid residency times and dissociation rates (k<sub>off</sub> values). This provided a theoretical basis for understanding the observed experimental differences in lipid exchange.

Datasets

The study utilized three distinct membrane protein systems:

  1. Presenilin homologue (PSH) from Methanoculleus marisnigri.
  2. Leucine transporter (LeuT) from Aquifex aeolicus.
  3. Lipid flippase (MurJ) from E. coli.

These proteins were studied in conjunction with various lipids, including E. coli polar lipids (phosphatidylethanolamines (PE), phosphatidylglycerols (PG), and cardiolipins (CDL)), and the natural substrate for MurJ, lipid-II. The study did not introduce new benchmark datasets but rather applied its methodology to well-characterized protein systems.

Key Insights and Ideas

  • Detergent Competition as a Lipid "Displacement Assay": The central innovation is using increasing detergent concentrations as a means to selectively "displace" and thus identify different classes of lipids bound to membrane proteins.
  • Annular Lipids are Readily Exchanged: For PSH, annular lipids were shown to be rapidly exchanged with detergent, with no preference for specific lipid types. This aligns with their proposed role in maintaining protein structure in a dynamic environment.
  • Non-Annular Lipids Show Detergent Resistance: Lipids bound at the dimer interface of LeuT exhibited significantly slower dissociation rates (lower k<sub>off</sub>) and longer residency times in MD simulations, indicating they are more resistant to detergent displacement.
  • Active Site Binding is Highly Protected: For MurJ, the natural substrate lipid-II formed a stable 1:1 complex that was resistant to detergent displacement, suggesting it binds within a protected active site. This contrasts with other lipids (like PE) that were readily exchanged.
  • MD Simulations Validate Experimental Observations: The CG-MD simulations provided crucial mechanistic insights, correlating slower k<sub>off</sub> values and longer residency times with specific, often interfacial, lipid binding sites.

Key Results

  • For PSH, increasing detergent (NG) concentration led to a stepwise removal of bound E. coli polar lipids, demonstrating the principle of detergent-driven lipid exchange.
  • In LeuT, while co-purified lipids were removed by detergent, those at the dimer interface showed significantly slower exchange rates compared to other sites, as evidenced by MD simulations (k<sub>off</sub> < 10 µs<sup>-1</sup> for interfacial CDL vs. > 31 µs<sup>-1</sup> for other sites).
  • MurJ formed a stable complex with its natural substrate, lipid-II, where the lipid-II adduct was largely unaffected by increasing detergent (OG) concentration, unlike other bound lipids.

Limitations and Future Work

  • Detergent Specificity: The paper notes that the efficiency of detergent-mediated delipidation can vary between protein systems, suggesting that the choice of detergent is critical and may require optimization for different targets.
  • MD Simulation Accuracy: While CG-MD simulations provided valuable insights, they are approximations of reality. The accuracy of the calculated k<sub>off</sub> values and residency times depends on the quality of the simulation parameters.
  • Future Work: The authors suggest that this MS-based strategy can be broadly applied to study lipid-protein interactions in various membrane protein systems. This could lead to a deeper understanding of how specific lipids modulate protein structure, function, and drug targeting. Further investigations could explore a wider range of detergents and lipid types, as well as more complex protein assemblies.

Summary updated

Abstract

Abstract Membrane proteins engage in a variety of contacts with their surrounding lipids, but distinguishing between specifically bound lipids, and non‐specific, annular interactions is a challenging problem. Applying native mass spectrometry to three membrane protein complexes with different lipid‐binding properties, we explore the ability of detergents to compete with lipids bound in different environments. We show that lipids in annular positions on the presenilin homologue protease are subject to constant exchange with detergent. By contrast, detergent‐resistant lipids bound at the dimer interface in the leucine transporter show decreased k off rates in molecular dynamics simulations. Turning to the lipid flippase MurJ, we find that addition of the natural substrate lipid‐II results in the formation of a 1:1 protein–lipid complex, where the lipid cannot be displaced by detergent from the highly protected active site. In summary, we distinguish annular from non‐annular lipids based on their exchange rates in solution.
BibTeX
@inproceedings{bolla2019massspectrometrybased,
  author = {Jani Reddy Bolla and Robin A. Corey and Cagla Sahin and Joseph Gault and Alissa M. Hummer and Jonathan T. S. Hopper and David P. Lane and David Drew and Timothy M. Allison and Phillip J. Stansfeld and Carol V. Robinson and Michael Landreh},
  title = {{A Mass‐Spectrometry‐Based Approach to Distinguish Annular and Specific Lipid Binding to Membrane Proteins}},
  booktitle = {Angewandte},
  year = {2019},
  doi = {10.1002/ange.201914411},
}
Figure