A Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of the CMSSM

Roberto Ruiz de Austri, Roberto Trotta, Leszek RoszkowskiJournal of High Energy Physics 2006 · DOI · arXiv

Abstract

This paper presents a comprehensive "weather map" of the Constrained Minimal Supersymmetric Standard Model (CMSSM) by replacing traditional, inefficient grid-based searches with Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) sampling. By applying Bayesian inference to a vast 8-dimensional parameter space, the authors provide the first comprehensive probability distributions for the masses of "superpartner" particles and dark matter candidates, predicting that the LHC has a high probability of discovering supersymmetry.

Introduction

Particle physicists have long sought to move beyond the Standard Model (SM) to solve major theoretical challenges, such as the "fine-tuning problem" regarding the Higgs mass stability and the nature of dark matter. Supersymmetry (SUSY) offers a compelling solution to both; however, even its constrained version (CMSSM) possesses a complex, multi-dimensional parameter space that is notoriously difficult to explore.

Historically, researchers relied on "fixed-grid scans," which are limited by the "curse of dimensionality" and often overlook narrow, high-probability regions. This study aims to provide a more rigorous, statistically sound map of the SUSY parameter space using advanced sampling techniques.

Methodology

The authors employ a Bayesian framework combined with a Markov Chain Monte Carlo (MCMC) algorithm, specifically the Metropolis algorithm. Unlike rigid grids, the MCMC "walks" through the parameter space, concentrating on regions with high posterior probability. This allows for the efficient exploration of an 8-dimensional space comprising four CMSSM parameters and four Standard Model "nuisance" parameters.

A key innovation is the treatment of Standard Model constants—such as the top quark mass and coupling constants—as variables with their own uncertainties. This ensures that experimental errors in the SM do not bias the SUSY predictions. The authors use Bayesian marginalization to project this complex 8D space onto interpretable 1D or 2D probability plots.

Table of CMSSM and Standard Model nuisance parameters and their explored ranges.

Experimental Constraints

The likelihood function is constructed using a diverse set of experimental constraints:

  • Cosmological Data: Dark matter relic density ($\Omega_{CDM}h^2$) from WMAP and other CMB observations.
  • Collider Data: Precision measurements from LEP and the Tevatron, including the $W$ boson mass, the effective leptonic weak mixing angle, and lower bounds on Higgs and superpartner masses.
  • B-Physics: Rare decays such as $BR(\bar{B} \to X_s \gamma)$ and $BR(B_s \to \mu^+ \mu^-)$.
  • Muon Anomalous Magnetic Moment: The $(g-2)_\mu$ discrepancy, which provides a strong hint of new physics.

Results and Discussion

The analysis reveals a significant tension between the $(g-2)_\mu$ measurement and other observables, where the posterior probability is "pulled" away from the value preferred by the anomaly. This suggests potential issues with either the model or the measurement.

The study highlights the importance of parameter space volume; Bayesian statistics naturally penalizes models requiring extreme fine-tuning by favoring regions with significant volume rather than isolated "spikes." Furthermore, the paper identifies a "Focus Point" region where dark matter is more detectable in direct experiments, contrasted with the "stau coannihilation" region, which is more favorable for LHC discovery.

Key results include:

  • Discovery Prospects: A 78% probability that the gluino mass is below 2.7 TeV and an 85% probability that certain squarks are below 2.5 TeV.
  • Parameter Intervals: 68% probability intervals were determined for $m_{1/2}$ (0.52 to 1.26 TeV) and $\tan \beta$ (38.5 to 54.6).
  • Dark Matter: The predicted spin-independent cross-section ($\sigma_p^{SI}$) is approximately $10^{-10}$ to $10^{-8}$ pb, placing it within reach of experiments like CDMS-II.

Conclusion

While the results are promising, the authors note several limitations. Theoretical uncertainties in calculating dark matter relic density can reach 100%, particularly in the "Focus Point" region. Additionally, some results, such as the mass of the scalar $m_0$, exhibit sensitivity to the "prior" (the initial assumed range, such as the 2 TeV vs. 4 TeV ranges shown in Figure 1). This sensitivity underscores the need for more precise data from the LHC to definitively constrain the model. Future work may involve exploring more complex SUSY models that offer different correlations between parameters.

Summary updated

BibTeX
@article{austri2006markov,
  author = {Roberto Ruiz de Austri and Roberto Trotta and Leszek Roszkowski},
  title = {{A Markov chain Monte Carlo analysis of the CMSSM}},
  journal = {Journal of High Energy Physics},
  year = {2006},
  doi = {10.1088/1126-6708/2006/05/002},
}
Figure